1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What was the Enlightenment or modernist view of the role of sociology held by early positivists such as Comte and Durkheim?
ā For early positivists, Comte (1798ā1857) and Durkheim (1858ā1917), creating a better society was not about subjective values or personal opinions on what was best.
ā They shared the Enlightenment or modernist view that sociology's job as the science of society was to discover the truth about how society works and uncover the laws governing its proper functioning.
ā Equipped with this scientific knowledge, social problems could be solved and human life improved.
What crucial role did Comte and Durkheim believe scientific sociology gave to sociologists regarding society's future?
ā Scientific sociology would reveal the one correct society, giving sociologists a crucial role.
ā By discovering the truth about how society worked, sociologists would be able to say objectively and with scientific certainty what was really best for society, thereby prescribing how things ought to be.
ā Comte regarded sociology as the 'queen of the sciences' and saw sociologists as latter-day priests of a new scientific religion of truth.
How did Karl Marx view his scientific approach and historical materialism in relation to the development of human society?
ā Although debated whether Marx was a positivist, he saw himself as a scientist and believed his method of historical analysis, historical materialism, could reveal the line of development of human society.
ā This development involved an evolution through a series of different types of class-based society, leading ultimately to a future classless communist society.
ā In this future communist society, exploitation, alienation, and poverty would end, and each individual would be free to achieve their true potential.
What was the role of Marx's sociology regarding the proletariat, and how did his view of science resemble that of Comte and Durkheim?
ā The role of Marx's sociology was to reveal the truth of societal development, especially to the proletariat, since they would be the class to overthrow capitalism and herald the birth of communist society.
ā Marx took for granted the value of the ideal communist society and argued that his scientific approach would show humanity how to reach it.
ā In this regard, Marx was similar to Comte and Durkheim because he saw science as helping to 'deliver' the good society.
How did Weber's view on the relationship between facts and values differ from earlier thinkers like Marx, Durkheim, and Comte?
ā Marx, Durkheim, and Comte made no distinction between the facts revealed by science and the values we should hold, believing that science could tell us what those values should be.
ā By contrast, Weber (1864ā1920) made a sharp distinction between value judgments and facts, arguing that we cannot logically derive the one from the other.
ā For example, research might show that divorcees are more likely to commit suicide, but this fact does not prove the value judgment that divorce should be made harder to obtain, as facts cannot logically compel us to accept any specific value.
What did Weber argue about whether values can be proved or disproved by facts, and what did he believe about the role of values in sociological research?
ā A value can be neither proved nor disproved by the facts because facts and values belong to entirely different realms.
ā However, despite making a sharp distinction between facts and values, Weber still saw an essential role for values in sociological research, dividing his views into four distinct stages of the research process.
Why does Weber argue that values are necessary as a guide to research when selecting facts to study?
ā Social reality is made up of a 'meaningless infinity' of facts, making it impossible to study in its totality, so researchers must select certain facts to study.
ā We choose which facts to study based on what we regard as important according to our own values, known as 'value relevance'.
ā Values are essential in enabling us to select which aspects of reality to study and in developing concepts to understand them.
ā For example, feminists value gender equality, leading them to study women's oppression and develop concepts like patriarchy to understand it.
What role do values play during the data collection and hypothesis testing stages of research according to Weber?
ā While values are essential in selecting what to study, Weber argues we must be as objective and unbiased as possible when actually collecting facts, keeping our values and prejudices out of the process.
ā For example, we should not ask leading questions designed to give the answers we want to hear, but should instead aim to get respondents to give their own views.
ā Once facts are gathered, they are used to test a hypothesis, which must stand or fall solely on whether or not it fits the observed facts without value interference.
How does Weber reconcile his view that values guide research selection with his insistence on objectivity during data gathering?
ā Weber resolves this by restricting values to the initial phase of topic selection and conceptualisation (value relevance).
ā During the active gathering of data and hypothesis testing, the researcher must maintain strict neutrality, ensuring hypotheses are judged solely by empirical observation rather than personal desires.
Why do values become important again during the interpretation of data, and what does Weber suggest researchers must do about this?
ā Values become important during data interpretation because facts need to be set within a theoretical framework to understand their significance and draw conclusions from them.
