1/74
Case, Holding
Katz v. US
Test:
1. Individual has a subjective expectation of privacy
2.Expectation is one society would deem reasonable
If expectation is violated, government has conducted a SEARCH
Florida v. RIley
MAJORITY: Open Fields Doctrine applies, if something can be seen from helicopter in navigable airspace, there is no expectation of privacy
DISSENT: The general public does not have helicopters! In no way did Riley knowingly express his property to the public
Smith v. Maryland
Third Party Doctrine applies: since we knowingly give a third party (the phone company) our information (who we call), there is no reasonable expectation of privacy from the government (pen register)
California v. Greenwood
Third Party Doctrine: Taking out the trash is considered by society to be surrendering it to the public, therefore no reasonable expectation of privacy
US v. White
Testimony obtained from an agent wearing a wire does NOT need a warrant, there is no expectation of privacy in disclosing criminal activity to a third party
Kyllo v. US
MAJORITY: If the government uses technology (Thermal Scanner) not available to the public to gain information from inside the home, that is a search. The home enjoys the MOST privacy
DISSENT: Sensing heat is decently normal for human beings to do, this was passive
US v. Jones
Scaliaās expansion of search doctrine: If there is no physical trespass, use Katz/reasonable expectation of privacy. If there is physicial trespass, Katz might not be the right test
Here a search because government physically attached device to car
Carpenter v. US
Using cell phone data to track citizensā locations is a search. We have an expectation of privacy in our physical location
Florida v. Jardines*
MAJORITY: Considered dog sniff on the porch to be a search because handler allowed dog to physcially invade property
DISSENT: The trespass doctrine should have no place in the court
Spinelli v. US
Test for obtaining a warrant based on information from informants:
Basis of knowledge - how did informant come to know this?
Veracity - reliability, credibility, truthfulness
Illinois v. Gates
1983 - New test for informants: totality of the circumstances
informant tips still must provide substantive basis, but requiring a strong basis and veracity may be unrealistic - emphasis on flexibility
*Maryland v. Pringle
Probable Cause requires reasonable belief arrestee did crime they are being arrested for
Richards v. Wisconsin
No-knock warrants must be analyzed on case by case, totality of circumstances basis
Standard: Cops must have reasonable suspicion knocking would be dangerous and/or futile
US v. Watson
Arrest in public only requires probable cause - no warrant
Payton v. New York
To go into someoneās house to arrest them, the cops need an arrest warrant AND probable cause the suspect is at home at the moment
Stegald v. US
To arrest someone in someone elseās home, cops need a valid arrest warrant for the suspect
Protecting the right of a homeowner: Cops would need valid search warrant for their home, OR probable cause to believe suspect is in their home before they can search
Chimel v. California
Reasonable for a cop to search a person upon arrest, and their immediate area to protect officer safety or against destruction of evidence - scope must be tied to circumstances
US v. Robinson
Vale v. Louisiana
Maryland v. Boyd
New York v. Betton
Arizona v. Gant
Riley v. California
California v. Carney
California v. Avecedo
Wyoming v. Houghton
Collins v. Virginia
US v. Leon
Nix v. Williams
Utah v. Strieff
Betts v. Brady
Gideon v. Wainwright
Ashcraft v. Tennessee
Spano v. New York
Massiah v. US
Escobedo v Illinois
US v. Henry
Kuhlmann
Miranda v. Arizona
Berkemer v. McCary
Miranda is a bright line rule for all custodial interrogations
Test: If a reasonable person would understand they are not free to leave, a warning is required
But, a coversation with the cop that pulled you is not considered custodial, so no Miranda needed for a routine roadside stop
JDB v. North Carolina
Rhode Island v. Innis
handicapped children
Illinois v. Perkins
Undercover cop in the prison
Miranda warnings not required if suspect is unaware they are talking to a cop and gives a voluntary statement
Michigan v. Mosely
fresh warning - fact specific so knowing facts will probably help
Edwards v. Arizona
Once suspect asks for a lawyer, all questioning must immediately cease, may only start questioning again if the lawyer is present, or if suspect clearly waives right to counsel by initiating questioning
Davis v. US
Clear and unambiguous
Suspect must unambiguously request counsel for right to be invoked, cops are not required to stop interrogation unless suspect clearly, explicitly requests a lawyer
Maryland v. Shatzer
break in custody, but he was still in custody
North Carolina v. Butler
Implied waiver
Waiver of Miranda can be implied as long as facts show suspect intelligently and knowingly waived right to remain silent
Moran v. Burbine
cops didnāt call the lawyer back, and didnāt tell suspect a lawyer tried to get in contact, he waived his right technically
Bergheis v. Thompkins
this case is stupid
NY v. Quarles
Public safety exception to Miranda warning - if there is an exigent, urgent threat to others, police can restrain suspect without giving Miranda in order to resolve the threat
US v. Patane
A mere Miranda violation does not immediately poison the tree
Evidence discovered as a result of defective Miranda confession (as long as not coerced) it outside the scope of self-incrimination privilege
Brewer v. Williams
judicial proceedings applied to these facts
Oregon v. Elstad
Cat out of the bag argument - post warning confession
Missouri v. Seibert
āMid-streamā Miranda warnings
Terry v. Ohio