Evidence

0.0(0)
Studied by 2 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/70

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

71 Terms

1
New cards

FRE 606(b)(1)

A juror may not testify about any statement about or incident that occurred during deliberations, the effect of anything on any juror's vote, OR any juror’s mental processes concerning the verdict or indictment.

2
New cards

FRE 606(b)(2)

A juror may testify about any statement or incident that occurred during deliberations if it relates to extraneous prejudicial information, an outside influence, or a mistake on the verdict form

3
New cards

FRE 402

Relevant evidence is admissible unless the Constitution, a federal statute, the FRE, or other SCOTUS rules provide otherwise

4
New cards

FRE 401

Evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence, and the fact is of consequence in determining the action

5
New cards

FRE 403

A judge should exclude evidence if its relevance (i.e. probative value) is substantially outweighed by the risk of unfair prejudice, confusion, or undue delay

6
New cards

FRE 407

Evidence of a subsequent remedial measure is inadmissible to prove negligence, culpable conduct, or a product defect. But the court may admit this evidence for another purpose, such as impeachment or, if disputed, proving ownership, control, or the feasibility of precautionary measures.

7
New cards

Doctrine of curative admissibility

Parties cannot use a specialized relevance rule to create a misconception in the courtroom. If they do, opposing counsel can use the specialized evidence to dispel the misconception

8
New cards

FRE 408

Evidence of a settlement offer or statements made during settlement negotiations is inadmissible to prove liability or to impeach a witness for contradictory testimony. However, settlements and settlement negotiations are admissible for all other purposes, including to establish witness bias

9
New cards

FRE 409

Evidence of an offer to pay someone’s medical expenses is inadmissible to prove liability. However, the rule does not cover incidental statements made in close proximity to the offer to pay medical expenses

10
New cards

FRE 411

Evidence that a party possesses liability insurance is inadmissible if offered to suggest that the party was negligent or acted wrongfully. However, the existence of liability insurance is admissible for all other purposes, including to establish witness bias, ownership, or control

11
New cards

FRE 410

Evidence of a withdrawn guilty plea, a nolo contendere (no contest) plea, or a statement made in the course of plea discussions is inadmissible to prove anything against the defendant who participated. However, the existence of a plea agreement or statements made during plea negotiations are admissible for fairness concerns if the Doctrine of Curative Admissibility is implicated or to establish perjury if the statement was under oath, on record, and with counsel

12
New cards

FRE 404(a)(1)

Evidence of a person's general character is inadmissible if it is simply being used to demonstrate that the person acted in accordance with that general character at some later point in time

13
New cards

FRE 404(b)(1)

Specific evidence of a crime, wrongdoing, or other past act is inadmissible if it is introduced in an attempt to demonstrate that the person acted in accordance with that past act at some later point in time

14
New cards

FRE 404(b)(2)

Character evidence may be admissible for another purpose, such as proving motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake, or lack of accident

15
New cards

Knowledge exception

Applicable when the current case/crime requires a specialized skill set AND the other event trying to be introduced demonstrates that the defendant has that skill set

16
New cards

Motive Exception

Applicable when an earlier act is inextricably intertwined with a current case, such that the introduction of the past act is essential for understanding the defendant’s mental state in the current case

17
New cards

Identity Exception

Applicable when we have two or more acts that are so unique and so similar that they had to have been committed by the same individual and if we have evidence that the defendant committed one of those acts, that necessarily implies that the defendant also committed the second unique act

18
New cards

Narrative Integrity

Two or more acts are inextricably intertwined such that the earlier act is essential to telling a complete story of the charged offense

19
New cards

Absence of Mistake/Lack of Accident Exception

Applies where a series of the same accidents continue to occur (despite our expectation that a reasonable person would be increasingly cautious against them), thus suggesting that the harm is, in fact no accident at all

20
New cards

FRE 404(a)(2)

In criminal cases, a defendant may “open the door” to the admission of character and propensity evidence to demonstrate a pertinent character trait of the defendant, the pertinent character trait of the victim, or that the victim was the first aggressor in a homicide case

21
New cards

FRE 404(a)(2)(A)

In a criminal case, a defendant controls whether (and what type of) propensity evidence may be introduced regarding that defendant’s own character. If she so chooses, a defendant may open the door and introduce evidence putting a pertinent character trait of the defendant into issue (that is, into dispute). Only once a defendant has “opened the door” (and never before) can the prosecution then introduce evidence to rebut the defendant’s evidence regarding her character

22
New cards

FRE 404(a)(2)(B)

