1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Who wrote the cosmological argument?
Thomas Aquinas
What type of argument is it and what do they mean
Inductive so probabilistic and a posteriori after empirical evidence/ experience
What are Aquinas’ five ways?
Motion
Causation
Contingency and Necessity
Perfection
Design
Explain Aquinas Third way?
It is the observation that all things we see in the universe are contingent, they are moved changed and caused. They do not need to exist but they do. From this observation Aquinas concludes that something must exist necessarily. It must be outside the observable universe because there is nothing in what we observe that can explain why contingent things exist.
Write the cosmological argument as an inductive proof 8 points?
P1- everything in the natural world is contingent and everything can exist or not exist
P2- if everything is contingent then at some time there was nothing because there must have been a time before anything had begun to exist
P3- if there was once nothing then nothing could have come from nothing
C1- therefore something must exist necessarily otherwise nothing would now exist which is false
P4- everything necessary must either be caused or uncaused
P5- but the series of necessary beings cannot be infinite or there would be no explanation of that series
C2- therefore there must be some uncaused being which exists of its own necessity
C3- by this we all understand God
How does Frederick Copleston support Aquinas?
He says in order to explain existence we must come to a Being which contains within itself the reason for its own existence that is to say which cannot not exist. It is only God who can be the necessarily existent first cause of the universe. He uses Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason- therefore must be a sufficient reason why there is something rather than nothing why this particular universe exists
What is Bertrand Russell’s critique of the argument?
The fallacy of composition- a fallacy is a failure in reasoning which makes an argument invalid. The fallacy of composition is the fallacy of inferring that something is true of the whole from the fact that it is true of part of the whole. For example hydrogen is not wet, oxygen is not wet. Therefore water is not wet. Which is clearly wrong. We cannot move from our observations of the parts like the earth and stars to a conclusion about the universe
What is Hume’s criticism of the argument? And how does Aquinas respond?
Hume says that the universe itself is the necessarily existent being you do not need to go one step further back and say that it is God. This approach confirms to Occam’s Razor that the simplest explanation is usually the right one. The universe, like a vegetable, could have created itself.
Aquinas responds by saying that the matter would be caused by a necessary being and would still need God as an uncaused necessary being to cause its existence
What is another criticism of the argument from Hume and how would theists respond?
If everything has a cause then what caused God
The argument is based on the observation that everything must have a cause but Aquinas then argues that there is something without a cause- God. Even if infinite regression is not possible there is no evidence for the monotheistic christian God being the first cause. Hume also argues that the words necessarily existence have no meaning. He argues there is no being whose non existence implies a contradiction. Any being claimed to exist may or may not exist
Theists would respond by saying that God is the only being with the characteristics capable of being the First Cause
What is Mackies criticism?
He says none of the Five Ways work as they either depend on some untenable medieval physical principle or just fail to establish a conclusion. He says we have no reason for accepting this implicit assumption.
Does the argument offer proof?
Yes because it is inductive and a posteriori so rationally and empirically based. Gerry Hughes says it is a more satisfactory explanation than the universe being a brute fact. Being an inductive argument means that the conclusions are probabilistic
No because only deductive arguments can give absolute proof and the cosmological argument is inductive so can never be absolutely certain. It may struggle to convince atheists instead only offers reasoning for theists. Fideists would argue that belief in God is a matter of faith not proof. Stephen Evans says the argument does not prove the God of Christian theism
Does it have value for faith?
Yes because it is rationally and empirically based so provides strong support for theists. It is consistent with biblical teachings like Genesis 1:1 ‘in the beginning God created the heavens and earth’ it confirms teachings that God is directing nature in a meaningful way. Gives evidence to support the belief God exists
No because for Fideists rational arguments play no part in faith as they do not lead to commitment. Belief in God should be based on faith alone not trying to prove God exists. Aquinas himself didnt think the argument was sufficient on its own as there are some key ideas about the christian God which are revealed in the bible and church teachings.