1/89
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Framework for capital markets expectations
Specify expectations w/ time horizon
Research historical record
Specify the methods and/or models w/ information requirements
Determine the best sources of information
Interpretation of current investment environment
Provide expectations: Present the actual forecasts.
Monitor actual outcomes and compare with expectations
Every Happy Monkey Steals Ice Pops Monday.
Challenges in developing capital market forecasts
Limitations of economic data
Data measurement errors and biases
The limitations of historical estimates
Ex-post risk can be a biased measure of ex-ante risk
Biases in analyst’s methods
The failure to account for conditioning information
Misinterpretation of correlation
Psychological Traps
Model Uncertainty
4) Ex-post risk can be a biased measure of ex-ante risk
why historical risk (ex-post) may not accurately represent the risk investors anticipated at the time (ex-ante).
First, the distinction
Ex-ante risk: The risk investors expect before an event occurs.
Ex-post risk: The risk measured afterward, using actual historical outcomes.
Example: Fear of a recession
Imagine investors believe there is a 50% chance of a severe recession next year.
Because they're worried, they sell stocks, causing stock prices to fall 15%.
But the recession never actually happens.
What would the historical data show?
Anchoring trap
initial impressions, data, or estimates - discuss anchor subsequent judgments
Status-quo trap
when a forecaster assumes that things will continue as they are, simply because changing their forecast feels riskier than sticking with the current situation.
Overconfidence trap
overestimate the accuracy of forecasts
tending to believe that most people share our views
predicting to narrow a range of possibilities
Prudence trap
tendency to temper forecasts so that they do not appear extreme
Availability bias
tendency of forecasts to be - discuss overly influenced by events that have left a strong impression
a personal/vivid experience comes easily to mind, so you give it too much weight when assessing what could happen
Exogenous shocks
unexpected events that come from outside the normal workings of the economy and significantly affect economic growth, inflation, or financial markets
can be positive or negative for growth
policy changes, new tech, geo-politics, natural disasters, financial crisis etc
Approaches to economic forecasting
Econometric modelling
Economic indicators
Checklist approach
Checklist approach to economic forecasting
A structured method of forecasting the economy by reviewing a standard list of economic indicators
(e.g., unemployment, inflation, GDP growth)
After answering the question you then review to decide where the economy is
Business Cycle Phases
Initial recovery
early expansion
late expansion (contraction)
slowdown
recession
Initial Recovery (Business Cycle)
business confidence rises
stimulate policies still in place
large negative output gap
decreasing inflation
CME:
short-term and bond yields low
quick rise in stock market
riskier and cyclical assets perform best
Early Expansion (Business Cycle)
economy gaining momentum
unemployment falls
output gap still negative
consumers borrowing and spending
businesses increase production and investment
profit rises rapidly
CME:
short-term rates increase as CB removes stimulus
bond yields hold steady
yield curve flattens
stocks trend upward
Late Expansion - (Business Cycle)
output gap closed
economy overheating
unemployment low
profits are strong
rising inflation
investment spending still strong
debt ratios are showing signs of stress
CME:
interest rates rise
monetary policy becomes restrictive
all rates rise, short-end faster leads to flattening curve
stock market rises but becomes more volatile
Slowdown (Business Cycle)
business confidence decreases
inflation rising
CME:
short-form rates high, rising towards peak
government bonds peak
yield curve may invert
Recession (Business Cycle)
investment decreases
CB ease monitory policy
profits decrease
CME:
short-term rates drop
yield curve steepens
stock market declines
credit spread widens
Business Cycle Chart

