1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Independence for audit and review arrangements
-Assurance engagement ( Audit or Review )
-Mainly deals with management decisions
-During the engagement period and financial period being audited
INDEPENDENCE OF MIND
The state of mind that permits the expression of a conclusion without being affected by influences that compromise professional judgement , thereby allowing an individual to act with integrity and to exercise objectivity and professional scepticism .
INDEPENDENCE IN APPEARANCE
The avoidance of facts and circumstances that are so significant that a reasonable informed third party ( RTP ) would be likely to conclude that a firm or an audit or assurance team member's integrity , objectivity or professional scepticism has been compromised
FEES - RELATIVE SIZE
THREAT:
Self - interest or intimidation threat might be created for independence ( objectivity ) when the total audit fees of a client represent a large part of the firm's total income .
FACTORS:
Operating structure of the firm
Whether the firm is well established or new
Significance of the client qualitatively and or quantitatively to the firm .
SAFEGUARDS:
Increase the client base
Have an appropriate reviewer
OVERDUE FEES
THREAT:
Self - interest threat might be created for independence if the fees are due by the client and not settled before the auditor's report for the following year is issued .
FACTORS:
Whether the overdue fees are regarded as a loan to the client
SAFEGUARDS:
Obtaining partial payment of overdue fees
Having an additional professional accountant who was not on the audit team who reviewed the work .
Gifts and Hospitality
THREAT:
Self - interest , familiarity or intimidation threat to the compliance with the fundamental principles of integrity , objectivity and professional behaviour .
FACTORS:
The intention behind the gift .
The nature , frequency and value
The timing of when it is given
Whether it is customary or cultural or an ancillary part of the service
The degree of transparency
Whether it is limited to the recipient or available to the broader group
SAFEGUARDS:
Do not accept gift Policy to prevent accepting gifts
Any gifts accepted must be approved by firm's quality review panel and senior management must be informed
Amending or terminating the business relationship with the client .
Financial interest SHARES
EXPLANATION:
Financial interests may include direct and material indirect financial interest in the client held by an audit team member , immediate family members of the team or the audit firm .
Includes owning shares and collective investments .
THREAT:
Creates a self - interest threat to independence .
FACTORS:
The role of the person holding the interest
Whether it is a direct or indirect interest
The materiality of the interest
SAFEGUARDS:
Selling the direct financial interest or selling a sufficient portion of material indirect financial interest in order to make it immaterial to the accountant and their close or immediate family .
Having another professional accountant review the work done by the accountant with the interest .
Removing the individual who is faced with self - interest threats .
Loans and guarantees
EXPLANATION:
This applies to the firm , individuals on the audit team and their immediate family members .
If the audit client is a bank or similar institution : The firm may only have a loan or deposits or a brokerage account unless it is made under normal lending conditions and procedures .
However , if it is material to the client it may still create a self- interest threat .
If the audit client is not a bank or similar institution : The firm shall not have a loan from the client or any director or officer of the client unless the loan is immaterial to the firm and client .
THREAT:
Creates a self - interest threat to independence .
FACTORS:
The materiality of the loan or guarantee to the individual and their immediate family members .
SAFEGUARDS:
Having the work reviewed by an appropriate reviewer who is not an audit team member and is not a beneficiary to the loan .
Business relationships
EXPLANATION:
Examples include :
-Financial interest in a joint venture
-Arrangements to combine one or more products or services
-Distributing or marketing arrangements for the client or firm
THREAT:
Creates a self - interest or intimidation threat to independence if there is a close business relationship between the client , management or the immediate family of the audit team member .
FACTORS:
The materiality of the financial interest and , The significance of the business relationship
SAFEGUARDS:
Having the work reviewed by an appropriate reviewer who is not an audit team member and is not a beneficiary to the loan .
Eliminating or reducing the magnitude of the transaction .
Removing the individual from the audit team .
Family and personal relationships
THREAT:
Self - interest , familiarity or intimidation threat might be created by family and personal relationships threat to independence ( objectivity ) .
FACTORS:
The nature of the relationship between the audit team member and close family member .
The position held by the close family member .
The role of the audit team member .
SAFEGUARDS:
Remove the individuals from the audit team
Structuring the responsibilities of the audit team so that the team member does not deal with matters relating to close family members .
