1/67
Looks like no tags are added yet.
legal reasoning
decided on a case by case basis
social science
in constitutional law wording stays the same but accepted interpretation changes over time
judges must make a decision even if there isn’t enough evidence to make a confident decision
laws need for immediate decisions has consequences for the quality of scientific evidence presented in court
Analogical reasoning
comparison of closely related cases to current case
heart of the case method
bottom up
used to compare set of experiments that have inconsistent results
convergence
judges or lawyers attempt to define the meaning of a case by looking for factual and legal similarities
Hindsight
once ppl know the outcome an event they believe that they would have predicted it in advance
can be dangerous in law bc the tendency to perceive that the outcome was predictable in advance may lead judges to believe the the defendant could or should’ve predicted it (tunnel vision)
Categorical thinking
final decisions in individual cases. Defendant is either liable or nonliable, sane or insane
junk scientist are favored by attorneys because
make questionable or exaggerated scientific claims that provide clear cut arguments that benefit their clients
cserne
economic analysis has contributed to a better understanding of law
Economics IN legal reasoning
purposes and consequences of legal rules and principles that are acceptable as legally relevant
Economics OF legal reasoning
explanatory models of legal processes in terms of rational activity of individuals
Economists consider legal reasoning a mere rhetoric, facon de parler
confusing at worst, irrelevant noise at best
Functionalist
only care about outcome of proceeding,
how expected legal outcomes change human behavior
leaves little room for analyzing legal reasoning in terms of procedures, duties…
Scientific reasoning
uses control groups
general principles may be reworded
collect new data to illuminate the question
nt constrained by evidence at hand
can say no answer is available at the present time
probabilistic reasoning
based on probability, expressing problems as likelihoods, risks, or degrees of beliefs rather than absolute certainty
convergent validity
many different tests of the same concepts or hypothesis all come out the same way
discriminant validity
researchers tries to show that 1 measure is not correlated with measures of other instances
HARKING
hypothesizing After the Results are Known (hindsight)
Continuous variable
asses the individual and the circumstantial pressures to come up with an individually nuanced explanation
a grey area between sane and insane
statistically significant findings
implies that other pppl would have behaved the same way in the same circumstances, suggesting the circumstances largely determine the behavior
fundamental attribution error
tendency to overlook situational influences and blame someones character
Frye v. US
research evidence must be generally accepted by. the relevant scientific community in order to be admissible in court
Daubert v. Merell Dow Pharmaceuticals
acceptance is an important factor for admissibility
judges act as gatekeepers and determine whether expert testimony is sufficiently reliable to be admitted in court
economist scan contribute to legal reasoning gin 2 main ways
under terms set by legal practice. accept these terms when recognizing the the impact of their findings depends on the specific political and legal systems in which it applies
draw attention to aspects of legal reasoning that are not really explicable from a legal practitioners perspective
Science and legal
pride themselves on rationality of intellectual methods that analyze questions and reach correct conclusions by means of reason free from bias
both use deductive an inductive reasoning
subject to error and biases
faced with situations that resemble past ones
analogy devised by Langdell
the study of law is a science
legal formalism
a pyramid of rules with fundamental first principles at the top and a very large number of rules can be derived (resmblane to biological taxonomic system)
The case method
new legal cases are like new species. method of classifying them by comparing them to existing cases
anchoring
when asked to make decisions in unknown contexts, ppl who are given some value even an arbitrary one, use it unwittingly as an anchor
confirmation bias
tendency to seek, believe, and remember info that agrees with what we already think
wealth maximization (posner)
judges should tend to decide cases to maximize social welfare
Posner
economic reasoning can be useful in law but believes judges should take a more practical approach to decision making
basic economic model of legal procedures
legal processs goal is to minimize error and costs. this model helps explain why certain legal procedures exist, and compare effectiveness of rules when costs can’t be measured exactly.
Teological reasoning (consequence based reasoning)
make decisions based on desired goals and consequences of diff choices
identify the desired goal
consider options to achieve it
choose best option
difficulties in consequence based reasoning
judges identify which consequences of their decisions are relevant ( can be hard to identify)
info is imperfect and fundmanal uncertainty about certain variables when measuring impact of decisions
weighing consequences of Dif interpretations against relevant moral standards, often make value based trade offs
although predicting every consequence is impossible
we shouldn’t ignore consequences all together ( kornhauser)
Juridicial consequences
internal to the legal system. consider how interpreting a law affects other laws and rules
behavioral consequences
outside legal system. what human behavior the rule will induce or discourage
efficiency theory of common law
par excellence, consequentialist reasoning, judges should make desciosn based on effects to society welfare
consequenatlism
consequence based arguments in legal reasoning
mutatis mutandis
with the necessary changes, judges can’t force every consequence because the future is uncertain
Formalistic adjudication
following established laws and limiting discretion creates certainty, predictability, and prosperity. protects individual rights and freedoms
legal reasoning can follow patterns that create unexpected consequences, economics helps identify these problems so the legal system could be improved
political economy perspective
how legal rule and procedures change because of political pressures
policy perspective
how legal procedures and institutional rules could be designed to achieve specific goals (efficiency, fairness)
incorporate economics on 2 conditions
judicial psychology: how judges think
legal process incentive: how courts rule limit and influence judicial behaviors
learning expertise
how consumers learn about products
learn through experience
doesn’t remove psychological bias
countefactual reasoning
ppl naturally think about what could have happened differently after an event
Microeconomics
why we need courts to resolve individual issues
Macroeconomics
how courts help society function and adapt
operation management science
use data, tech, science, math to improve business decisions/ operations account for human error
organizational behavior
explain and facilitate executive work, decision making, conflict management, innovation
behavioral finance
psychology and bias influence financial decisions
info search
ppl don’t search endlessly
they might stop bc
found everything
found smth specific
new info doesn’t change understanding
each new piece adds little value
reached threshold
group cognition
how groups and orgs learn, innovate, remeber
how ppl work together ( problem solving), distributing knowledge and responsibilities
loss aversion
ppl feel the impact of losing money more than gaining the same amount
reference point
ppl evaluate decisons based on starting point or expectation rather than looking at their financical position
fundamental cognitive claim
how ppl Frame a problem influences the solution ppl generate
similarity and analogy
consumer use familiar experiences as comparisons when evaluating smth new
companies use similarities and analogies to make products comprehensible and appealing
4 broad goals for consumer decisions
decision quality
minimize effort
minimize negative emotion
increasing justification
alienable differences
options differ among some dimension, easier to compare
nonalignable diff:
options have completely diff feats or qualities, harder to compare
marketing consume rbehavior
shaping how customers make purchases, use products, think abt brands
applied research and thinking
translates basic research to advance real world practice
provides contexts that raise new questions
Lowenstein:
each area of business academia has a segment engaged in behavioral research
Categories
organize types of products and services
organize judgments of quality, availability, desirability
kinds of consumers, how to generate marketing
product categories aren’t fixed they evolve with consumer and producer interactions
category perception influences customer preference
when something fits familiar category other judge on those expectations
culture shapes categories
creativity
ads aimed at engaging consumers attention
diversity of knowledge encourages creativity, helps ppl connect ideas
behavioral accounting
how ppl generate, use, audit an orgs quantitative economic info
how info used for budgeting or compensation
how they communicate to lenders, investors
numerical cognition
ppl remember overall impression of financial info not precise numbers
data can become distorted, limitations in humans
Correlation to Law: law also requires people to interpret complex systems of rules
conclusions
research on how ppl think and reason can help businesses function
how ppl categorize information, how they change based on choices, culture, expand our understanding of human thinking
society shapes individual cognition