1/97
Looks like no tags are added yet.
power to
the capacity to achieve a desired outcome
power over
the exercise of control by one person over another
“power over” as relational
the power to get other people to do what you want
“power over” as dominion
the power to make decisions that others follow
Steven Lukes
political theorist who came up with the 3 faces of power
Lukes’ 3 faces of power, and Heywood/Chin’s 4th
Power as:
Influencing decision-making
Agenda-setting
Preference manipulation
Productive
Hobbes’ definition of power
power is the ability of an agent to affect the behavior of a patient
Dahl’s concept of power
A has power over B when A can get B to do something that B would not otherwise do
Hobbes & Dahl’s definitions of power full under which of Lukes’ faces of power?
Ability to influence decision making
non-decision-making
agenda-setting tactic; a decision that results in the exclusion of threats to the interests of the decision maker
Preference manipulation
one of Lukes’ approach to / faces of power
the ability of A to exercise power over B by “influencing, shaping, or determining his very wants”
3 examples of thinkers in preference manipulation
Neustadt & presidential power
Carole Pateman & The Sexual Contract
Riker & heresthetic
heresthetic
“the art of political manipulation”; a set of political strategies to set up decision-making situations in a way that helps you win
4 Heresthetic tactics
agenda control
strategic voting
dimension manipulation
participant curation
power as productive
Heywood & Chin’s 4th face of power; power is about relations and who has the power to ascribe/assign meaning
focuses on how power gets embedded in language and systems of thought
discourse
a system of social relations, practices, and ideas that assigns meaning, and therefore identities, to those within it
Frankfurt School of Social Theory
school from which critical theory emerged in the early 1900s
critical theory
political thought that critiques social practices, power relations, institutions, and structures, with a commitment to emancipation
theorists associated with critical theory
Horkheimer, Habermas
Post-structuralism
theory that examines how power, language, and meaning construct social/political reality, rather than relying on fixed structures or universal truths
thinkers associated with post-structuralism
Heidegger, Foucault, Derrida
authority
the means through which one person can influence the behavior of another; “the right to rule”
power vs authority
Power is about whose order is obeyed; authority is about whose order SHOULD be obeyed
3 “ideal types” of authority
traditional
charismatic
legal-rational
traditional authority
(& example)
a theory of leadership where power/legitimacy come from customs, traditions, and the “collected reason of the ages”
ex. patriarchalism
charismatic authority
the power of one’s personality, gained not by status/position but by charisma, speaking ability, and perception of the individual
legal-rational authority
attaches authority to the office and formal powers, not to the office holder
3 views of justifying authority
limited authority based on consent
authority based on need
Rejection of authority as oppressive (critical view)
legitimacy
“rightfulness”; the quality that transforms power as domination into rightful authority
David Beetham’s (3) conditions of legitimate governments:
Power is exercised according to established rules
Established rules are justified by shared beliefs of the government and governed
Expressed consent of the governed
consent
idea that the consent of the governed provides legitimacy to governments
Tacit consent
an implied agreement among citizens to obey the law and respect the authority of the government
Explicit consent
verbal or written confirmation that you recognize the authority and legitimacy of the government
constitutionalism
the political/legal principle that a government's legitimacy is derived from a fundamental higher law or constitution that limits individuals and itself
French & Indian War (1754-1763)
the part of the Seven Year’s War that is fought in North America between Britain and France
Stamp Act (1765)
law passed by British Parliament that enacts a tax on all paper documents in the colonies (“taxation without representation)
Rights consciousness
widespread conversation about / demands for natural rights
First and Second Continental Congress (1774 to 1781)
provisional governing bodies of the Thirteen Colonies
First: organized to deliberate/coordinate independence movement
Second: Manage war and transition to self-governance
Articles of Confederation (1777-1789)
United States' first constitution that had a very weak national government, a unicameral Congress, and high state autonomy
The Federalist
a series of 85 essays written and published from 1787-1788 to support the ratification of the Constitution
written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay
Otto van Bismark view of politics
“politics is an art, not a science”
3 views of politics
politics as government
politics as a public affair
politics as power & conflict
politics as government
politics is limited to government institutions and actors
politics as a public affair
politics is a public sphere of life, separate from the private
Citizens engage with each other about what society needs
civil society
a realm of group life that, while outside the formal character of the state, is deeply relevant to politics and is therefore political
Aristotle’s 3 types of government
Govern in interest of all
Monarchy (rule by the one)
Aristocracy (rule by the few)
Polity (rule by the many)
Aristotle’s 3 types of government if corrupted
Debased forms of rule where rulers rule in their own interests
tyranny (one)
oligarchy (few)
democracy (many)
Aristotle’s ideal government system
mixed system of government is most likely to pursue interests of middle class
which of the 3 views of politics would Aristotle most likely ascribe to? why?
