1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Georgia vs Tennessee Copper Co (1907)
Findings: GA Common Law Public Nuisance Suit Against TN Copper Co. and Other Companies, Alleging Smelter Fumes Destroyed Forests, Orchards, Crops, and Seeking Damages and Injunction
Issue: Whether Court Should Order an Injunction When Evidence of Causation and Injury, and Plaintiff is a State Seeking to Protect Citizen Interests
Holding: Yes, Injunction
Reasoning: State Has a Valid Interest beyond That of Individual Citizens in Protecting its Earth and Air
What are the Two Categories of Air Pollution?
Criteria Air Pollutants and Non-Criteria Air Pollutants
What are the 6 Criteria Air Pollutants?
Sulfur Oxide, Carbon Monoxide, Particulates, Nitrogen Oxides, Lead, and Ozone
What are Non-Criteria Pollutants
Toxic or Hazardous; Not Regulated Until 1990s
What are Ambient Standards (NAAQS) Based On?
Health Based
What are Emission Standards Based On?
Technology Based
What are Primary NAAQS?
For Criteria Pollutants; Levels are Set to Protect Human Health (1-in-1 Million Lifetime Excess Cancer Risk)
What are Secondary NAAQS?
Levels Set to Protect Public Welfare, Such as the Environment, Visibility, Climate, and Property
Lead Industries vs EPA (1980)
Issue: Whether EPA May Consider Economic and Technological Feasibility When Setting NAAQS, or Only Public Health and Welfare
Holding: Only Health and Safety
Periodic Review of NAAQS?
EPA Must Periodically Review NAAQS and Revise the Criteria and Standards to Protect the Public Health
Whitman vs American Trucking Association (2001)
Facts: In 1997, EPA Proposed Stricter Ozone and Particulate NAAQS Which Required Reduced Emissions from Diesel Buses and Trucks
Issue: Whether EPA May Consider Costs When Implements NAAQS
Holding: EPA May Not Consider Costs, EPA Must Set Standards to Protect Public Health with an Adequate Margin of Safety
What are State Implementation Plans (SIPs)?
State Implementation of NAAQS; Must Monitor Ambient Air and Report to EPA, Require Permits for Stationary Sources, and Apply Emissions Standards
What are the 3 Designations for Air Quality?
Attainment Areas, Non-Attainment Areas, and Insufficient Data Areas
What are Non-Attainment Areas?
Areas That Do Not Meet NAAQS
What Must Non-Attainment Areas Do?
Transportation Control Plans, Offset Required for New or Modified Sources, and More Stringent Emission Standards
Criteria Pollutant Emission Standards for New and Modified Source Include?
New Source Performance Standards (NSPS); Requires Best Pollution Control
Criteria Pollutant Emission Standards for Existing Sources Include?
Exemption from NSPS; Old, Less Protective Control Methods Allowed
Why are Existing Sources Exempt?
CAA Allows Them to be “Grandfathered in,” Unless Major Modifications Occur
What is the Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) Program?
Areas Cleaner Than NAAQS Must Preserve Air Quality of the Area
What is the National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAPS) Program?
Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (HAPs); No Ambient Standards or Systematic Monitoring
Emissions Standards for HAPs Were Originally Based On?
Protecting Human Health; Abandonded in 1990
What are the Emission Standards for HAPs Based On Now?
The Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT)
What is a Residual Risk Assessment?
Done by EPA 8 Years After MACT Implementation; If Needed, Adoption of Additional Emissions Standards to Reduce Risk and Protect Human Health
What are Title V Permits?
CAA Permits That Apply Emission Standards to Stationary Air Pollution Sources
What are Some of Our Current Air Pollution Issues?
Coal Powered Power Plant Emissions and Carbon Emissions
What’s the Issue With TVA Coal Powered Power Plants?
TVA Claims They’re Not Subject to NSPS, While EPA Claims it is Because of Major Modifications
NC vs TVA (2009)
Findings: TVA Coal Powered Power Plants Releasing Air Pollutants Causing Public Nuisance That Harms Citizens in NC
Issue 1: Whether TVA Coal Powered Power Plants are a Public Nuisance
Issue 2: Whether CAA Displaces Public Nuisance Suit by NC
Holding: TVA Plants in TN and AL are Public Nuisance
Aftermath: TVA Appealed and Won in Circuit Court :(
Massachusetts Et Al vs EPA (2007)
Facts: Mass. and 11 Other States Sued EPA for Not Regulating Carbon Emissions from Mobile Sources Under CAA
Issues:
Whether Party Had Standing
Whether GHGs are Pollutants Under the CAA
Whether EPA Has Statutory Authority to Regulate Global Warming Pollution from Mobile Sources
Whether EPA Has Authority to Refuse to Regulate
Holdings:
Plaintiffs Have Standing
GHGs are Pollutants
EPA Does Have Statutory Authority to Regulate GHGs
EPA Must Regulate Emissions if Endangerment Assessment Determines Negative Affects to “Public Health and Welfare”
American Electric Power vs Connecticut
Finding: 8 States, NYC, and 3 Nonprofits Sue Alleging Power Plant Carbon Emissions are a Public Nuisance
Issue: Whether CAA Displaces Federal Common Law
Holding: CAA Displaces Federal Common Law
Reasoning: Should be Suited Under CAA, Not Common Law
West Virginia vs EPA (2022)
Finding: New EPA Regulation Requiring Existing Coal-Fired Power Plants to Reduce Carbon by Either Subsidizing or Reducing Production
Issue: Whether CAA Granted EPA Authority to Devise Emissions Caps Based on the “Generation Shifting” Approach
Holding: No, EPA Regulation is Invalid
Reasoning: EPA Exceeded Statutory Authority