1/44
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Contract Clause
located in article 1 section 10 prevents STATES from passing laws impairing the obligation of contracts
contract clause designed to protect business
dormant commerce clause
a judicial doctrine that invalidates state laws burdening interstate commerce even in the absence of any conflicting federal law
comes from shreveport doctrine
Fletcher V Peck (1810)
case involves 1795 sales of land by the states of Georgia to a group of investors who bribed the state legislature to greatly reduce the sale of the land
new Georgia legislature passed a 1796 act that rescinded the original land sale
fletcher said claiming the act meant that peck sold him land to which he did not have the legal title
Fletcher v Peck question
did the state of Georgia have the authority to invalidate the contract between peck and fletcher
fletcher v peck answer
ruled in favor of peck against the state of Georgia holding that the sate could dno鈥檛 invalidate the original land sale
land passed through a number of hands in good faith
no point in penalizing individuals who acted legally and in good faith
Trustees of Dartmouth College v Woodward (1819)
case involves the revocation of Dartmouths college鈥檚 1769 royal charter by the New Hampshire legislature
trustees sued the state asking to have the state charter revoked and the original royal charter restored
Trustees of Dartmouth College v Woodward question
could the state of New Hampshire replace the Dartmouth college charter
Trustees of Dartmouth College v Woodward answer
court says yes and restored Dartmouths royal charter
charters are contracts and protected from state action by the contract clause
therefore rechartering act of the college violated the contract
Decline of the Contract Clause
the ascendency of the Jacksonian democrats in 1828 significantly affected the policy preferences of the Supreme Court
Charles River Bridge v Warren Bridge (1837)
involves conflict over the right to operate bridge in between Boston and Charlestown MA
state granted warren bridge co a charter to build a second bridge this bridge would become public after six years and could be used toll free
Charles rover co sued claiming their 1875 charter gave them exclusive rights to operate between Boston and Charlestown
Charles River Bridge v Warren Bridge question
did MA violate its contract with the original bridge company by granting the warren bridge charter
CR bridge v Warren bridge answer
court ruled no holding that the CR bridge did not grant the company non exclusive rights to operate over the river
establishes that states cannot contract away their governmental functions
Stone v Mississippi (1880)
involves the Mississippi agriculture educational and manufacturing aid society charted by the state in 1867 to operate a lottery
1870 Mississippi legislature passed a law that outlawed lotteries
stone sued federal court claiming that the states anti lottery law violated the aid society鈥檚 charter to operate the lottery
stone v Mississippi question
was the mamas charter an irrevocable contact between the state and aid society
stone v Mississippi answer
court says no holding that the aid society鈥檚 charter to conduct a lottery of 25 years did not prevent the enforcement of the state鈥檚 anti lottery statue
court ruled that states could not bargain away their police powers
police powers
the power of the states to regular for health, safety, morals, general welfare of its citizens
reduced the importance of the contract clause
Home Building & Loan Association v Blaisdell (1934)
blaisdell sought and received a two year moratorium on the mortgage payments
mortgage company sued claiming that Minnesota mortgage moratorium act impaired their mortgage contract
HMLA v Blaisdell question
did the Minnesota moratorium act violate contract clause
HMLA v Blaisdell answers
yes holding that the economic emergent justified states exercise of expanded police powers into the area of mortgage foreclosure
when states must exercise emergency powers to impair contracts
a. in recognition of an emergency
b. must be for general welfare not individuals
c. contracts must be reasonably related to emergencies
d. changes must be reasonable
e. use of police powers must be limited to the duration of the emergency
United States Trust Company of NY v New Jersey (1977)
involves the port authority of NY and NJ acquisition of a railroad in 1962
the port authority was prohibited from using money that was reserved for revenue bond payments for the operation of the railroad
USTCNY v NJ question
did the 1974 acts of they ny and nj legislature which repealed the 1962 bond contracts violate the contract clause
USTCNY v NJ answer
courts says yes holding that the states could not void their bond payment contract
court limits the use of a states police power to abrogate contracts
prevents states from pulling contracts saying what they rather do instead of paying others their money back
Allied Strutural Steel Company v Spannaus (1978)
involves a conflict between allied co and the state of Minnesota over the company鈥檚 retirement pension obligations
Allied Strutural Steel Company v Spannaus Question
did the act unconstitutionally impair allied contractual relationship with its employees
Allied Strutural Steel Company v Spannaus answer
yes holding that the benefits protection act was an unconstitutional violation of the contract clause
was not a response to an emergency
not directed at the general welfare
was not limited in duration
Takings clause
last phrase in the 5th amendment
private property cannot be taken for public use without just compensation
eminent domain
authority of the government to take private properties for public purpose
selective incorporation
case by case method the Supreme Court has used to hold that certain rights in the bill of rights are part of due process of law and thus serve as limits on state powers through the due process clause of the 14th amendment
Barron v Mayor & City Council of Baltimore (1833)
involves a dispute between John Barron who owned a wharf in Baltimore
sued claiming that the wharf was destroyed by a city project that diverted streams away from a wharf making water too shallow for boats
Barron v Mayor & City Council of Baltimore question
did the takings clause apply to the states and by extension the city of Baltimore
Barron v Mayor & City Council of Baltimore answer
no they did not have to pay for damages to Barrons wharf
court held that the 5th amendment did not apply to the states because constitutions are created by governments and are meant to apply only to those specific governments
the protection in the bill of rights only apply to federal governments
Chicago Burlingtonn & Quincy Railroad v Chicago (1897)
sued city of Chicago for not providing just compensation for its land and that was taken under the principle of eminent domain
company used asking court to apply takings clause of 5th amendment through the 14th amendment due process clause
Chicago Burlingtonn & Quincy Railroad v Chicago answer
ruled the 14th amendment prevented states from taking property without providing just compensation..state violated due process clause when it did not give the railroad proper compensation for taking its land
due process
government procedures that follow principles of essential fairness
what exactly is a takings when does the gov have the right to take property
what is public use
public use requirement
the takings cause in the 5th amendment says nor shall private property be taken for public use without compensation
Berman v Parker (1954)
involves the District of Columbia redevelopment act of 1945 an act designed to redevelop particularly blighted areas of Washington D.C.
redevelopment act provided that the doc redevelopment land agency could acquire (by eminent domain) properties to blighted areas for redevelopment projects
Berman v Parker question
could the agency acquire private property via eminent domain and transfer that property to private concerns for redevelopment
Berman v Parker answer
ruled yes for Parker
public use is what the government says it is
Hawaii Housing Authority v Midkiff (1984)
case involves Hawaii land reform act of 1967 which allowed the Hawaii housing authority to exercise eminent domain condemning the property of large landowners
under the act the Hawaii housing authority would then sell the tracks of land they obtained via eminent domain to other citizens
Hawaii Housing Authority v Midkiff question
did the exercise of eminent domain under the Hawaii land reform act violate the public use provision in the takings clause
Hawaii Housing Authority v Midkiff answer
finds for Hawaii upholding states land reform
as long as original landowners are fairly compensated there is not a problem
coterminous with the states police power
the use of eminent domain is extremely broad but not limitless
Kelo v City of New London (2005)
involves that condemnation of a number of private properties in new London, Connecticut for economic development purposes
Kelo v City of New London questions
was the condemnation of private property development a public use
does economic development meet the definition of a public use a required by the 5th amendment takings clause
Kelo v City of New London answer
in favor of the city holding that the condemnation for private economic development meet the definition of a public use