1/123
Health Psychology - Chapter 9
Healthcare provider
professional who provides health services to individuals
nurses
physician assistants
other healthcare professionals
Nurses
trained healthcare provider who provides care to sick/injuries people
many different types encountered in healthcare journey
advanced practice nursing
nurse practitioners
Advanced practice nursing
umbrella term for nurses who have completed education beyond the basic 4 years of nursing education
more advanced responsibilities in patient care
Nurse practitioners
focus on health promotion and education
normally screen a patient before physician goes in
becoming more common in canada
have additional training in areas for
assessment
diagnosis
treatment
can order test and prescribe medication
Telehealth
providing care through communication technology
video calls
phone calls
Why telehealth is important in canada
many rural/remote communities so can make it more convenient and improve access to services
Issues with telehealth
need to have good internet access and connection to access
communities without this are not able to use these services
Physician assistants
trained healthcare professionals who can perform many medical services under supervision of a physician
common responsibilities
take patient history
conduct physical examinations
diagnose and treat medical conditions
write prescriptions
assist with surgical procedures
not replacing physicians, just helping them
Other healthcare professionals
normally work in inter-professional teams
physiotherapists
helps with movement and recovery
social workers
helps with social and personally challenges that may affect their health
occupational therapists
helps improve ability to function and do everyday activities
nutritionists
provides guidance about food and nutrition
psychologists
help treat psychological issues
Inter-professional teams
brings together healthcare providers from different areas of healthcare
good for patients with complex/specialized health issues
each person contributes their expertise
allows patients to receive more comprehensive care
Problems with inter-professional teams
can create communication problems
different providers may not communicate with each other
info about diagnoses may not be shared
treatment plans may not be properly coordinated
can cause quality of care to decrease
Common complaints in healthcare providers
too much medical jargon
not enough feedback
impersonal care
Jargon
technical language that the patient does not understand
How patients judge the quality of their care
do not have medical knowledge so they cannot notice small mistakes, so not based on the quality
judge based on things they can observe
the way care is delivered
how the provider communicates with them
Issues with poor patient-provider communication
patients not following the treatment plans
patients failing to share important info
worse health outcomes
Patient consumerism
idea that patients should be involved in decisions about their health
Why patient consumerism is increasing
self-determination theory
autonomy is one of the 3 basic psychological needs
people feel the need to have control over decisions
Factors that have caused an increase in patient consumerism
patients have become more proactive about their health and more likely to view themselves as a consumer of healthcare products/services
self-care products becoming more available
society’s strong emphasis on maintaining good health
social media provides information about health and encourages people to take care of themselves
How patients consumerism affects treatment
providers need to grain patients cooperation instead of expecting them to follow instructions
if they do not want to follow the treatment plan then it will not be successful
providers need to sell the treatment in an appealing way to gain patients cooperation
more likely to follow the treatment if patient feels like they had control over the decisions rather than forced by provider
Internet and patient consumerism
health information is easily available
used to research health concerns and then bring that info to a healthcare provider to talk about it
can be inaccurate to the specific conditions on the patient
can increase anxiety
Information prescriptions
providers giving patients reliable links to health information
helps find trustworthy source rather than misleading online sources
Typical doctor’s appointment
short
tight time frame
stranger
may be uncomfortable to share info with them
Conflict between patient and providers at doctor’s appointments
patients need for support/time to feel understood and providers need to manage time to see many people
can create strain on communication
somethings that make it harder
patients using alternative treatments that could interact with traditional treatments
patient may think other symptoms are more important
patient may need more time to explain concerns and to receive emotional support
Structure of the healthcare delivery system in canada
publicly funded!
