1/12
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ultimate telos
Fellowship with God
Eternal law
Principles that God used to create foundations of universe; only known to God
Natural Law
Law of God that is revealed in nature; partial reflection of EL
Divine Law
Law of God revealed in the Bible; partial reflection of EL
Human Law
Fallible law of humans, ideally derived from NL and DL
Synderesis Principle
Do good and avoid evil
Primary precepts
Fixed and unchangeable commandments to apply synderesis;
Protection
Order
Worship God
Education
Reproduction
Secondary precepts
Commandments derived from primary precepts; e.g sexual protection banned due to conflict with reproduction
Internal vs external acts
Internal act = intent behind a moral action
External act = result of the action
Internal act > external act; intent > result
E.g prevention of abortion is a good external act (reproduction) but if not done out of the primary precepts then action as a whole isn’t good
A good internal act but bad external act is amoral
Real vs Apparent goods
Real good = good which aligns with reasoning and primary precepts
Apparent good = action which aligns with reasoning but not the primary precepts
No human can pursue anything but real/apparent goods; “no evil can be desirable, either by natural appetite or by conscious will
Doctrine of Double Effect
Immoral acts may be justified under 4 conditions:
Good action obtained by means of a bad effect (terminate ectopic pregnancy)
Bad effects are permitted rather than intended (passive euthanasia)
Proportionally grave reason for permitting bad effects are permitted (self-defence)
Action must be good/indifferent
Strengths of NML
Primary precepts can be observed across multiple cultures, ie protection/reproduction
Single standard of truth; “Natural law is the same for all men…there is a single standard of truth and right for everyone…which is known by everyone”
Ability to reason is accessible to all; “To disparage the dictate of reason is equivalent to condemning the command of God”
Weaknesses of NML
Human nature/goods is subjective; little evidence of common law between different societies e.g North Sentinel, ’The concept of human nature is a rather vague cultural concept; it is not a scientific one’ - Kai Nelson
Represents legalistic morality condemned by Jesus (Pharisees)
Outdated compared to modern era; excludes infertile, homosexuals etc
Is-ought gap, just because sex produces babies doesn’t mean it ought to always be used as such