1/85
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Independent Variable
Refers to the condition of an experiment that is systematically manipulated by the investigator. It is the presumed cause.
Dependent Variable
expected to change as a result of an experimental
manipulation of the independent variable(s). It is the presumed effect.
Extraneous Variables
Variables other than the manipulated variables that affect the results of the experiment
Study population
A group of individuals taken from the general
population who share a common characteristic, such
as HTN, Dyslipidemia, etc.
Internal Validity
Indicates whether the independent variable was the sole cause of the change in the dependent variable
External Validity
Indicates the extent to which the results of the experiment are applicable to the real world
Randomization
Assignment of subjects and treatment to groups is
based on chance
Blinding
- used to control subjects' knowledge of whether they receive the experimental treatment.
Open label/No blinding
Single blinding
Double blinding
Experimental Group
Group of subjects exposed to the experimental treatment
Control Group
Not exposed to the experimental treatment
Levels of Evidence
1. Meta analysis
2. RCT
3. Cohort studies
4. Case control study
5. Case reports
6. Bench research/expert opinions
Descriptive studies are:
- Case report
- Case series
- Survey
Analytic studies are:
- Observational
- Experimental
Observational
- Cross section
- Case-control
- Cohort studies
Experimental
- Quasi (clinical trials)
Strength of evidence for causality between a risk factor and outcome
Descriptive < Observational < Experimental
Descriptive Studies
represent the first scientific clue into new areas of scientific inquiry
- Disease
- Adverse Drug Reaction
- New Indication (off-label use)
Answers to: 6 basic "W" questions
Help in generating hypotheses and associations
Case Report
Most basic form of medical evidence
- A careful clinician observes a new disease presentation or an unusual ADR
Case report types are often based on the objective new findings
- (New indication; New ADR; Disease)
Examples: The advent of HIV and COVID-19
A 57-year-old woman developed a cough and fever after returning to Changsha
from Wuhan on January 9, 2020. She tested positive for COVID-19 infection, a
diagnosis that chest CT supported. The patient was treated with lopinavir, ritonavir
tablets, and interferon alfa-2b injection. A low dose of glucocorticoids was used
briefly to control the bilateral lung immune response, and this patient avoided being
crushed by cytokine storms that might have occurred. The clinical condition of this
patient improved, and a COVID-19 assay conducted on January 25, 2020, generated
negative results.
This case describes the symptoms, diagnosis, treatment, and management of a patient cured of COVID-19 infection, which may serve as a reference for future cases while further studies are needed.
Case Series
- is an aggregate of individual cases on the same topic in one report
- Case series report may warrant additional
investigations
Ex: A cluster of homosexual men in LA with similar clinical syndromes alerted the medical community to the AIDS epidemic
Surveys
the collection of information from a sample of individuals through their responses to questions
Ex: Questionnaire & Interview
Quantitative
- Designed to collect numerical or quantitative data that can be used to measure a variable
Ex: Dabigatran use among patients with valvular AF
Qualitative
Information that seeks to describe a topic more than measure it. This type of research measures opinions, views, and attributes
Ex: Opinions about the COVID-19 vaccines
Errors in Survey Research
- Coverage
- Sampling
- Measurement
- Nonresponse
Coverage
Zero chance of being included in the sample
- Use Multiple design
Sampling
Individual included in the sample do not represent the population
- Clearly define your population
Measurement
Questions/instruments do not adequately reflect the topic
- Use valid, reliable instruments
Nonresponse
Lack of response from sample individuals'
User-friendly survey design; follow-up procedures
Descriptive Studies
- Strengths
- Relatively inexpensive
- Relatively expeditious; can publish results quickly
- Provides very detailed information
Descriptive Studies
- Weakness
- Difficult to replicate
- May include bias
- Cannot be generalized
Observational Studies
the Investigator(s) does not intervene - simply observe(s) and collect data of interest
Accesses the strength of the relationship between the
exposure and the outcome of interest.
The Investigator attempts to establish a causal link
between a risk factor and an outcome.
Investigator(s) draw inferences about the possible
effects of a treatment or risks on subjects.
Assignment of Treatment or Intervention is outside
the control of the investigator.
The assignment of treatments/intervention is beyond
the control of the investigator for a variety of reasons:
- Ethical
- Several confounders
- Rare occurrence
Uses of Observational studies
- Prevalence
- Incidence
- Prognosis
- Effects of treatment
- Characteristics of a disease/Outcomes
Observational Studies
- Strengths
- Relatively fast and inexpensive to conduct
- Detect signals about the benefits and risks of
certain treatments.
- Help formulate hypotheses to be tested in
subsequent experiments.
Observational Studies
- Weakness
- Cannot provide definitive evidence of safety or
efficacy.
- Cannot provide causality.
