State of Michigan v. Devin Emerson Mock Trial Review

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/24

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Comprehensive practice flashcards in Question and Answer format covering case facts, witness affidavits, exhibits, legal statutes, and pretrial stipulations for State of Michigan v. Devin Emerson.

25 Terms

1
New cards

In Case No. 2025−06132025-0613, what three criminal offenses is Devin Emerson charged with under Michigan law?

Devin Emerson is charged with Count I: First-Degree Murder (MCL 750.316\text{MCL } 750.316; MCL 750.317\text{MCL } 750.317), Count II: Armed Robbery (MCL 750.529\text{MCL } 750.529), and Count III: Arson / Arson, Second Degree (MCL 750.73\text{MCL } 750.73).

2
New cards

What was stipulated as the cause of death of Lois Mae Alcott, and what specific item was identified as the murder weapon?

The cause of death was blunt force trauma to the back of her head occurring prior to fire exposure, caused by a Wagner's 1891 Original cast iron skillet found on the kitchen floor.

3
New cards

Who is Lois Mae Alcott's closest living relative entitled to inherit her estate under Michigan intestate succession?

Sidney Alcott-Walden, who is the surviving spouse of Lois Mae Alcott's deceased twin sibling, Ashton Alcott.

4
New cards

How does the Pretrial Order define the terms 'codicil' and 'life estate'?

A 'codicil' is defined as an amendment to an existing will that supplements, alters, or expands upon that will. A 'life estate' is defined as a person's legal interest in the possession and use of property during that person's lifetime.

5
New cards

What objective evidence corroborated Sidney Alcott-Walden's timeline on the evening of April 6, 2025?

Security camera video footage and the digital log from the security gate of Alcott-Walden's gated community in Beaufort confirmed Alcott-Walden's white Cadillac entered at exactly 19:3819:38 (7:38 p.m.7:38\text{ p.m.}), matching the approximately 30-minute30\text{-minute} drive time from the Emerson Homestead.

6
New cards

What evidence excluded Jaylen Whitman and Miller Whitman as suspects in the arson and homicide?

A recorded video chat session on Jaylen Whitman's laptop verified that Miller Whitman was out of state and Jaylen Whitman was continuously inside the Carriage House from 19:0219:02 (7:02 p.m.7:02\text{ p.m.}) until 22:4422:44 (10:44 p.m.10:44\text{ p.m.}) on April 6, 2025.

7
New cards

According to Chief Nat Hawthorne, where and how did the fire at Emerson Hall originate?

The fire originated in the kitchen in the area of the stove, started intentionally by an accelerant-soaked towel near the stove, with flowing burn patterns showing three areas where liquid accelerant pooled on the floor.

8
New cards
<p>Identify this property sketch and explain what reference points 1 through 6 indicate.</p>

Identify this property sketch and explain what reference points 1 through 6 indicate.

Exhibit #1: Property Sketch of Emerson Homestead. Point 1: Freddie Douglas's reserved church parking space. Point 2: Path where Sidney was seen shouting on a cell phone. Point 3: Driveway where Sidney unloaded groceries from the Cadillac. Point 4: Rear door of Emerson Hall where a person believed to be Devin Emerson exited. Point 5: Side yard of the Carriage House where the lighter fluid container was found. Point 6: Sand walking path where six athletic shoeprints were found.

9
New cards
<p>Identify this item from the evidence exhibits and state where it was recovered.</p>

Identify this item from the evidence exhibits and state where it was recovered.

Exhibit #2: A nearly empty 2 QT2\text{ QT} (64 FL OZ64\text{ FL OZ} / 1892 mL1892\,mL) container of Flamesford Charcoal Lighter fluid, recovered with no fingerprints in the side yard of the Carriage House (Reference Point 5).

10
New cards
<p>What exhibit is shown here, and what lineage does it document for the defendant Devin Emerson?</p>

What exhibit is shown here, and what lineage does it document for the defendant Devin Emerson?

Exhibit #5: A family tree handwritten inside the Emerson Family Bible, establishing that Devin Emerson is the child of Ralph D. Emerson III and Henrietta Davida Thoreau, the grandchild of Ralph O. Emerson Jr. and Maggie Fuller, and the great-grandchild of Ralph Devin Emerson and Olivia W. Holmes.

11
New cards
<p>What evidence item is shown in this photograph, and what was its significance in the case?</p>

What evidence item is shown in this photograph, and what was its significance in the case?

Exhibit #6: A Wagner's 1891 Original 1134 inch11\frac{3}{4}\text{ inch} cast iron skillet recovered from the kitchen floor of Emerson Hall, stipulated as the murder weapon that inflicted blunt force trauma and a fatal skull fracture to Lois Mae Alcott.

12
New cards
<p>What evidence item is shown here, and what forensic links did investigators establish with it?</p>

What evidence item is shown here, and what forensic links did investigators establish with it?

