1/4
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Elements R2§153:
Mistake of one party
With regard to a basic assumption of the K (not only with regard to K's value)
That has Material Effect on the exchange (I.e. substantial impact)
No Assumption of the Risk by the party seeking relief
Unconscionable result (I.e. extreme unfairness) or
Other party: caused/knew/should have known
Goal: the law responds by adding requirements to mutual mistake making it even harder to get justification.
Try to establish both on exam
Wil-Fred's Jurisdictional Split (include in exam):
Mistake of one party
With regard to a basic assumption of the K (not only with regard to K's value)
That has Material Effect on the exchange (I.e. substantial impact)
No Negligence (mistaken P)
No Reliance (non-mistaken P)
Element 2: Basic Assumption Test:
A mistake regarding only the value of the exchange is ineffective.
A mistake regarding the nature of the thing is effective.
EX: Sellers argued the mistake relates only to "the quality or value of the real estate transferred", and thus, fails the element. (I.e. disappointed gambler)
EX: Buyers argued the mistake relates to "the very nature of the character of the consideration" and thus, satisfies the element."
Element 3: Material Effect Test:
Makes performance impossible or impracticable;
Frustrates the purpose of the contract; and/or
Seriously undercuts the equivalence of the parties' exchange
Assumption of Risk Test:
A party bears the risk of mistake when:
The risk is allocated to him by agreement of the parties, [Express risk]or
He is aware at the time the contract is made that he has limited knowledge [implied in fact]
The risk allocated to him by the court on the ground that it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so. [Implied in law]