1/12
Looks like no tags are added yet.
the idiographic-nomothetic debate
debate over which position is preferable in society
idiographic suggests psychology is focused on the study of individuals as this provides detailed information about human behaviour
nomothetic suggests psychology should study large or varied groups, making generalisations on typical behaviour
dictates if we study individuals or larger groups (depth details, averages)
the 2 approaches may both have a place within a scientific study of a person i.e. they may overlap and be used alongside each other
idiographic approach
an approach to research that focuses more on the individual case (person/group) to provide an in depth explanation of behaviour
what do idiographic approaches study?
small number of participants, often a single case study of an individual or group, research may include others eg family, friends
focus is on detail, initial focus is understanding the individual but generalisations may be made on findings
uses mostly qualitative research, first hand accounts, case studies
may interview participants or use questionnaires, focus may be on a certain behaviour, data is analysed by thematic analysis and emergent themes analysed
conclusions can be applied to similar people, with similar experiences and help mental health professionals determine best practice and develop therapies
examples of idiographic research
humanistic and psychodynamic approaches
Rogers concept of counselling was based on his work as a therapist, his âtheoryâ on the role of unconditional positive regard in self development was based on his in depth study of his clients
Freudâs theories developed through observation of patients eg Little Hans case study to explain phobias
patient HM, single patient with brain damage led to generalisations about procedural memory to others
nomothetic approach
aims to study human behaviour through the development of general principles and universal laws, study of larger groups
aims to generalise findings to develop laws, general principles of behaviour that can be applied in individual situations eg therapy
what does nomothetic approaches study?
uses quantitative research, fits the traditional scientific method of psychology: formulate hypothesis, collect and assess samples of people, analyse numerical data for statistical significance
aim to quantity (count) human behaviour
examples of nomothetic research
behaviourist and biological approaches
Skinner studied animals to develop general laws of learning, research looked at one unit of behaviour in a small sample but the goal was to establish general laws
Sperryâs split brain research involved repeated testing on a small sample to provide and understand a basis of hemispheric lateralisation in general
objective vs subjective
nomothetic approach focuses on objectivity, seeks standardised methods of assessing people, carried out objectively for general laws to be defined, ensures true replication across all samples and removes the contaminating influence of bias
idiographic approach tends not to believe objectivity is possible in psychological research, the subjectivity of the individuals experience of their unique context informs the findings
strength- idiographic and nomothetic approaches work together
a strength of the idiographic approach is it contributes to the nomothetic approach by using qualitative methods which complements the nomothetic approach by providing detail and giving a broad description of an individual, could challenge general nomothetic laws
in depth case studies such as HM (damaged memory) may reveal insights about normal memory functioning which contribute to overall understanding
suggests even though the focus is on fewer individuals, the idiographic approach may help form âscientificâ laws of behaviour
counterpoint- issues with generalisation
idiographic approach on its own is restricted
idiographic findings cant be generalised to larger groups without more than one example, small sample will provide a weak baseline for comparison of behaviour, case studies also less scientific as theyâre often subjective and open to bias
suggests its difficult to build effective general theories of human behaviour in the complete absence of nomothetic research
strength- both approaches have scientific credibility, fit with the aims of science
both approaches make use of scientific methods, nomothetic research seeks objectivity through standardisation, control and statistical testing
idiographic research also seeks objectivity through triangulation, comparing findings from a range of studies with different methods to increase validity, and reflexivity, qualitative researchers examine own biases
suggests both nomothetic and idiographic approaches raise psychologyâs status as a science
limitation- individual experience is lost in nomothetic approach
nomothetic approach focuses on general laws and may âlose the whole personâ within psychology
eg knowing about a 1% lifetime risk of schizophrenia is a general law telling us little about having the disorder or quality of life for sufferers, may be useful for therapeutic ideas
means, in its search for generalities, the nomothetic approach may sometimes fail to relate to âexperienceâ
evaluation/limitation- distinct or complementary?
each approach is distinct and appropriate for different situations or aims eg Schaffer described general stages of attachment (nomothetic ) but case studies of extreme neglect, eg Genie, highlight subjective experience (idiographic)
however, they may be 2 ends of a continuum, eg when diagnosing personality disorders, clinicians begin with general nomothetic criteria to match symptoms to diagnosis, then focus on the individuals unique needs (Millon 1995)
suggests these approaches arenât either/or, we can consider the same topic form both perspectives