Exhibit #7A: Black New Balance 992 athletic shoes seized from Devin Emerson's bedroom closet. Forensic testing matched their sole tread to two shoeprints lifted from the sand walking path (Reference Point 6) and detected trace petroleum-based accelerant on the soles.

13
New cards

What was the exact total amount and composition of cash and checks in the April 6, 2025 weekly collection for the Church of St. Francis de Sales?

The total collections equaled $1,917.00\$1,917.00, comprising $280.00\$280.00 in checks (66 checks) and $1,637.00\$1,637.00 in cash: 22 fifties ($100\$100), 4646 twenties ($920\$920), 3636 tens ($360\$360), 3939 fives ($195\$195), and 6262 ones ($62\$62).

14
New cards

What phone conversation did Freddie Douglas overhear cousin Barnard having on the porch shortly before the murder?

Barnard was shouting to Devin Emerson: 'Devin, you cannot just mooch off everyone your whole life. At some point, you have to pay back what you borrow… You know if it was me I would not care, but these guys are no joke… Well, you will have to find yourself another job then and ---'.

15
New cards

What did Freddie Douglas observe upon returning to the Church of St. Francis de Sales around 6:55 p.m. on April 6, 2025?

Freddie Douglas heard a door close, saw someone believed to be Devin Emerson exiting the rear door of Emerson Hall carrying something and walking around the far side (Reference Point 4), and later smelled something burning when returning to the car.

16
New cards

What personal property of Lois Mae Alcott was recovered from the exterior burn pile near Emerson Hall?

Investigators recovered her partially burned purse containing white lady's gloves, sunglasses, a wallet with credit cards, remnants of cosmetic compact cases, and a set of keys with a leather fob.

17
New cards

What two caches of currency were seized during the search of Devin Emerson's residence (Ralph Jr.'s house)?

A rubber-banded bundle of $1,637.00\$1,637.00 in cash hidden in the kitchen cabinet to the left of the refrigerator (matching the exact denominations of the church collection), and $25.00\$25.00 in loose cash (one $20\$20 and one $5\$5 bill) on the living room coffee table.

18
New cards

What error did the forensics personnel make regarding the shoeprint evidence lifted from the walking path?

Of the six full or partial shoeprints lifted from the path, two matched Devin Emerson's shoes, while the casts of the other four unidentified shoeprints were accidentally discarded by the cleaning crew before being secured in the evidence room.

19
New cards

What percentage of ownership in the Emerson Homestead did each family branch hold prior to Lois Mae Alcott's death?

Ralph Emerson III held 50%50\%, Sidney Alcott-Walden held 25%25\% (inherited from spouse Ashton Alcott), and Lois Mae Alcott held 25%25\% plus a lifetime life estate requiring her consent for any sale of the property.

20
New cards

What real estate development offer did Sidney Alcott-Walden pressure Lois Mae Alcott to accept on the day she died?

A $5.5 million\$5.5\text{ million} offer from a commercial developer to subdivide the Emerson Homestead property, which would have earned Sidney Alcott-Walden a 3%3\% commission totaling $165,000.00\$165,000.00.

21
New cards

How did Devin Emerson explain the presence of accelerant on their athletic shoes and clothing?

Devin stated that after returning from the store on Sunday afternoon, Jaylen Whitman's SUV leaked oil onto the driveway, and Devin poured lighter fluid from the container to clean up the spill, splashing lighter fluid onto their shoes.

22
New cards

What were the exact recorded times of Jaylen Whitman's 911 call and the initial containment of the fire on April 6, 2025?

Jaylen Whitman dialed 911 at 22:48:5122:48:51 (10:48 p.m.10:48\text{ p.m.}). First responders arrived at 22:55:4822:55:48, Chief Hawthorne assumed command at 23:19:1723:19:17, and the fire was declared sufficiently contained at 23:49:0323:49:03.

23
New cards

What four expert opinions did defense witness Kendall Philpot offer to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty?

Philpot concluded that: (1) The fire was intentionally set; (2) The trace accelerant evidence collected was inconclusive; (3) The time the fire started is indeterminate; and (4) The investigation into the fire and the death of the victim was inadequate.

24
New cards

What cross-contamination critique did Kendall Philpot raise concerning the cash seized from Devin Emerson's house?

Officers placed both the loose cash from the coffee table (handled after the driveway lighter fluid cleanup) and the bundled cash from the kitchen cabinet into the same evidence bag, allowing evaporating petroleum gases to cross-contaminate all the bills inside the sealed bag.

25
New cards

Under Michigan law (MCL 750.316), what four elements must the prosecution prove to establish First-Degree Murder?

The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt: (1) The defendant caused the death of Lois Mae Alcott; (2) The defendant intended to kill Lois Mae Alcott; (3) The intent to kill was premeditated (thought out beforehand); and (4) The killing was deliberate (considered the pros and cons and chose the action beforehand).