1/76
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Dispute Resolution Methods
Mediation
Conciliation
Arbitration
Mediation
Mediator facilitates discussions between parties in order to reach a resolution. Listens to both sides and can be separately. Does not make suggestions, or impose solutions, parties come to own resolution not legally binding. Used to preserve a relationship
Mediation with VCAT
VCAT often utilises mediation as a dispute resolution method in various matters, such as tenancy and building disputes, and planning and environmental matters
Mediation with CAV
CAV do not usually refer matters to mediation
Conciliation
An independent person facilitates a discussion between the parties and suggests solutions to them (cannot impose a decision on the parties), but not legally binding (only legally binding if terms are signed). Used to preserve a relationship to a point
Conciliation with VCAT
VCAT often utilises the conciliation process in their compulsory conference
Conciliation with CAV
CAV utilises conciliation to resolve disputes
Strengths of Mediation and Conciliation
Preserve the relationship. More context to the dispute.
Strategic questioning allows parties to understand the cause of their upset/anger.
Less formal than the court process. Less expensive.
Confidential because not public.
Parties are likely to abide by resolution.
Weaknesses of Mediation and Conciliation
Some relationships are not worth preserving.
If there is a power imbalance between the parties these methods are inappropriate.
Mediator/conciliators can't compel parties to attend.
Arbitration
An independent third person listens to both parties and imposes a decision upon them which is legally binding. More formal than mediation and conciliation but less formal then courts, legal representation is necessary
Arbitration in VCAT and CAV
Not used in VCAT or CAV
Strengths of Arbitration
Unlike a court hearing, the arbitration process can still be private. This contributes to some flexibility about how the dispute may be resolved. This means that the resolution can be 'fitted' to the context.
Although formal > the level of formality is less than courts.
Less formality may link to fewer costs.
Arbitration is private and confidential.
Weaknesses of Arbitration
Not as flexible as mediation or conciliation because in arbitration the decision is imposed on the parties.
The parties have less control than in mediation or conciliation which is party led dispute resolution.
Arbitration is not always available to the parties or availability may be limited, e.g. $10,000 Magistrates court
Why choose Arbitration over Courts
Costs - legal rep is not needed as long as in courts
Specialisation of Arbitration - Arbitrator is an expert in the field of the dispute, deliberation and outcome more relevant to dispute
Privacy - Court hearings are open to public, whereas arbitration may be considered privately
Mediation Conciliation and Arbitration Compared
Legally Binding - x x ^
Specialist Knowledge - x ^ ^
Cooperative - ^ ^ ^
Helps Parties Negotiate - ^ ^ ^
Offers Suggestions and Solutions - x ^ ^
Focuses on Relationship - ^ ^ ^
Formal - x x (less formal than courts, more than con/med)
Suitable for all cases (cr + cv) - x x x
Legal Rep Req - x x (is required but not for whole time)
Faster and Cheaper - ^ ^ ^
Purpose of VCAT (Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal)
Provides dispute resolution for small civil disputes
LATE
Low-cost dispute resolution
Accessible and informal
Timely resolution
Expert bodies
Low-cost dispute resolution
Nominal Fee
No need for legal representation
More people can afford to have their dispute heard
Increases access
Accessible and informal
No strict rules of evident and procedure
Less intimidating
Focus on resolving disputes
Increases access for ordinary people
Timely resolution
VCAT resolves disputes much faster than courts
Most hearings resolved in less than a day
Reduces stress and cost of delays
Expert bodies
Has specialised 'lists'. Develops expertise in their areas of law
Mediation at VCAT
Discuss issues with mediator
Promote a settlement (can be made legally binding by signing drawn up deed of settlement)
Compulsory Conference (Conciliation) at VCAT
Confidential meeting
Parties discuss issues with VCAT member (VCAT member may inform parties of the likely should it go to hearing (arbitration))
Form of conciliation
Hearing (Arbitration) at VCAT
Parties present evidence
VCAT member makes a binding decision
Strengths of VCAT
· VCAT is normally cheaper than the courts
(filing fees & not allowing or requiring legal rep)
· VCAT operates with as little formality as possible make it more accessible and less intimidating
· Flexibility of hearing ensures fairness and equality.