National Income Accounting Formula

Econometric modelling
quantitative modelling grounded in economic theory using only economic variables
(e.g. structural models reduced-form models)
Economic indicators
economic statistics provided by government and private organizations that contain information on economy’s past (lagging), current (coincident) and future (leading) performance
YTM
YTM → PV(CF) = Po
It is the rate that would make all the present value of future cashflow equal to the current price
MacDur
MacDur = ModDur(1+YTM)
the weighted average time (in years) required for an investor to recover the price of a bond through its cash flows
Building Block Approach
one period default- free rate is
one period = forecast horizon (complicates term premium)
or/ (more commonly) return generated by rolling over the 30-day T-Bill over the forecast horizon (keeps the term premium clean)

4 main drivers of term premium (maturity premium)
inflation uncertainty
ability to hedge recession risk
good hedge against recession = low term premium
supply/demand of bonds at various maturities
cyclical effects - shape of the curve changes over the course of the business cycle .
Credit premium
Credit premium = expected loss + risk of default or credit migration
Conclusion: credit spreads driven primarily by credit premium + financial market conditions, but only secondarily by expected level of default
Liquidity premium
Liquidity for bonds are better when:
priced near par
relatively new
from a relatively large issuer
from a well known issuer
standard/simple structure
high quality
Three Approaches to Forecasting Equity Returns
historical statistics approach
Discounted cash flow approach
risk premium approach
Grinold-Kroner Model

Gordon Growth Model (GGM)

Equity Risk Premium (ERP)
historical equity premiums are subject to substantial estimation error
ERP = historical equity returns - historical risk-free returns
Equilibrium approach (singer & Terhaar)

Real estate risk premium
Term premium + credit premium + equity risk premium + liquidity premium
Risk premium should be between corporate bonds and equity
Term premium: long-lived asset, very sensitive to level of long-term rates, therefore high term premium
Credit premium: exposed to the credit risk of tenants, lease → bond-like cash flows, therefore credit premium commensurate with the average tenant credit risk
Equity risk premium: relative to corporate debt, owner bears full risk of fluctuations in property value, (+ uncertainty in rent growth, occupancy etc)
Real estate in an equilibrium framework
unsmoothed data series
equilibrium models assume fully liquid assets, therefore add a liquidity premium
far less integrated (.50-.75), more closely related to local economic factors
Exchange rate influences
trade flows
purchasing power parity
competitiveness and sustainability of the current account
Expected percentage change in the exchange rate

Forecasting volatility methods
Sample statistics
VCV-matrix from multi-factor models
Shrinkage estimation of VCV-matrices
Estimating volatility from smoothed returns
Time-varying volatility: ARCH models
VCV = Variance-Covariance Matrix
Sample statistics
estimates calculated using historical data
example VCV
Small samples or too many assets can make these estimates unreliable.
Using past data to estimate risk, but limited data can lead to inaccurate estimates.
Variance-Covariance Matrix (VCV)
a table that shows how risky each asset is and how different assets move together.
a way to understand the risk of an entire portfolio, rather than just individual investments
VCV-matrix from multi-factor models
Instead of relying only on historical returns, uses a small number of common risk factors (e.g., interest rates, inflation) to estimate how assets move together
Handles a large number of assets, less estimation error than using small historical samples, improves consistency across assets
BUT- factor models are rarely correctly specified, therefore VCV-matrix will be biased and inconsistent

Number of Distinct Covariance Elements

Shrinkage estimation of VCV-matrices

Estimating volatility from smoothed returns
Ex: real estate, private equity, hedge funds
smoothed returns dampen volatility, distort correlation\

Traded REITs correlation with equity (short vs long-run)
Highly correlated in the short-run less correlated in the long-run
Real estate expected return (long-run)