In a criminal case, a defendant controls whether (and what type of) propensity evidence may be introduced regarding a victim’s character. If she so chooses, a defendant may “open the door” and introduce evidence putting a pertinent character trait of the victim into issue (that is, into dispute). Only once a defendant has opened the door (and never before) can the prosecution then introduce evidence either to rebut the defendant’s claims regarding the victim’s character or to show that the defendant has that very same character trait

23
New cards

FRE 404(a)(2)(C)

In a homicide case, a defendant controls whether propensity evidence may be introduced regarding the victim’s character for peacefulness. If she so chooses, a defendant may open the door for introduction of the victim’s character for peacefulness simply by suggesting that the victim was the first aggressor in a homicide case and, therefore, the defendant was acting in self-defense. The defendant doesn’t have to introduce character evidence here, only has to say the victim was a “first aggressor” to permit the prosecution to introduce character evidence of the victim’s peacefulness

24
New cards

FRE 405

On direct examination, a witness may only elucidate pertinent character traits through reputation or opinion testimony. But if D opened the door on direct, that door remains open. On cross-examination, character evidence may be explored through testimony regarding reputation, opinion, or specific acts. Referencing specific acts on cross examination is allowed to test whether a character witness truly has a complete picture about the individual she is testifying about

25
New cards

FRE 607

Any party (including the party who called the witness) may “open the door” and attack a witness’s credibility. That is, any party may attack a witness using character or propensity evidence to portray them as a generally dishonest person. Importantly, the second island only applies to attacking witnesses and only applies to this one character trait – a witness’s character for truthfulness

26
New cards

FRE 608

Any party may introduce evidence challenging a witness’s character for truthfulness/demonstrating their character for dishonesty. On direct examination, a party may only elucidate a witness’s character for dishonesty through reputation or opinion testimony (unless it falls under Rule 609). On cross-examination, evidence of a witness’s character for dishonesty may be explored through testimony regarding reputation, opinion, or specific acts. Referencing specific acts on cross examination is allowed to test either whether the witness is a liar generally or whether the witness truly has a complete picture about the individual she is testifying about. A party must first open the door and attack a witness’s character for truthfulness before one can introduce evidence bolstering the general trustworthiness of that witness

27
New cards

FRE 609(a)(2)

When a party attempts to introduce a witness’s past criminal conviction to challenge that witness’s character for truthfulness, the admissibility of that past conviction will depend on the nature and timing of the offense. If the offense involves a crime of dishonesty, the offense must be admitted. A crime qualifies only if it requires the defendant to affirmatively lie or make a false statement in the commission of the crime

28
New cards

FRE 609(a)(1)(A)

If the offense involves a felony conviction committed by a witness who is not the defendant within the last ten years, the offense is admissible if it survives normal Rule 403 balancing.

29
New cards

FRE 609(a)(1)(B)

If the offense involves a felony conviction committed by the defendant within the last ten years, the offense is admissible if the probative value of the evidence outweighs its prejudicial effect to that defendant. Only admissible if the probative value outweighs the unfair prejudice. Ties under the test go towards inadmissibility. Analyze the Brewer factors here

30
New cards

FRE 609(b)

If the offense did not occur within the last ten years (meaning that it is stale), the offense is admissible only if its probative value substantially outweighs its prejudicial effect and the proponent gives an adverse party reasonable written notice of the intent to use it so that the party has a fair opportunity to contest its use. Only admissible if the probative value substantially outweighs the unfair prejudice. THEN apply Brewer factors if the defendant is the witness. Calculate staleness based on the day the defendant was released

31
New cards

FRE 609(d)

If the offense was committed by a juvenile, it is admissible only against a non-defendant and only if it is “necessary to fairly determine guilt or innocence” at a criminal trial.

32
New cards

Brewer factors

The nature of the previous conviction (goes to its probative value–if not a crime evincing dishonesty, then probative value is low)

The time of the previous conviction and the defendant’s subsequent history (goes to probative value–if the crime took place long ago and the defendant’s record is clean since then, probative value is low)

The similarity between the previous conviction and the present crime for which the defendant is accused (goes to unfair prejudice–the more similar the crimes are, the higher the unfair prejudice)

The importance of the defendant’s testimony (goes to unfair prejudice–we do not want to chill essential defendant testimony)

The centrality of credibility (goes to probative value—if credibility is unimportant in the case, then the probative value is low)

33
New cards

FRE 801(a)

“Statement” means a person’s oral assertion, written assertion, or nonverbal conduct, if the person intended it as an assertion.

34
New cards

FRE 801(b)

“Declarant” means the person who made the statement.

35
New cards

FRE 801(c)

“Hearsay” means a statement that: (1) the declarant does not make while testifying at the current trial or hearing; and (2) a party offers in evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted in the statement.