Politics as public affairs
Politics takes place in public settings and the gov should protect “the good life” via community involvement
republicanism
political ideology that says sovereignty resides in the people and their elected representatives
“Freedom as non-domination”
the absence of being under a power, not just absence of interference
3 common themes of republicanism
freedom as non-denomination
pursuit of common good
emphasis on public activity
The Prince, 1531
work by Machiavelli that is an account of politics as the pursuit/exercise of power and rebukes the idea that a ruler should be guided by Christian/moral ideas
state
a political entity with (1) a defined territory, (2) a permanent population, (3) a government, and (4) sovereignty
functions of government (examples)
legislation, administration, judiciary, foreign relations
two theories of the state
absolutism and constitutionalism
absolutist state theory
a political state should be embodied in a single figure, and all the rights, powers, and obligations of the state should exist w/ reference to that centralized power
sovereignty
power that states have within their territorial borders
legal sovereignty
de jure sovereignty; power defined in terms of legal authority (through the state’s laws)
political sovereignty
de facto sovereignty; sovereignty based on the actual distribution of power (not laws)
internal sovereignty
a state's final and independent authority to govern itself, its people, and its territory
popular sovereignty
the claim that political right lies within the people in some form
federalism
a system of government where power is divided between a central (national) government and smaller regional units
external sovereignty
the state’s place in the international order and sovereign independence from other states
ability to preserve territory, people, government, & independence
key themes of machiavelli
Realism
Not reliant on religion
Prioritizing security/stability
Politics about pursuit and exercise of power
rule of law
principle that laws and legal institutions, not individuals should have the highest governing authority in a state
law (definition w/ 4 requirements)
a set of rules that is (1) institutionalized with the state, (2) compulsory, (3) consists of published rules/consequences, (4) binding
3 types of law
natural law
positive law
legal realism
natural law
idea that law should be founded upon a moral system rooted in justice
positive law
idea that there is no justification or context for breaking the law, and interpreting the law should focus on its “letter not spirit”
legal realism
idea that law is what the judges say, so it’s not a moral code based in objective truth
judges are not non-political/impartial actors
order
regular, stable, and predictable behavior that is conducive to personal security
order as social control
idea that the state must ensure security by discipline, regulation and authority, to protect humans from their corrupt/selfish nature
order as natural harmony
idea that societal order comes naturally through cooperation, whereas introduction of government, law, and property corrupts human behavior and leads to disorder
obligation
a duty to act
three types of obligations
legal obligations
moral obligations
political obligations
legal obligations (definition & example)
obligations enforceable through legal system / penalties
ex. requirement to pay taxes and observe laws
moral obligations (definition & example)
obligation to do what is ethically right, even if not compelled by state
ex. help a stranger in distress
political obligations (definition & example)
responsibilities of the citizen to the state
ex. break an unjust law, voting
civil disobedience
the breaking of a law for religious, moral, or political principles through participating in overt, public, and principled acts to demonstrate a difference between law and justice and bring about change outside of official government channels
citizen
a member of a political community given a set of rights and obligations by the state
three theories of citizenship
social citizenship
active citizenship
universal citizenship
social citizenship
citizenship includes equal rights and access to welfare programs because they are a mechanism for achieving social equality
T.H. Marshall
thinker who introduced social citizenship, arguing that in order to fully participate in their communities, citizens require a foundational baseline of economic security and education
active citizenship
idea that citizens take responsibility for themselves and their communities by participating actively in social, economic, and political life
universal citizenship
idea that all citizens have same status within political community and citizenship supersedes other identities
two theories of freedom
negative and positive
negative freedom
freedom as “the absence of impediment”
Isaiah Berlin’s 4 theoretical implications of negative freedom
If freedom is the absence of external constraints, then law can only restrict freedom
Negative freedom is linked to having choices/options
Negative freedom is connected to privacy (implies existence of public/private realms)
Human individual is rational (freedom to make harmful choices is detrimental to individuals/society)
positive freedom
freedom as the presence of autonomy, self-government, and teh capacity to achive your goals
aka “the freedom to be one’s own master”
a right
an entitlement to act or be treated in a particular way
4 types of rights discussed
legal
moral
human
environmental
legal rights
recognized, enforceable, and institutionalized rights, often protected in a bill of rights
civil rights
protection by a government power that obligate government intervention
civil liberties
protection by a government power that requires the government not to interfere
moral rights
rights that lack legal backing, instead relying on moral, ethical, or religious claims/agreements
human rights
universal and fundamental rights that people are entitled to by the virtue of being human
environmental rights
idea that questions humanity’s role on earth and focuses on animal rights/welfare
humans must bet intentional about our effects on nature and we have an obligation to preserve the future of humanity and other species