1/43
Ethics
Beliefs
What we understand or accept as true
Values
What matters to us and guides priorities
Morals
Judgements about right and wrong
Ethics
Reasonded examination of what ought to be done in professional practice
What sre personak values shaped by
experiences, family, culture, and context
Do patients and family sometimes hold different, equally important values
Yes
What does professional responsibility require
curiosity, self-awareness, and respect
Morals further explained
Private, personal standards of right and wrong based on social norms and customs.
A code of behavior or community expectations- one’s conscience or how we act in situations
Moral development (ethical) theories provide
Provide frameworks to view and clarify moral and ethical dilemmas
What is the difference between morals and values?
Values are what you cherish or prioritize (the "why"); morals are the rules or boundaries you follow regarding right and wrong (the "what").
Ethics further explained
philosophical ideals of right and wrong behavior.
• A way to understand morals
• Ethics is not religion or law
• Nurses have a duty to practice ethically and morally
Morals are internal personal principles and ethics are external rules, standards
Why do we need ethics in healthcare
Principles to guide conduct
Principles to guide decision making
What are ethical storeis
A set of principles which provide different lens (perspectives) to view and reflect on different circumstances
Ethical theories: cosequentialism
Consider likely outcomes and benefits/harms
Also referred to as teleological
Emphasis is on the outcome versus one guiding principle
• Follow the principle of utilitarianism: The most good for the greatest # of people
Ethical theories: Deontology
Consider duties, obligations and rights
Principle and rule based
Duty based- emphasize individual rights, obligations and duties
Not concerned with consequence but rather involves considering an objective principle
Obeys rules that are universal (honesty, truthfulness and moral obligation)
Ethical theories: Relational / ethics of care
Attend to relationships, vulnerability and context
Focus on ‘caring’ as caring is foundational to nursing.
Stress the need to nurture and maintain relationships
Situation based (versus following rules)
Increasingly used in nursing and nursing ethics
Focuses on the relationship
How does the relationship impact the context?
Recognizes that decisions are driven and impacted by relationships and context
What are the biomedical ethical (bioethics) principles
Autonomy
•Beneficence
•Nonmaleficence
•Paternalism
•Justice
•Fidelity
•Veracity
What do ethical principles lack?
Although there is value in these principles, they lack the relational and contextual pieces often required in ethical decision making
Ethical principle: Autonomy
Respect informed choices and self-determination
Definition: “autos” = self, “nomos” = rule
• Individual rights
• Privacy
• Freedom of choice
Ethical principle:Beneficence
Act to promote well-being
Duty to do good
Reflection of goodness, kindness, charity
Central for caring practice
Ethical principle: Nonmaleficence
Avoid or minimize harm
Duty: NOT TO CAUSE harm
Duty: PREVENT harm
Duty: REMOVE harm
Ethical principle: Justice
Fairness in access, benefit and burdens
Seeks fairness
More specifically, distributive justice refers to distribution of benefits and burdens
Justice issues in healthcare often arise based on resources
Ethical principle: Fidelity and veracity
Keeps commitments and communicate truthfully
Fidelity:
Duty to be faithful to one’s commitments
Includes implicit and explicit promises
Make a promise, follow through
Veracity:
Vera = truth
The obligation to tell the truth and not to lie or deceive others
Paternalism
When one individual assumes the right to make decisions for another
Limits freedom of choice
Think about parents making decisions for children
When principles compete
Autonomy and beneficence may point in different directions
Avoiding harm may mean different things to different people
Fairness and individual needs may create tension
Ethical reasoning makes the tension visible; it does not guarantee one easy answer
Purpose of the CNA code of ethics
Provides guidance
Ensures accountability
Promotes best practice
Upholds professional standards
Navigates contemporary issues
CNA code of ethics
Honouring the dignity and autonomy of all people
Valuing relationships and humanizing care
Maintain intergrity and accountability in nursing practice
Pursuing truth and reconcilliation
Pormoting social justice
Providing competent professional nursing practice
Preserving privacy and confidentiality
Ethics in nursing practice
In providing care, the nurse promotes an environment in which the human rights, values, customs, and spiritual beliefs of the indivisual, family anf community is respected
What defines a good decision?
One that is in the clients best interest and at the same time preserves the integrity of all involved
Nurses own values: moral integrity
The quality of one’s character and integrated virtues including honesty and truthfulness
Nurses own values: Moral dilemma
Situations where there are conflicting ethical claims. What ought we do?
Nurses own values: Moral distress
When the individual knows the ethically correct action to take but is unable to do so because of internal of external barriers.
What is an ethical dilemma
Two or more important ethical claims or values are in tension
Not every difficult decision is an ethical dilemma
Moral distress may occur when someone believes they know the right action but cannot take it
Cause distress and confusion for clients/families
Acknowledge uncertainty without assuming bad intentions
Emotions play an important role and can lead us to see a problem
A practical ethical decision-making framework
1. Clarify the issue: what makes this ethically difficult?
2. Gather relevant facts, perspectives and missing information
3. Examine values, principles, professional duties and your own assumptions
4. Consider possible responses and their consequences
5. Communicate, act appropriately, reflect and evaluate
The nurse’s role in a difficult decision
Listen carefully to patients, families and the care team
Clarify understanding; communicate honestly and compassionately
Support informed discussion and advocate for patient-centred care
Recognize limits of the student role and seek guidance when needed