talk to primary care physician first
if needed they refer you to secondary services
Problems with the structure of healthcare delivery system in canada
if you do not have a primary care physician then you cannot get access as easily to secondary healthcare services
not able to see primary care physician on the same day as complaint
can sometimes not get an appointment until a week later
Reasons for issues with access to healthcare
low physician-patient ratio
too many patients so they cannot provide timely appointments
cannot access diagnostic test for patients
leads to even more delays
Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM)
treatments that are not considered typical or conventional medical practices
massage therapy
chiropractic
acupuncture
provided by healthcare professionals or self-care
Specific groups that us CAM
breast cancer patients
people with chronic conditions
females
middle-aged people
highly educated
because these people are more proactive with their health
Why people use CAM
even with extra cost, still lots of benefits
longer consultation
greater sense of control
greater patient satisfaction
Changes in philosophy behind healthcare delivery in canada
increased use of CAM
more women entering medical professions
changes to stereotype of physicians as dominant authority figures
Holistic health
health is a positive stats, not just the absence of disease
involves many influences
physical
psychological
social influences
puts responsibility on patient to achieve health through their
attitudes, behaviors, and beliefs
emphasizes the use of CAM, health education, and self-help
Impacts of holistic health on communication
improves communication between patients and providers
encourage more
egalitarian relationships
reciprocal relationships
makes patients feel more supported, empowered, and relieved
Egalitarian relationships
patients and provider are treated more equally rather than provider having authority
Reciprocal relationship
both patient and provider contribute to the relationship and share information
Behaviors of healthcare providers that negatively affect communication
not listening
use of jargon
baby talk
elderspeak
patient stereotype
Not listening and its affect on patient-provider communication
important information may be missed
providers do not receive all information needed to understand the patients condition
patients may be interrupted before they can explain their symptoms
Use of jargon and its affect on patient-provider communication
patients may misunderstand their diagnosis because the provider has not explain it in everyday language
could be used to discourage patients from asking too many questions
could be because they use these terms all day when talking to colleges who understand
Baby talk and its affect on patient-provider communication
assumes a patient has no knowledge about their illness and gives explanations that are overly simplistic
can make patients feel
like helpless kids
less capable of understanding their own healthcare
Elderspeak and its affect on patient-provider communication
similar to baby talk but targets older adults
calling patients “dear” or “sweetie”
suggests that older adults are not capable of understanding normal communication
can feel disrespectful and make them more likely to resist care
Patient stereotypes and its affect on patient-provider communication
indigenous patients
ethical similarities between patients and physicians
sexism
Stereotypes about indigenous patients and its affect on patient-provider communication
physicians may say they are passive, quite, and angry
assumptions negatively affect how patients are treated
Ethical similarities between patients and physicians and its affect on patient-provider communication
higher rate of satisfaction when the patient and physician are from the same ethical background
Sexism and its affect on patient-provider communication
can influence how patients are treatment
most times men are taken more seriously than women even when they have the same symptoms
Gender pay gap among physicians
male physicians earn on average 100,000$ more than female physicians
despite females having lover patient mortality rates
Behaviors of patients that negatively affect communication
neuroticism and anxiety
patient knowledge and access to information
different attitudes towards symptoms and pain
misleading information and fear of asking questions
Neuroticism and anxiety and their affects on patient-provider communication
neuroticism
can cause patients to exaggerate their symptoms
make harder for physicians to judge how serious condition is
anxiety
harder to concentrate
may struggle to remember or understand information given to them
Patient knowledge and access to information and their affects on patient-provider communication
language barriers
trouble understanding/speaking the language used by their provider may have trouble communicating
less understanding during appointments
access to internet
can give helpful health information that people who do not have access to it will miss out on
can also give patients misleading information
Different attitudes towards symptoms and pain and their affects on patient-provider communication
focus on different aspects of illness
patients - the pain they are experiencing is most important
providers - finding the underlying cause of the pain
patient may fee that provider is missing something or ignoring them
Misleading information and fear of asking questions and their affects of patient-provider communication
occurs when
patients provide misleading info
embarrassed or uncomfortable talking about it
providers may not get all the information they need
providers may incorrectly assume that patients do not want any more information if they are not asking questions
Lack of feedback and its affect on patient-provider communication
providers do not receive feedback about their appointments as patients do not normally return
treatment worked
treatment didn’t work and they went elsewhere
patient died
may avoid giving feedback because uncomfortable criticizing their physician
cannot properly evaluate the quality of their care and may continue to use poor communication in the future
Communication consequences
leads to negative health outcomes
patients who are dissatisfied may
be less likely to use medical services in the future
turn to CAM
less likely to tell provide they are using CAM
Why patients may hide their CAM use
alternative treatments may conflict with prescribed medical treatments
can create potential conflicts and negatively affect patient care
Main trait for someone to have good communication
their motivation and interest in people
not based on the person’s personality
Patient-centered communication
collaborative approach that prioritizes patients unique perspectives, values, and life circumstances
including patients in decisions about their healthcare
trying to understand the illness from the patients point of view
having an interest/motivation to talk to people
Training physicians to improve communication
teach skills that are
easy to learn
easy to put into practice
makes them use them in a more automatic, realistic, and useful way
Interview techniques used in communication training
the NURSE model
the WEMS model
The NURSE model
promotes empathy
naming
identify patients emotion
understanding
show you understand the patient’s perspective
respecting
recognize and respect the patient’s experience
supporting
offer support
exploring
ask about the patient’s feelings or concerns
The WEMS model
promotes active listening
waiting
giving the patient time to speak
echoing
repeat important words or phrases
mirroring
reflect the patient’s feelings or communication
summarizing
restate the main points to show understanding
Training patients to improve communication