Real estate expected return (short-run)
g = growth in NOI, NOI/p = cap rate

Metrics for investing in emerging market debt
Fiscal deficit/GDP: < 4%
Debt/GDP: < 70%
Current account deficit/GDP: < 4%
FX reserves / short-term debt: > 100%
3 levels of governance structure
governing investment committee
investment staff
third-party resources
6 common elements of effective governance
articulate the long and short-term objectives of the investment program
Allocate decision rights and responsibilities among the functional units in the governance hierarchy effectively
Specify the process for developing and approving the investment policy statement
Specify processes for developing and approving the strategic asset allocation
Establish a reporting framework to monitor the programs progress towards the agreed don goals and objectives
periodically undertake a governance audit
Specify the process for developing and approving the investment policy statement features
Statement of investment objectives
Investment constraints
Duties and responsibilities
investment committee
Investment staff
3rd party providers
Investment guidelines
Reporting
Extended portfolio assets and liabilities
human capital
PV of pension income
PV of expected inheritance
PV of future consumption

3 broad approaches to asset allocation
Asset-only
focus solely on the asset side of the investor’s balance sheet
Liability-relative
choose an asset allocation in relation to the objective of funding liabilities
Goals-based
used primarily for individuals & families
Specify asset allocations for sub-portfolios, each of which is aligned to specified goals
3 super classes of assets
capital assets - an ongoing source of something of value
consumable/transformable assets - commodities
Store of value assets - currencies, gold, art
Criteria for specifying asset classes
assets within a class should be relatively homogenous
asset classes should be mutually exclusive
asset classes should be diversifying
asset class as a group should make up a preponderance of world investable wealth (large enough to be widely investable)
asset classes should have the capacity to absorb a meaningful proportion of an investor’s portfolio (liquidity and transaction costs)
8 steps for asset allocation selection

Human capital (equity vs bond split)
Most human capital is 70% bond like and 30% capital like
Absolute contribution to risk (ACTR)
MCTR - marginal contribution to total risk
MCTR = Bi * σp
You then multiply MCTR by the weight to get ACTR
Excess return over MCTR for the overall portfolio, the result equals the Sharpe ratio.
because MCTR for the portfolio is standard deviation

Liability Relative Asset-Allocation Approaches
Surplus optimization
Hedging/return seeking portfolio
Integrated asset-liability approach
models legal and quasi-legal liabilities and is more commonly used with institutional
Surplus Optimization -
Liability Relative Asset-Allocation Approaches
maximize risk-adjusted surplus return (Assets minus Liabilities)
single period snap shot
treats liabilities as a static constraint and optimizes only the asset mix

Hedging/Return Seeking Portfolio -
Liability Relative Asset-Allocation Approaches
two-portfolio approach most appropriate for conservative investors or when the size of the PVL is large in relation to the size of the firm
Basic - surplus available
hedging portfolio
return seeking portfolio
Variants - deficit
partial hedged portfolio
return seeking portfolio
Integrated Asset-Liability Approach -
Liability Relative Asset-Allocation Approaches
simultaneously and jointly optimizes both sides of the balance sheet
multi-period dynamic model (projects cash flow over time)
adjusts both investment strategy and operational/liability decisions (like funding or payouts) together
Pension funding ratio

After-tax return formula (interest and equity)

After-tax standard dev
Taxes hurt gains and help losses therefore reduce the standard dev on expected return

Tactical Asset Allocation (TAA)
business or monetary cycle opportunities
temporary price dislocations
objective → increase risk-adjusted return by taking advantage of short-term market conditions
predicated on the belief that some short-term returns are predictable
Discretionary TAA
based on manager skill in predicting & timing short-term market moves
Systematic TAA
based on technical analysis/market signals
look for asset class level return anomalies
(value, momentum, valuation, trend-following)
Loss Aversion - Behavioural Bias
People feel the pain of a loss more strongly than the pleasure from an equivalent gain, This can cause investors to hold losing investments too long because they don't want to realize the loss, while potentially selling winners too early.
Illusion of Control
believing you have more influence over outcomes than you actually do
may result in:
extreme TAA (all in/all out market calls)
belief in superior resources (institutional investors)
excessive trading, use of leverage
eliminating/shorting asset classes
Mental accounting
treating money differently depending on the mental “bucket” you put it in, even though money is fungible.
goals-based investing incorporates this bias into the process
Representative Bias
(recency bias)
Seeing a pattern/recent trend and assume it is representative of what will happen going forward.
ex: this company looks like the next Apple, so it will probably be hugely successful
Equities have recently done well so they will continue to
TAA particularly susceptible to this bias (e.g. return chasing)
Framing Bias
choice of asset allocation may be influenced merely by the manner in which the risk-to-return trade-off is presented
Availability Bias
giving more weight to information that is familiar or easily recalled
Ex home bias, investing more in your own countries economy
Taylor Rule