ADDITIONAL:
Close or immediate family members of an audit team member is :
-A director or officer of the audit client
-An employee in a position to exert significant influence over the preparation of client's accounting records or the financial statements .
Recent services with an audit client
THREAT:
Creates a self - interest , self review and familiarity threat if an audit team member has recently served as a director , officer or employee of the audit client .
FACTORS:
The position of the individual held with the client
The length of time since the individual left the client
The role of the audit team member
SAFEGUARDS:
The audit team should not include an individual who at any time during or before the audit report served as a director , officer or employee to the client where they would have been able to exert significant influence on the decisions .
Have an appropriate reviewer review the work performed by the audit team member .
Serving as a director or officer of an audit client
EXPLANATION:
The Code forbids an employee or partner of an audit firm to act as an officer or director of an audit client
They shall also not serve as a company secretary for an audit client of the firm . ( See exceptions )
THREAT:
Director or officer : Self - review and self - interest threats for objectivity are created .
Secretary : Self - review and advocacy threats .
Therefore , it is too significant for a safeguard to bring the threat to an acceptable level .
EXCEPTIONS:
Specifically allowed by local laws and professional rules and , Management makes all the decisions and Company secretary's responsibilities are limited to routine and administrative tasks .
Employment with an audit client
EXPLANATION:
A significant connection remains between the firm and the individual , unless :
-The individual is not entitled to any benefits or payments
-Any amount owed to the individual is not material .
-The individual no longer participates in any related business activities .
THREAT:
Creates a self - interest , self - review and familiarity threat if the member was a director , officer or an employee with significant influence .
FACTORS:
The position of the individual held with the client
The involvement of the individual in the audit team
The length of time since being a member of the team
The former position of the individual within the team or firm .
SAFEGUARDS:
Modifying the audit plan
Having an appropriate reviewer to check the former team's work
Assigning to the audit team to individuals who have sufficient experience relative to the individual who joined the client
Temporary personnel assignments
EXPLANATION:
A firm shall not loan personnel to an audit client unless It is for a short period of time
The personnel are involved in providing non - assurance services
The personnel do not assume management responsibility
THREAT:
The loan of personnel to an audit client creates a self - review , advocacy or familiarity threat .
FACTORS:
It may be acceptable if the secondment is only for a short time or ,
If the staff member is not involved in management or non - assurance activities
In certain secondments , the firm becomes too closely linked to the audit client - in which case it should not take place .
SAFEGUARDS:
Conducting an additional review of the work performed by the loaned person to address a self - review threat .
Not including the loaned personnel as an audit team member to address a familiarity or advocacy threat .
Long association with audit client
THREAT:
Familiarity and self - interest threats for objectivity will be created if person is on audit for a long period of time .
FACTORS:
The length of time that the individual has been on the team
The role of the individual on the team
The extent work is directed , reviewed and supervised by senior personnel ability to influence outcome of audit closeness of relationship nature , frequency and extent of interaction
Whether the nature and complexity of the client's accounting and reporting issues have changed
Whether the client's management team has changed structural changes in client's organisation impacting nature , frequency and extent of interaction
SAFEGUARDS:
Changing role of individual on audit team or nature and extent of tasks Rotate senior staff off the engagement team Appropriate reviewer
Regular independent internal or external quality reviews
Provision of non - assurance services to an audit client
THREAT:
Creates a self - review , self - interest and advocacy threat for objectivity and independence .
Remember if it is so significant that safeguards cannot reduce the threat , the engagement must be rejected .
FACTORS:
Type of client ( audit client , public interest etc. )
Type of non - assurance services to be provided ( e.g. tax services )
Who provides the non - assurance service
The extent to which the non - assurance service impacts the financial statements and internal controls
The level of expertise of the client's employees with respect to the service provided
SAFEGUARDS:
The person performing the services may not be on the audit team
Procedures and policies prohibit participation in management decisions
Source documents must be prepared by client
Audit committee must approve appointment members of the team
A senior staff member with experience and who is not on the audit team must review the work of that person .
Part 4A : Independence for audit and review arrangements
410 Fees
420 Gifts and Hospitality
510 Financial interest Loans and guarantees
520 Business relationships
521 Family and personal relationships
522 Recent services with an audit client
523 Serving as a director or officer of an audit client
524 Employment with audit client
525 Temporary personnel assignments
540 Long association with audit client
600 Provision of non assurance services to an audit client