Limitations of VCAT
Some of VCAT's lists r more complex & result in legal rep
Too much informality can make some parties feel that it isn't appropriate to settle disputes
Ordinary people can present their case decision made by VCAT do not establish precedent and people don't know how their case is likely to be settle as they would in court
Consumer Affairs Victoria (CAV)
The Victorian civil complaints body that provides information and helps resolve disputes to create a fair and competitive marketplace for consumers and businesses.
CAV can hear
Faulty products bought
Service that is not completed
Disputes about buying vehicles
Disputes about rental agreements
Disputes about repairs
CAV doesn't hear
Doesn't accept complaints from businesses or landlords
Conciliation at CAV
CAV offer a free conciliation service over the phone.
Involves an independent 3rd party who facilitates discussion, makes suggests, helps parties come to their own decision
Conciliation at CAV linked to POJ
Increases efficiency - links to access
Confidential - links to equality and fairness
Promotes accessibility as it can be done from anywhere
Strengths of CAV
CAV Conciliation is a free service providing the dispute qualifies, meets the CAV Criteria
Conciliation is an informal way to resolve disputes
CAV upholds procedural fairness by allowing each party to present their side of events & to challenge the other parties version of events
Processes offered by CAV allows small consumer matters the opportunity to be resolved by an independent body
Limitations of CAV
Its criteria to resolve disputes is quite narrow
CAV has no power to compel the parties to take part in its processes, so the dispute may remain unresolved
There is not power to impose or enforce a decision/ resolution on the parties unless they agree at the end to make it legally binding
CAV is unsuitable for large and complex disputes
Similarities of VCAT and CAV
Both use conciliation. Both Low cost. Both Informal
Both take pressure off court
Both promote collaboration/promote relationship
Both can hear tenant/landlord and consumer disputes
Differences of VCAT and CAV
VCAT has more extensive jurisdiction than CAV (limited)
CAV only uses conciliation whereas VCAT uses mediation, conciliation & arbitration
VCAT has more resources (more timely) the CAV (limited)
VCAT can attract a fee whereas CAV is free
CAV is private, VCAT final hearing can be open to public
VCAT does have avenues to appeal, CAV doesn't
Grounds for Appeal
Point of Law - Where the judge or Magistrates made an error in the law
Damages - The amount of damages
Question of Fact - Facts presented were untrue/incorrect, therefore the verdict was not correct
Courts
Liability. Claims. Matters Proceeding
Remedies - damages, injunctions
Standard of Proof - balance of probabilities, more likely than not
Burden of Proof - on plaintiff
Claims
Need to be fully documented by the plaintiff and communicated in writing to the defendant who then requires time to respond.
Discovery Process
The collection of evidence on both sides and then shared with the other side. This prevents 'trial by ambush'.
Magistrates Court
Arbitration for under $10k - VCAT & CAV.
No appellate jurisdiction
County Court
Unlimited jurisdiction. No appellate jurisdiction
Can also hear appeals from VCAT
Supreme Court
Unlimited jurisdiction
A judge can hear an appeal on a point of law from a case decided in Magistrates court
Court of Appeal
No original jurisdiction.
Hears appeals from County and Supreme courts. On a point of law or amount of damages awarded.
High Court of Australia
Hears appeals from all state equivalents of the court of appeal
CAV, VCAT and Courts comparison of Role of 3rd Party
Facilitates discussions, suggests options/solutions
Hears the evidence, makes binding decision
Hears the evidence, makes binding decision
CAV, VCAT and Courts compared
Binding decision - no yes yes
Appeals - no yes(but limited) yes
Private - yes no no
Rules of evidence and procedure - no generally yes
Jury available - no no yes(if 1 party requests)
Appropriate for large & complex claims - no no yes
Representative proceedings - no no yes
Mediation - no yes yes
Conciliation - yes yes generally no
Arbitration - no yes yes (MC for claims
Jury in a Civil Trial
Comprised of 6 community members who hear the evidence, decide the verdict and decide the level of damages awarded
Jury
Jury is optional in County or Supreme court. A party must request a jury and pay the associated fees to have one
Difficulties Faced by 1st Nations People in Civil Justice System
Distrust in legal system
Language differences
Cultural differences
Distrust in legal system
Because of the way Australia was settled, Aboriginal people were dispossessed of their land from the beginning of colonisation and the legal system made is possible
Language differences
Respect conveyed on different ways.
Listeners have the right to ignore who is speaking.