Types of Observational studies
- Cross sectional
- Case control
- Cohort
— Prospective
— Retrospective
Cross Sectional Study
At one point, subjects are sampled and assessed to
determine whether they were exposed to the relevant
agent and whether they have the outcome of interest
Describe associations:
- Influences the likelihood of a particular diagnosis and the predictive value of a test
- Provides estimates for prevalence
Time frame: Present
Performing Cross sectional study
- Risk factor = Yes (+ for disease)
- Risk factor = Yes (- for disease)
- Risk factor = No (+ for disease)
- Risk factor = No (- for disease)
Cross Sectional
- Strengths
- Can only measure prevalence
- Relatively fast and inexpensive to conduct
- No loss to follow up
- Associations can be studied
Cross Sectional
- Weakness
- Not suitable for rare diseases or side effects
- Can't show causality
Case Control Studies
- Persons with the condition or outcome of interest ("case") are identified.
- Match them with identical persons without the condition ("control")
Retrospectively assess exposures
Prospective case-control studies are less common
- Previous exposure data are collected, and the exposed patients are followed prospectively for the outcome
Ex: "Statins may be associated with significant increase in Diabetes risk in post-menopausal Women"
Case Control Studies
- Strengths
- Rare diseases/outcomes e.g., cancer
- Study many exposures
- Fast and Inexpensive
- Provides Odds Ratio
- Can generate hypothesis
Case Control Studies
- Weakness
Cannot measure
- Incidence
- Prevalence
- Relative Risks
Very prone to bias
- Recall bias
Cohort Studies
- Best method for determining the incidence & natural history of a condition, disease, adverse drug effects, treatments, etc.
- The studies can be prospective or
retrospective
- Two cohorts' studies can be compared
Cohort Studies
- Prospective
- Start with the study population who do not have the disease/outcome of interest
- Measure variables that might be relevant to the
development of the condition.
- Match with a similar population without the
variable
- Follow the population over a period of time.
- The groups are assessed for the development of
the disease/outcome of interest.
Time frame: Past/Future
Cohort Studies
- Retrospective
- Identification of cohort, measurement of predictor variables, follow-up and measurement of outcomes have all occurred in the past
- Much less costly than prospective cohorts
- Investigator has minimal control over study design
Cohort Strengths
- Provides incidence data
- Establishes time sequence for causality
- Eliminates recall bias
- Allows for accurate measurement of exposure and other variables
- Can measure multiple outcomes
- May be able to adjust for confounders
- Can calculate relative risk
Cohort Weakness
- Expensive
- Exposure may change over time
- Disease may have a long pre-clinical phase
- Attrition of study population
Limitations of Observational Studies
Observational studies are prone to:
- Biases
— Information Bias
— Selection Bias
- Confounders
Study Bias
Any trend in the collection, analysis, interpretation, publication, or review of data that can lead to conclusions that are systematically different from the truth. (Last et)
A process at any state of inference tending to produce results that depart systematically from the actual values. (Fletcher et)
Systematic error in design or conduct of a study. (Szklo et)
Types of Study bias
- Selection Bias
- Information Bias
- Confounding Bias
"Bias" = internal validity
Generalizability = external validity
Experimental study design
- determining the strongest evidence between exposure and outcome.
- Experimental study can be controlled or non-controlled.
- Randomized or non-randomized
- Double-blinded, single-blinded, or no blinding
- Experimental trials can be described as
prospective or longitudinal.
Experimental Research Elements
- Looks for cause-and-effect relationships
- Highly controlled, objective, and systematic operations
- Involves accurate measurement, analysis, and interpretation of the dependent and independent variables
- Can state a hypothesis
- A researcher can test the hypothesis
- Can draw a conclusion
Experimental Research Characteristics
- Characterized by complete random assignment of groups or subjects
- Groups/subjects are either dependent/independent
- Manipulation of at least one independent variable
- Usually employs strong control
- Employs blinding
Manipulation
- Manipulation of an independent variable.
- Manipulation of the dependent variable by the independent variable is observed.
- All variables except the dependent variable are held constant.
Control Methods
- Experimental control attempts to predict events that will occur in the experimental setting by neutralizing the effects of other factors.
Physical control
- Gives all subjects equal exposure to the independent variable.
Selective control
Indirectly manipulate by selecting in or out variables that cannot be controlled.
Statistical control
Variables may be controlled by statistical techniques
Randomization
- A process by which study participants have an equal
chance of being assigned to the treatment arm
- Eliminates selection and "accidental" bias
- Group assignments cannot be predicted in advance
- Produces comparable study groups
- Ensures that statistical tests will have a valid significance level
Forms of randomization include:
- Simple randomization
- Permuted block randomization
- Stratified randomization
Simple randomization
- Coin tossing for each participant
- Computer generated
Stratified Randomization
- Restricts imbalances to ensure the treatment groups are as alike as possible.
- Following a simple randomization
- According to age
Blinding
is intended to avoid bias caused by subjective judgment in reporting, evaluation, data processing, and analysis due to knowledge of treatment.