ā Our choice of theoretical framework or perspective is influenced by our values.
ā Therefore, we must be explicit about our values, spelling them out so that others can check for unconscious bias in our interpretation of the data.
Why does Weber reject the view that sociologists and scientists should ignore the uses to which their research findings are put?
ā Research findings often have very real effects on people's lives, but scientists sometimes hide behind 'objectivity' or 'value freedom' to avoid the moral and political issues their work raises.
ā Weber argues that sociologists are human beings and citizens, and they must not dodge moral responsibility for the harm their research may cause.
ā For example, Einstein's scientific theories helped make the atomic bomb possible, yet he subsequently spoke out against nuclear weapons.
According to Weber's summary, in what three stages of research are values relevant, and in what stage must they be strictly kept out?
ā Values are relevant to the sociologist in:
1. Choosing what to research (value relevance).
2. Interpreting the data collected.
3. Deciding the use to which the findings should be put.
ā By contrast, the sociologist's values must be kept out of the actual process of fact gathering and hypothesis testing.
What contrast exists between modern positivists and sociologists from Marxist, interactionist, and feminist perspectives regarding value commitment in research?
ā Some modern positivists have shied away from any value commitments, attempting to maintain absolute neutrality.
ā By contrast, Marxists, interactionists, and feminists have argued for a 'committed sociology' in which the sociologist explicitly spells out the importance of their values to their research.
Why did mid-20th-century positivists argue that their values were irrelevant to their research in their desire to appear scientific?
ā Unlike Comte and Durkheim, mid-20th-century positivists argued that science is concerned with matters of fact, not value, focusing on 'is' questions rather than 'ought' questions.
ā Therefore, they believed sociologists should remain morally neutral, with their job being simply to establish the truth about people's behaviour rather than judge it.
ā Critics argue this reflected a desire to make sociology respectable, as science had high prestige in modern society and mimicking its ways raised the discipline's status and academic respectability when it was newly established.
What does Gouldner (1975) argue regarding the social position of American sociologists by the 1950s and why they abandoned their values?
ā Gouldner argues that by the 1950s, American sociologists had become 'spiritless technicians' rather than critical voices challenging authority.
ā Instead of being 'problem makers' who defined their own research, they became 'problem takers' hired out to organisations like business and the military to solve their problems.
ā By leaving their values behind, sociologists made a 'gentleman's promise' not to rock the boat by criticising their paymasters, rendering their own values irrelevant as mere hired hands.
What does Myrdal (1969) argue regarding committed sociology and taking sides in research?
ā Gunnar Myrdal argues that sociologists should not only spell out their values, as Weber recommends, but should also openly 'take sides' by espousing the values and interests of particular individuals or groups.
ā Proponents of committed sociology argue that it is neither possible nor desirable to keep values out of research.
According to Gouldner, why is a value-free sociology both 'impossible' and 'undesirable'?
ā Value-free sociology is impossible because either the sociologist's own values, or those of their paymasters, are bound to be reflected in their work.
ā It is undesirable because without values to guide research, sociologists are merely selling their services to the highest bidder.
ā Gouldner illustrates this by noting that without moral values, there is no ethical reason why a sociologist cannot sell their knowledge to spread a disease just as freely as fight it, such as conducting market research to sell cigarettes despite knowing cancer risks.
What does Becker (1970) argue in his classic question 'Whose side are we on?', and why does he advocate siding with the 'underdogs'?
ā Becker argues that values are always present in sociology, meaning sociologists must inevitably take sides, and by not choosing, they default to taking the side of the more powerful.
ā Traditionally, positivists and functionalists have taken the viewpoint of powerful groups ('overdogs' like police and psychiatrists).
ā Becker argues sociologists should adopt a compassionate stance and take the side of the powerless ('underdogs' like criminals and mental patients) because less is known about them, and giving them a voice redresses the balance and reveals a hidden side of social reality.
How does Goffman (1968) support Becker's view, and what methodology do interactionists favour for this approach?
ā Goffman argues that to describe the situation of a mental patient faithfully, we have to take their side, meaning we must be biased in favour of the patient and against the psychiatrist to show the hidden rationality of their behaviour.
ā This emphasis on identifying with the powerless is linked to interactionist preferences for qualitative methods, such as participant observation, to reveal the true meanings of 'outsiders'.
