1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Behaviour modification
Behaviour modification is an application of behaviourism (specifically principles of operant conditioning).
Token economy systems (TES) are applied in prisons to 'correct' offender behaviour.
Behaviourists assume all behaviour is learnt, so can be 'unlearnt' through operant conditioning.
Desirable behaviours
Systematically reinforcing obedient behaviours means desirable behaviours are more likely to occur in the future.
Punishing disobedience means disobedience will be extinguished.
Desirable behaviour:
- Avoiding conflict
- Following prison rules
- Keeping cell tidy
Token economies: Rewards
Desirable behaviour is reinforced with an immediate token (secondary reinforcer) that is later exchanged for some kind of reward (primary reinforcer).
Rewards:
- Phone calls
- Time outside/in gym
- Food/cigarettes
The tokens (secondary reinforcers) become reinforcing in their own right because prisoners associate them with rewards (primary reinforcers).
Token economies: Operationalisation
Desired target behaviour must be operationalised.
Everyone should know how many tokens each behaviour is worth.
Some worth more than others (hierarchical).
Token economies: System set up and use
System must be clearly explained to prisoners.
e.g. explaining that noncompliance leads to tokens being taken away.
Staff must be fully trained and must keep clear records.
AO3: Behaviour Modification - Research evidence
P- Strength: research evidence
E- Hobbs and Holt: introduced TES in 3 groups, found significant difference in positive behaviour vs control group
C- However, Bassett and Blanchard - benefits lost upon release, likely due to a lack of training or high staff turnover
S- So, behaviour modification schemes need full and consistent staff participation to reduce recidivism
AO3: Behaviour Modification - Easier to implement
P- Strength: easier to implement than other methods
E- No need for a specialist to be involved, as with anger management
E- TES can be designed and implemented by anyone, it is cost-effective and relatively easy to follow once set up
L- So, behaviour modification techniques useful in potentially reducing recidivism
AO3: Behaviour Modification - Long-term behaviour
P- Limitation: may not affect long-term behaviour
E- Blackburn: Desirable behaviours extinguished if they are not continually reinforced
E- Cognitive treatments like anger management more likely permanently change in behaviour
L- So, behaviour modification is less likely to reduce recidivism than other methods
AO3: Behaviour Modification - Ethical issues
P- Limitation: ethical issues
E- Moya and Achtenberg: it is manipulative and dehumanising to use a TES
C- However, behaviour modification can relieve pressure and stress on prison staff
S- So, apparent success of behaviour modification varies from the perspective of prison staff to the prisoners