focused on asking questions
helps to improve communication to lead to smoother treatment
preparing questions in advance
Patient preparing questions in advance
tend to be less anxious during the appointment
ask more questions overall
Providers encouraging questions
leads to patients asking more questions
improves
communication between patient and physician
patient’s satisfaction with the visit
patient’s sense of control over the situation
Treatment non-adherence
when a patient does not follow the behaviors or treatment recommended by their physician
can negatively affect health and prevent a patient from improving
Non-adherence in canada
most common form is
not taking prescription medications as prescribed
1/3 Canadians do not fill their prescriptions after receiving them
Adherence differences between illnesses
not the same for every condition
the type of illness and treatment can influence how likely someone is to follow their treatment plan
higher adherence
HIV
cancer
arthritis
gastrointestinal disorders
lower adherence
diabetes
sleep disorders
pulmonary disease
Measuring adherence
self-report data
treatment outcomes
appointment attendance
does counts
pharmacy records
medication event monitoring systems (MEMS)
biomarkers
Self-report data
patients report how well they follow treatment
easy and inexpensive to use
medical outcomes survey
uses a likert scale to measure levels of agreement
Problems with self-reports
social desirability bias
people changing their answers to make themselves look better or more socially acceptable
may make adherence appear higher than it actually is
Treatment outcomes
checking whether the patients health improves after giving them a treatment
Appointment attendance
counting how many appointments the patient attends
more = better adherence
Does count
checking how much medication has been taken
Pharmacy records
checking whether prescriptions have been filled or not
Medication event monitoring system (MEMS)
systems used to monitor medication-taking behavior
Biomarkers
measuring biological indicators that may show whether a treatment is being followed
Why other methods adherence measuring methods can be inaccurate
patients may miss an appointment for work or travel difficulties, not because they are not following treatment
other disease factors may affect biological measurements
no single method of measuring adherence is perfect
Creative non-adherence
patients fail to follow their treatment plan
patients actively change or add to their prescribed treatment
Reasons for creative non-adherence
financial difficulties
saving medication for later
confusion about instructions
uncomfortable side effects
personal beliefs about illness and treatment
trying to speed up recovery
Financial difficulties and creative non-adherence
reduce their medication dosage so the prescription last longer
if they cannot afford to refill their medication
Saving medication for later and creative non-adherence
take less medication to keep some for later
for themselves or a family member who may need it
Confusion about instructions and creative non-adherence
may misunderstand or forget their physician’s dosage instructions
can be result of poor communication
may take lower dosage because they are afraid of taking too much and overdosing
Uncomfortable side effects and creative non-adherence
side effects being uncomfortable/concerning may make a patient stop taking medication
side effects seem worse than the illness symptoms they may feel like its not working and not worth taking
Personal beliefs about illness and treatment and creative non-adherence
develop their own theories about their illness
mainly focus on the painful symptoms that bother them
if patient thinks that certain symptoms need additional treatment they may use home remedies and non-prescription products
dangerous because patient may not understand how different treatments or medications interact
Trying to speed up recovery and creative non-adherence
take more medication than prescribed because they believe it will help them recover faster
4 pills per day for 10 days, taking 8 pill per day for 5 days does not make them get better faster
can be very harmful
Causes of non-adherence
no single explanation for why it happens
physicians’ beliefs about non-adherence
communication
treatment regimen
side effects
avoidant coping
life stressors
Physicians’ beliefs about non-adherence
believe patients fail to follow treatment because of
uncooperative attitudes
lack of knowledge
ignorance
lack of motivation
forgetfulness
Communication and why it leads to non-adherence
patient needs to understand what they are supposed to do to follow treatment
poor communication between patients and healthcare providers may make it so patients cannot follow the treatment correctly
Ways to improve communication to increase adherence
providers give patients jargon-free explanations about their
diagnosis
cause/origin of their illness
treatment options
quality of patient-provider relationship also matters
Quality of patient-provider relationship and impacts on adherence
treatment adherence is more likely when warm and respectful communication happens
better communication
warm and caring
answers patients questions
shows respect
makes connections with the patient
poor communication
impatient and angry
does not address questions
makes patient feel dismissed
does not make connections with patient
Treatment regimen and why it can lead to non-adherence
tends to be lower when treatments
must be followed for a long time
are complicated and hard to remember
interfere with behaviors the patient enjoys
all these factors lead to a decrease in adherence
Side effects and why they can lead to non-adherence
can make a patient feel like it is not worth continuing the treatment
may believe that medication is not working if the side effects feel worse than their original symptoms
makes them less likely to follow the treatment
Avoidant coping and why it can lead to non-adherence
dealing with illness by avoiding/distancing themselves from it
may avoid following treatment as a way of coping with the fact that they are ill
Life stressors and why they can lead to non-adherence
everyday problems can make it harder for patients to follow treatment
financial difficulties
lack of time
other distractions/responsibilities
people living in disorganized homes tend to have lower adherence than those living in more organized homes
Ways to reduce non-adherence
4 types of interventions that can improve adherence
technical
behavioral
educational
multifaceted/complex
Technical intervention
make treatment easier to follow
simplifying the treatment plan
found to be the most effective at encouraging adherence
Behavioral intervention
focus on changing/supporting the patient’s behaviors
Educational intervention
provide information to patients
teach them about their treatment
Multifaceted/complex intervention
combine different approaches to improve adherence
Self-efficacy
person’s belief that they are capable of completing a task or behavior
Self-efficacy theory use to simplify treatment and increase adherence
make the patient have a higher belief that they can do something
providers can…
break large treatment goals into smaller goals that are more manageable
make the treatment seem less overwhelming
help patients feel more capable of achieving each step
monitor smaller goals more easily and provide encouragement
Modelling healthy behaviors to increase adherence
physicians demonstrate the behavior they recommend to patients
they become a source of inspiration
patients may be encouraged to copy these desirable behaviors
Placebo
a medical procedure or treatment that produces an effect because of its expected/inferred intentions not its actual physical or chemical properties