Open Label
No blinding
- useful for:
—Pilot studies
—Dose ranging studies
- Applications may be substantially biased by knowledge of the treatment given and may result in:
- Toxicity over/under reporting
- Efficacy over estimation
Single blind
Only the patient is blinded to treatment
- Cases where double-blind is "impractical" because of the need to adjust medication, medication affecting
laboratory values, potential side effects, etc.
- Single blind study should be used only when it would be unacceptable ethically to give an appropriate placebo treatment to a patient, and in such a case, the assessor (not the patient) should be the one blinded to the treatment
Double blind
Patient and assessors (who often are also health care providers and data collectors) are blinded treatment
- Serve as the standard by which all studies are judged.
- Minimize both potential patients' and investigators' biases
- Should be used whenever ethically possible
Double blinding techniques
- Coded treatment groups
- Placebo for each possible treatment
- Tablets or capsules identical in physical appearance
- Tablets or capsules with similar taste and smell
- IV infusions would normally be the same carrier as used for active medications
Double blinding problems
- Fake surgery would be considered unethical in a study
- It would be hard to blind a patient to the therapy given in an adverse effect, exercise, etc. studies
- It might not be possible to blind a patient while
comparing the utility of different invasive procedures
Complete blind
everyone involved in the study is blinded to treatment
Experimental study design
- Strengths
- Best measure of causal relationships
- Best design for controlling bias
- Can measure multiple outcomes
Experimental study design
- Weakness
- Relatively expensive
- Ethical issues may be a problem
- Compliance
- Issues with external validity
Randomized Controlled Clinical study
- Patients are randomly assigned to one of two, three
or more groups that receive a drug or intervention
and are followed over time for the outcome of
interest.
- Some patients may fall under the control group
which serves as the comparison group the group
may be given a placebo drug (inactive drug, aka
"sugar pill"), or a comparison drug may be given
- Both groups are compared on the outcomes and
treatment effectiveness is determined.
RCT Advantages
- Provides the most robust evidence for determining drug efficacy
- Employs a control group (ideal for comparisons)
- Bias is minimized
- Extraneous factors are minimized.
- Most reliable trial for evaluating therapies
- Trials are reproducible and can be replicated
RCT Disadvantages
- Studies can be odious and time-consuming
- Expensive - Most expensive study design
- Patient enrollment can be difficult (time- consuming)
- The dropout rate is high
- Ethical problems in testing new drugs in humans and in certain populations
Non-controlled experimental Study
- Does not utilize a control group.
- The drug or procedure to be evaluated is administered to a single group of patients.
- Outcomes of interest are measured and analyzed
- Draw research conclusion
Parallel Design
- Includes independent study groups, and each group receives a different treatment regimen or intervention
- Randomized Controlled Trials are often parallel design
- Parallel design is more useful for studying conditions that are prone to change over time (pain, acute exacerbations of disease, remissions)
Parallel Design example
In a study to evaluate the efficacy of ARB for CHF exacerbation, 500 patients are randomized into two groups of 250 patients. One group is then treated with an ARB, and the other is treated with ACEI and followed for 6 months.
Crossover Design
- Both groups receive treatments or interventions (Drug and placebo).
- The groups are later crossed over (switched)
- It is statistically sensitive and efficient
—Use fewer patients
- Fewer patients can lead to a more homogenous group with less variability in measurement.
—Less variability between groups implies a measured difference is more likely to be due to treatment effects instead of interpatient variability
Crossover Design example
- In a study to assess the efficacy of ARB for the
treatment of hypertension, 800 patients are
randomized into two groups of 400 patients. One
group is treated with an ARB and the other treated
with furosemide and followed for 6 months.
- After a washout period, 400 patients received the
same study drug in a reverse order
Crossover design Advantages
A smaller number of patients is required since
the same patient groups receive both treatments
—Relatively less expensive
The ability to analyze patients both within
groups as well as between groups
—Within groups: baseline factors (age, gender
differences) that could influence the results are
eliminated because patients serve as their own
control group.
Crossover design Disadvantages
- Time involved for a crossover design is longer than other design types
- More dropouts because of time involved.
- Study design is very sensitive to drop outs since small number of patients involved.
- Period effects
- Sequence effects
- Carry over effects
Time Series Design(Before and After)
- Patients are studied before the experimental drug is given. After the drug is given for a certain amount of time, the patients are evaluated again to determine the effects of the drug
- More than one drug can be tested with this type of study design by continuing to administer drugs in sequence.
Time Series Design(Before and After)
- Advantages
- Certain factors which could influence the
study are eliminated (age, gender
differences, etc.)
- Patients serve as their own controls so
smaller number of patients are needed (as
compared to parallel design)
Time Series Design(Before and After)
- Disadvantages
- The disease/condition being treated can change over time, unrelated to the drug treatment.
- Carry-over effects could occur.
Causes of a carry-over effect
- Drugs with a long elimination half-life
- Drugs with active metabolites (esp. active
metabolites with long half-lives)
- Drugs whose effects on the disease state being
treated persist after the drugs themselves are
eliminated from the body (lipophillic drugs)