1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Four elements of negligence
Duty, breach, causation, damages. The plaintiff must prove all four.
Reasonable person standard
The duty is to act as a reasonable person (here, a reasonable advisor) would under the circumstances. Not a duty to prevent every loss; advisors don't guarantee returns.
Uniform Prudent Investor Act (UPIA)
Statute setting a fiduciary's duty:
1)invest prudently
2)Diversify unless special circumstances apply
3)set a strategy suited to the client, and keep monitoring.
Usually your controlling rule for duty.
Tibble v. Edison International
2015 Supreme Court case. Plan managers kept high-fee retail fund shares when cheaper identical institutional shares were available. Held that a fiduciary has a continuing duty to monitor investments and remove imprudent ones, not just choose them carefully at the start.
Old prudent man rule vs. prudent investor rule
Old rule: judged each investment alone and discouraged delegation and diversification. New rule (UPIA): judges the whole portfolio, requires diversification, and allows delegation with care.
T.J. Hooper
Following industry custom is no defense if the custom lags behind reliable, available technology. A tug owner was negligent for not buying radios that would have warned of a storm, even though most tugs didn't have them. Main use: breach.
Learned Hand formula (United States v. Carroll Towing)
Negligence if the burden of a precaution (B) is less than the probability of harm (P) times the size of the loss (L): B < PL. Use to prove breach.
Palkowski's three safeguards
Select, Scope, Supervise. 1) Prudent selection: check design, track record, data, conflicts. 2) Defined scope: risk limits, benchmarks, human control of major decisions. 3) Ongoing monitoring. Passive reliance is a breach.
Idiosyncratic risk
Risk tied to one company or sector (scandal, failed product, sector crisis). Uncompensated and avoidable by diversifying, so a fiduciary should minimize it.
Market risk
Risk of the whole market moving (recession, crash). Compensated with higher expected returns and can't be diversified away, so a fiduciary manages it to fit the client rather than avoiding it.
But-for causation
Causation-in-fact: would the harm still have happened if the defendant hadn't breached? If no, but-for causation is met. From the Torts Reading, p. 262.
Proximate cause (Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad)
Legal cause: no liability if the harm was too remote or unforeseeable, even if the breach was a but-for cause. Railroad not liable when fireworks exploded and scales fell on Mrs. Palsgraf.
Unavoidable market drop defense
The defense argues the loss came from market risk, not the breach. Answer (your own analysis): market-wide losses aren't caused by the breach, but extra losses from over-concentration are.
Comparative negligence (CASE)
Scott v. Alpha Beta. Damages are split by each side's percentage of fault. Scott slipped in wet slippers on a wet store floor: store 60%, Scott 40%, so she recovered $120,000 of $200,000. Use when the client shares blame.
Hindsight defense
Prudence is judged by what the advisor knew and did at the time, not by how things turned out (In re Chamberlain's Estate). A defense argument.
Winn Dixie v. Benton
A store was liable for a milk spill it should have noticed and cleaned within a reasonable time. Use if the AI flagged a risk and the advisor sat on the warning.
Deterministic fields
Fixed cause-and-effect rules; same inputs give the same verifiable answer. Example: core finance and wealth management. Hard structured data, mostly yes-or-no errors, AI automates and optimizes.
Probabilistic fields
Outcomes based on likelihoods; output is a best estimate. Example: clinical dermatology. Messy data like images, errors in degrees like false negatives, AI recognizes patterns as a second set of eyes.