1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
One limitation of Milgrim’s research is that there were ethical issues
Participant were exposed to extremely stressful situations that may have the potential to cause psychological harm many of the ppts were visibly distressed
Signs of tension included trembling, sweating and stuttering. One participant had an uncontrollable seizure and many pleaded to be allowed to stop the exp.
therefore the research is considered unacceptable as it does not adhere to the bps ethical guidelines as participants will not protect protected from psychological harm and questions whether the research should’ve been allowed to take place
furthermore, other ethical guidelines such as deception and informed consent were also broken as a participants were to believe the study was un punishment and learning further questioning the suitability of the study
One limitation of Malcolm’s research is that there was a sample bias
Malcolm used the sample of male American volunteer participants so his study tells us very little about how other groups may respond in this environment
For example, Malcolm used an individual individualistic culture in his sample so we cannot make any assumptions about the obedience of individuals of a collectivist culture
Therefore, this is a limitation of Milgrim study as the sample lacks population validity and so the findings cannot be generalised
furthermore Malcolm use an artificial environment to study complex social behaviour and the findings like ecological validity as they are not representative of real word behaviours
A strength is support from Hofling
Hofling did a naturalistic experiment involving 22 nurses Dr Smith (a confederate)phones the nurses at hospital and asked them to administer a drug to patient of the follow the request they will be breaking through hospital rules
Hoffing found that 21 out of 22 nurses followed Dr Smith request and broke the rules all because someone in authority told them to do so
therefore, this is a strength for Milgrim as the finances are consistent with Milgrim study and shows that we are willing to obey authority figure even to the extent that we could harm other increasing the reliability of the research
Furthermore, the study was a naturalistic field experiment so against the criticism that people only obeyed in a Milgrim study as they believe the shocks were fake
c
c