Nominal GDP growth
Nominal GDP growth ≈ Forecasted increase in labor input + Forecasted increase in labor productivity + Forecasted inflation
Monte Carlo Simulation
potential future outcomes
likelihood of meeting various goals
distribution of the portfolio’s expected value through time
potential maximum drawdowns
the effects of trading/rebalancing costs & taxes
Criticisms:
outputs highly sensitive to small changes in the inputs
the asset allocations tend to be highly concentrated in a subset of the available asset
Shrinkage Estimate
A weighted average of historical sample estimates and target estimates (often from a factor model) used to reduce estimation error and produce a more stable covariance matrix.
Mean-Variance Optimization (MVO) - Asset Allocation Model
Finds the optimal portfolio by maximizing expected return relative to risk, based on expected returns, variances, and covariances.
Mean-variance optimization formula

Black-Litterman - Asset Allocation Model
Combines market-implied expected returns with an investor's own market views to determine portfolio allocations.
Reverse Optimization - Asset Allocation Model
Starts with market portfolio weights and works backward to calculate the expected returns implied by those weights.
Resampling - Asset Allocation Model
Combines Mean–Variance Optimization (MVO) with Monte Carlo simulations to create multiple possible portfolios, then averages their asset weights to produce a more diversified allocation.
Advantages: More diversified portfolios and less sensitivity to estimation errors.
Disadvantages: Still relies on potentially inaccurate inputs and can produce overly diversified portfolios.
Heuristic - Asset Allocation Model
Heuristic: A simple rule of thumb used to make asset allocation decisions without complex mathematical optimization.
Examples:
60/40 rule: Invest 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds.
1/N rule: Divide investments equally among all asset classes.
Probability Ratio
Measures how likely a portfolio is to achieve a required minimum return, assuming normally distributed returns.

Cash Flow-Based Goals vs Labeled Goals
Labeled goals
Goals expressed as desired investment characteristics without a clearly defined cash flow or time horizon
Cash flow-based goals
Goals with a specific monetary amount and an identifiable time horizon
Efficient Frontier
Every portfolio on the upper efficient frontier offers the highest expected return for its level of risk.
Sharpe ratio: The slope of the line connecting the risk-free rate Steeper = higher
Optimal risky portfolio: The portfolio where the line from Rf is touches but does not cross (tangent) to the efficient frontier. This has the highest Sharpe ratio.

Data-mining bias
Definition: Finding patterns in historical data that appear significant but are actually due to chance.
If you run enough tests you will eventually find something that looks significant. Too much searching → Finding patterns that aren't real.
Time-Period Bias
Using historical data from a particular period that is not representative of other periods or future market conditions.
Example: Estimating expected stock returns using only 2010–2021, a period with unusually strong equity performance.
Five Criteria for Specifying Asset Classes
Assets within an asset class should be relatively homogeneous
Asset classes should be mutually exclusive
Asset classes should be diversifying
Asset classes should collectively represent the majority of globally available investable assets
Asset classes selected for investment should have the capacity to absorb a meaningful proportion of an investor’s portfolio
Asset Only, Goals Based and Liability Relative Allocation
Goals-based:
Allocates investments to achieve specific financial goals, considering each goal's importance and time horizon.
Liability-relative:
Allocates investments to ensure assets can meet future liabilities.
Asset-based:
Allocates investments to maximize risk-adjusted returns based on the investor's risk tolerance.