36
New cards

FRE 802

Hearsay is not admissible unless a federal statute, the FRE, or other rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise

37
New cards

Three hearsay questions

Was the statement that a party is now attempting to introduce originally made by a person outside of this courtroom? Is the statement an assertion? Is the statement now being introduced for the truth of the matter asserted?

38
New cards

Non-truth permissible purposes for hearsay statements

Effect on the listener, declarant’s state of mind, or impeachment

39
New cards

FRE 805

Hearsay within hearsay is not excluded by the rule against hearsay if each part of the combined statements conforms with an exception to the rule

40
New cards

FRE 104(a)

Any time there is a question about whether a hearsay exception’s element is satisfied (i.e., is it more likely than not that the hearsay exception applies), the judge will make the determination based on the preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not)

41
New cards

FRE 801(d)(2)(A)

A hearsay statement is admissible at trial if it was made by the opposing party

42
New cards

FRE 801(d)(2)(B)

A hearsay statement is admissible at trial if it was adopted by the opposing party. To determine if the adoption is appropriate, we must ask four questions: Did the party opponent hear and understand a statement that purported to speak on its behalf? Was the party opponent at liberty to disagree with the statement? Did the circumstances naturally call for the party opponent to disagree with the statement if it was false? Did the party opponent fail to disagree with the statement?

43
New cards

FRE 801(d)(2)(D)

A hearsay statement is admissible at trial if it was made by an agent or employee of the opposing party who was acting in the scope of that business relationship (at the time the statement was made). Evaluate under 104(a)

44
New cards

FRE 801(d)(2)(E)

A hearsay statement is admissible at trial if it was made by an opposing party’s coconspiratory in furtherance of their joint conspiracy. Three preconditions must be met. A conspiracy must exist at the time of the out of court statement. The conspiracy must include both the declarant and the party against whom the statement is offered. The declarant must speak during the course of and in furtherance of the conspiracy. A judge determines whether the elements have been met using 104a

45
New cards

FRE 801(d)(2)(C)

A hearsay statement is admissible at trial if it was made by someone who is authorized to make statements for an opposing party

46
New cards

FRE 801(d)(1)(A)

A hearsay statement is admissible if it is inconsistent with a witness’s current testimony, the witness is testifying at the current trial (meaning that they can now be cross examined), and the previous (inconsistent) hearsay statement was made when the witness was under oath

47
New cards

FRE 801(d)(1)(B)

Under Rule 801(d)(1)(B), a hearsay statement that is consistent with a witness’s current testimony is admissible if the witness is testifying at the current trial, the hearsay statement is offered to rebut an express or implicit allegation that the witness fabricated testimony due to an improper influence or motive, and the past consistent statement was made before the improper motive to fabricate emerged

48
New cards

FRE 801(d)(1)(C)

A hearsay statement by a witness is admissible if the witness is testifying at the current trial and the statement identifies a person as someone the witness previously observed

49
New cards

FRE 804(a)

A witness is unavailable if she refuses to fully participate at trial because of stubbornness, the assertion of a privilege, lack of memory, death, illness, or mere absence

50
New cards

FRE 804(b)(1)

Former testimony by a witness (if hearsay) is nonetheless admissible if the witness is currently unavailable under Rule 804(a); the testimony was given at a trial, hearing, or lawful deposition; and the testimony is offered against a party (or a predecessor in interest) who previously had the opportunity and a similar motive to challenge the testimony by direct or cross-examination. Only in a civil case, the declarant’s statement need not have been subject to cross by the same opposing party. Instead, if a declarant’s statement was subject to cross by a “predecessor in interest” that will also suffice

51
New cards

FRE 804(b)(3)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the declarant is currently unavailable under Rule 804(a) and a reasonable person in the declarant’s position would not have made the statement unless they believed it to be true because the statement was contrary to the declarant’s monetary interests, invalidated the declarant’s claims against someone else, or exposed the declarant to civil or criminal liability. In a criminal case, the statement is supported by corroborating circumstances. This is an objective test: Would a reasonable person in your position recognize that admitting to the crime would expose them to legal liability?

52
New cards

FRE 804(b)(2)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the declarant is currently unavailable under Rule 804(a), the statement is offered in a homicide or civil case, the statement was made when the declarant subjectively believed their death to be imminent as determined by the judge under 104(a), and the statement is about the cause or circumstances of their death

53
New cards

FRE 804(b)(6)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the declarant is currently unavailable under Rule 804(a); the witness refuses to fully participate at trial because of stubbornness, the assertion of a privilege, lack of memory, death, illness, or mere absence; and the statement is offered against a party who wrongfully and intentionally caused the declarant’s unavailability as a witness. For this rule to apply, a party must make a witness unavailable for the specific reason of preventing them from testifying at some proceeding

54
New cards

FRE 803(1)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the statement describes or explains an event that a witness perceived and the statement was made during or immediately after the witness perceived the event in question. The statement must come within seconds (not minutes or hours) after the event in question

55
New cards

FRE 803(2)

Under Rule 803(2), a hearsay statement is admissible if the statement relates to a startling event, the statement was made while the witness was still under the stress caused by that event (can be minutes and perhaps hours after the startling event, so long as the declarant is still under the stress caused by that event). This is a subjective test.

