1/60
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Who can evidence be produced by at trial?
1. Witnesses of fact
2. Expert Witnesses
3. Objects
When will evidence be admissible?
If it is relevant to the issues in dispute (reference to the statements of case)
Give 2 examples where evidence may be inadmissible?
1. Without prejudice
2. Privileged
What directions can the court give to guide evidence?
1. Issues on which it requires evidence
2. nature of the evidence it requires to decide issues
3. the way in which evidence is to be placed before the court
Is Hearsay evidence admissible?
YES unlike criminal proceedings
If a party wants to rely on hearsay evidence what must they do?
Give notice to the other side- hearsay notice
What are the ways of making a hearsay notice
1. Service of WS
2. Formal notice of intention (used if in a document)
If maker of the witness statement does not intend to give evidence in court what else must be done (hearsay)
Party must state and explain why when serving the WS
When must a hearsay notice be served?
NO LATEr than the latest date for serving witness statement
If hearsay is in a document can that document be requested by the other side?
yes
When a hearsay notice is received what are the options of response?
1. Request further paritcualrs
2. Apply to the court WITHIN 14 days for an order to call the witness to cross examination
3. Call evidence to attack the credibility of the witness (other side must be informed within 14 days)
When must all of the options of response to a hearsay notice be done by?
NO LATER THAN 14 days after hearsay notice was served.
Can the weight placed on hearsay evidence be challenged at trial?
Yes
Give some example of factors the court will consider when assessing the weight of hearsay evidence>
e.g. would it have been reasonable and practicable to produce the maker of the original statement, is there multiple hearsay, is there a motive, is there bias
When can a notice to admit facts be served?
anytime - up to 21 days before trial
What happens if the receiving party does not admit the facts in question and later on in trial the court decides the fact should have been admitted>
party may be ordered to pay the costs
Who bears the burden of proof in civil litigation?
Claimant UNLESS defendant is pleading a positive case (e..g contributory negligence) OR counterclaim
What is the standard of proof in civil litigation?
on the balance of probabilities
When does the standard of proof in litigation differ?
1. Summary judgement - applicant must satisfy court the respondent no real prospect of succeeding
2. Contempt of court- beyond reasonable doubt
What does 'no real prospect of succeeding mean'?
includes an improbably case, must be more than merely arguable
If a party wishes to rely on the contents of a witness statement at trial what must they do?
1. Call the witness to give oral evidence
2. Submit the statement as hearsay evidence
What are the stages of witness evidence at trial?
1. Evidence in Chief (this is their witness statement)
2. Cross examination
3. Re-examination
What are some rules of witness statement?
.e.g. must be in their own words in the 1st person, explain how it was prepared, be supported by exhibits, be verified by a statement of truth
who are additional witness statement rules applied for in the Business and Property Courts?
Witness statement for trial
Can a witness statement be used for an other purpose (e.g. a related claim)
NO UNLESS
1. Witness gives their consent in writing
2. Court gives permission
3. Witness statement has been put in evidence at hearing held in public
Witness summaries
If a party is unable to obtain a witness statement, they may serve a witness summary.
When might a witness summary be appropriate?
e.g. person does not want to be seen to voluntarily provide evidence, hard to track down
What is an affidavit?
Sworn witness statement
How does an affidavit differ to a witness statement
It has a jurat instead of a statement of truth
What if someone makes a false statement in a witness statement?
Can be in contempt of court
What is the possible penalties of being held in contempt of court for a false statement in a witness statement?
Unlimited fine and a custodial sentence of up to 2 years
What if someone makes a false statement in an affidavit
could face criminal prosecution for perjury
What is the possible penalties of perjury for a false statement in an affadavit?
Unlimited fine and a custodial sentence of up to 2 years
If a document is referenced in a witness statement can it be requested?
YES
if the deadline is missed for serving a witness statement what does this mean>
the witness may not be called for evidence at trial unless the court gives permission
what is the nature of expert evidence?
opinion
To call an expert what is required?
Permission of the court
If permission is granted what will the court do?
court will define the scope of expert evidence
What is the preferable position on experts at trial>
Parties should try to agree the appointment of a single joint expert
If a single joint expert is agreed what is the next step>
parties should agree on a form of joint instructions
When may a single joint expert not be appropriate?
high value cases, where there is likely to be a range of opinion.
Who do the experts owe their duties do>
The court - they must be viewed as independent
How are experts instructed?
Formal letter of instruction
Is the formal letter of instruction to experts privileged?
No
When will the formal letter of instruction be disclosed
If the other side want disclosure and they have reasonable grounds for believing or suspecting that the instructions were inappropriate or inaccurate in some way
How should oral instructions to an expert be documented?
in an attendance note
What are the procedural requriemtns if an expert witness asks the court for specific directions?
expert must provide a copy of proposed request to:
1. Their sides solicitor at least 7 days before submitting to court
2. All other parties at leas 4 days before submitting to court
What must all expert reports comply with
CPR 35
CPR 35
must be objective and unbiased, give reasons, verified with statement of truth
When are different sides experts reports exhacnegd?
date given in the directions report
Can a party rely on an undisclosed expert report?
No
When must questions to experts be submitted
Within 28 days of the service of their report
When must these questions to experts be answered?
No set time limit but at a reasonable time
If no reply is received to a question to an expert?
court may order the report cannot be relied upon and the experts fees should not be recoverable
If there are separate experts what is the court likely to order?
Discussion between experts, production of a joint statement
doe the solicitors obtain this expert meeting?
NO
Is the agreement reached by the experts in a joint discussion binding?
No but is admissible to the court
Do experts attend trial?
Yes (unless reached an agreement on all issues in their joint meeting)
DO NOT attend trial in small or fast track claims
What are the ways of oral evidence for exerts
Standard- cross examination
Hot tubbing- experts called together, experts ask each other questions
If a party does not wish to rely on their expert report once it's been disclosed can the other party rely on it?
YEs
If a party wants to change expert, how do they go about it?
must get the courts permission, court will only give permission once the firs report is disclosed