Silence is valued. Speaking context is valued. Not appropriated to reference people who have passed away.
Cultural differences
Aboriginal Elders are highly respected, they resolve disputes through leadership.
Family networks are considered fundamental, have the utmost priority. Strong connection to land and spirituality
What can be done to address these difficulties
- Established Victorian Aboriginal Legal Services (VALS) - funded by courts - assists with crim, civil and family law.
- Courts and tribunals train staff to understand ATSI culture by running cultural competence training run by Aboriginal groups. ATSI-Aboriginal & Torre Strait Islanders
- VCAT has deliberately employed more Koori staff and made changes to ensure hearing rooms are cleansed via 'smoking'
Remedies
Mechanisms for returning a wronged party to their original position as far as it is practicable prior to the wrong occurring
Purposes of Remedies
Restore the wronged party to their original position before the wrong occurred as far as is practicable.
To stop the harm from continuing - e.g. defamation
To force a party to do something that otherwise they wouldn't do
Injunction
A court order requiring a party to take action or stop acting. Court order can either be:
interlocutory - temporary
Perpetual - ongoing
Purpose of injunctions
To rectify a situation caused by the person who was found to be in the wrong and restore the plaintiff.
Mandatory (compulsory) injunction
Instruction meaning that the party must do something
e.g. builder complying with the original contract
Mandatory injunction strengths
Can undo wrong itself & restore plaintiffs original position
Directly addresses the cause of the dispute, not just cost
Useful where money could not achieve the same outcome
Enforceable, as breach is contempt of court
Mandatory injunction limitations
Rarely granted - courts are reluctant to supervise ongoing conduct
No money for loss already suffered
Compliance may be difficult, delayed or impossible
Plaintiff may need to return to court to enforce it
Prohibitive/Restrictive (stop) injunction
Stop a party from doing something
e.g. stop publishing defamatory material
Prohibitive injunction strengths
Stops the wrongful conduct before further loss is suffered
Can protect reputation, privacy or property that money cannot repair
Breach is contempt of court, so the order is enforceable
Can be granted quickly on an interlocutory basis while the case is heard
Prohibitive injunction limitations
Provides no compensation for loss already suffered
Often comes too late - the harm may already be done
Court has discretion & may refuse if damages r adequate
Needs monitoring, & further court action if breached
Compulsory Damages
Specific
General
Aggravated
Specific Damages
Quantifiable. Damages that are able to be calculated. E.g. loss of wages, medical bills
Specific damages strengths
Accurately calculated from receipts and records
Objective & easy to prove in court
Return the plaintiff close to their pre-wrong financial position
Specific damages limitations
Covers documented financial loss only
Future or ongoing cost can be underestimated
Does not compensate pain or distress
Useless if the defendant cannot pay
General Damages
Subjective. General estimate of loss, hard to calculate. E.g. loss of function, loss of enjoyment of life, PTSD
General damages strengths
Recognises harm that money cannot itemise
Considers the plaintiffs individual circumstances
Can include future loss, not just past costs
General damages limitations
Amount is subjective and hard to predict
Awards can be inconsistent between plaintiffs
Caps & thresholds may limit the award (The Wrongs Act)
No sum can restore health or quality of life
Aggravated Damages
An additional award where the defendants conduct was especially humiliating, insulting or malicious and increased the plaintiff's injury or distress.
E.g. humiliation, embarrassed the plaintiff, insult
Aggravated damages strengths
Compensates for the manner of the wrongdoing
Reflects humiliation and embarrassment suffered
Signals disapproval and may deter such conduct
Aggravated damages limitations
Rarely awarded - conduct must be extreme
Amount is highly discretionary
Money cannot undo humiliation or emotional harm
Nominal Damages
Small amount where a legal principle is proven by no loss is incurred. Purpose is to make a legal point
Exemplary (Punitive) Damages
Used where conduct is malicious, or violent, or cruel or in scornful disregard of the plaintiffs rights.
Purpose is to punish and deter the defendant
Contemptuous Damages
An intense lack of respect. Is where the matter has been proven but shouldn't have gone to court at all. Purpose is to show contempt for the plaintiffs claim
3 General Purposes of Remedies with Appropriate Remedy
Restoration - Specific damages & Nominal damages
Compensation - General damages & Aggravated damages
Prevention - Injunction & Exemplary damages