56
New cards

FRE 803(3)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the statement regards what the declarant was planning to do at the time the statement was made OR the statement regards what the declarant was feeling at the time the statement was made

57
New cards

Hillmon View of 803(3)

A hearsay statement that regards what the declarant was planning to do at the time the statement was made (i.e., it regards the declarant’s motives or intentions) may also mention the actions or intentions of third parties without falling afoul of 803(3)

58
New cards

House Judiciary View of 803(3)

The committee intends that Rule 803(3) to be construed to limit the doctrine of Hillmon so as to render statements of intent by a declarant admissible only to prove his future conduct, not the future conduct of another person

59
New cards

FRE 803(4)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the statement was made for the purposes of obtaining medical treatment or a medical diagnosis and the statement describes either the declarant’s medical history or symptoms

60
New cards

FRE 803(5)

A hearsay statement is admissible if the declarant had firsthand knowledge of an event, the declarant wrote down her recollections of that event soon after the time it occurred, the declarant can no longer remember the details of her initial observation, and he declarant vouches for the authenticity of the recorded recollection during the current trial

61
New cards

FRE 803(6)

Under Rule 803(6), a business record (that constitutes hearsay) is admissible if the record was made soon after the underlying incident that is the basis for the record, the type of record at issue was made during the regular operations of the business, the business at issue normally makes this type of record, a custodian from the business testifies (or certifies) that the record meets the four aforementioned requirements, and there is no indication that the record lacks trustworthiness

62
New cards

FRE 803(8)

A public record is admissible if it describes EITHER the activities or operations of a public office OR a matter observed by a public official who has a legal duty to report her findings OR factual findings from a legal authorized investigation by a public official acting in the course and scope of her role AND there is no indication that the public record is untrustworthy. In a criminal case, Rule 803(8)(a)(iii) cannot be used by the prosecution. In a criminal case Rule 803(8)(a)(ii) cannot be used to admit a report created by law enforcement personnel

63
New cards

FRE 807

A hearsay statement that fails to meet any other exception is nonetheless admissible if the hearsay statement is supported by sufficient guarantees of trustworthiness and the statement is essential/necessary

64
New cards

Confrontation Clause

Under the Sixth Amendment, in a criminal case, statements admitted by the prosecution and against the accused are inadmissible (even if they fit within a hearsay exception) unless the declarant appears in court and is subject to cross examination by the defendant

65
New cards

Crawford Confrontation Clause requirements

Testimonial statements admitted by the prosecution against the accused are inadmissible, even if they fit within a hearsay exception, unless (1) the declarant appears in court and is subject to cross-examination by the defendant, or (2) the declarant is unavailable and the defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine

66
New cards

If a statement is deemed “non-testimonial,” will it ever fall afoul of the Confrontation Clause?

No, under Whorton v. Bockting, statements that are non-testimonial will not be barred by the Confrontation Clause

67
New cards

Is the testimonial bar absolute? If a statement is deemed “testimonial,” is the declarant always required to appear in court and subject himself to cross-examination?

No, under Giles v. California, a hearsay statement that is admitted under Rule 804(b)(6) will not give rise to any Confrontation Clause problems because the defendant has forfeited his right to cross-examine the witness by intentionally and wrongfully preventing her from appearing

68
New cards

FRE 701

Lay witnesses (i.e., witnesses who do not profess to have an expert skill set) can only provide opinion testimony if that opinion testimony meets three elements: it is rationally based on the witness’s firsthand perception, it is helpful to the jury’s fact-finding responsibility, and it is not based on scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge (which is the subject of Rule 702)

69
New cards

FRE 702

Expert testimony must be provided by a witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, help the trier of fact understand the evidence or determine a fact in issue, be based on sufficient facts or data, be the product of reliable principles and methods, AND constitute a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts at issue in a case

70
New cards

The Daubert Standard

Judges weigh flexible factors, none of which is required: whether the method is testable (falsifiable), whether it has been peer-reviewed, its known or potential error rate, whether there are objective standards controlling its use (which your professor calls the most important factor), and general acceptance, which is now just one factor among several

71
New cards

FRE 703

Expert witnesses can only base their testimony on their own personal knowledge of facts or data, evidence presented at trial, hypotheticals presented at trial, or any source of information reasonably relied upon by experts in the field