How does Gouldner criticise Becker's approach from a Marxist perspective, and what does he argue sociologists should do instead?
ā Gouldner criticises Becker for taking a romantic and sentimental approach to disadvantaged groups, accusing him of focusing only on those who are 'on their backs' (the misunderstood or negatively labelled deviants).
ā Instead, adopting a Marxist perspective, Gouldner argues that sociologists should take the side of those who are 'fighting back' (political radicals struggling to change society).
ā He argues sociology should not just describe the underdog's viewpoint, but be committed to ending their oppression by unmasking the ways the powerful maintain their position.
How do external funding bodies influence sociological research, and what risks do researchers face regarding their findings?
ā Most sociological research is funded by outside bodies like government departments, businesses, and voluntary organisations.
ā The paying body often controls the research direction, the questions asked, and the questions left unasked, ensuring the work embodies the values and interests of its paymasters.
ā Funding bodies may also block the publication of research if the findings prove unacceptable to them.
How can personal career ambitions and institutional pressures influence a sociologist's work, and what is Gouldner's overall conclusion on values?
ā Sociologists may choose fashionable topics, shape research questions, and interpret findings to further their careers and reputations.
ā Researchers may self-censor out of fear that being too outspoken will harm career prospects or cost them their jobs, while university academics face pressures to publish regardless of quality.
ā For Gouldner, all research is inevitably influenced by values, whether belonging to the sociologist or to the funding body paying for the work.
How do different sociological perspectives like Feminism, Functionalism, and Marxism embody distinct assumptions, values, and research conclusions?
ā Feminism sees society as based on gender inequality and promotes women's rights; functionalism sees society as harmonious and espouses conservative values favouring the status quo; Marxism sees society as conflict-ridden and strives for a classless society.
ā These assumptions and values influence the topics sociologists choose to research, the concepts they develop, and the conclusions they reach.
ā For example, functionalists have concluded that inequality is beneficial for society, whereas Marxists conclude that it produces exploitation of the poor by the rich.
What link exists between sociologists' methods and their value-stance, and what critique is made regarding methods and value outlooks?
ā There is a direct link between sociologists' methods and their value-stance.
ā For example, interactionists' preference for qualitative methods fits with their desire to empathise with the underdog because such methods give access to actor meanings.
ā Likewise, functionalist and positivist tendencies to take the side of the establishment fit with their uncritical acceptance of official government statistics.
ā Consequently, both interactionists and functionalists can be accused of selecting methods that produce facts reflecting their underlying values and outlook.
What two main arguments does relativism make regarding differing views of truth across groups, cultures, and sociologists?
ā Different groups, cultures, and individuals (including sociologists) have different views on what is true, each seeing the world through their own perspectives, concepts, values, and interests.
ā There is no independent or objective way of judging whether any single view is truer than any other.
How does relativism define truth, and what is its stance on absolute or objective truth versus plural truths?
ā Relativism argues that there is no absolute or objective truth, only truths in the plural.
ā What an individual believes is true is valid only for them (what you believe is true is true for you, and what I believe is true is true for me).
ā Consequently, relativism claims that if one person believes the earth is round and another believes it is flat, there is no objective way of determining who is right.
How do postmodernists view knowledge in sociology, and why do they reject perspectives like Marxism?
ā Postmodernists take a relativist view of knowledge, rejecting the idea that any single account of the social world is superior or has special access to the truth.
ā They argue that any perspective claiming to possess the truth, such as Marxism, is merely a 'meta-narrative' or 'big story'.
ā All knowledge from any perspective is based on underlying values and assumptions, meaning no perspective has a special claim to absolute truth.
What is the logical paradox of relativism, and how do practical sociologists resolve the tension between values and objective reality?
ā Relativism is self-defeating because it claims to be telling us something true while simultaneously asserting that no one can tell us what is true (meaning we shouldn't believe postmodernism either).
ā In practice, sociologists rarely go this far because a real factual world exists 'out there' (e.g., women doing more housework or ethnicity affecting life chances) which can be observed and recorded regardless of values.
ā Established facts can be used to judge competing theories, meaning it matters less whether a theory contains values than whether it can actually explain the observed world.