1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
P1 and E1
L - issues with generalising the findings to humans
E- this is as humans do not imprint like geese do
1E2 L1 C1
instead attachment is a slow process that can take up to 7 months where a close and emotional bond is formed
Lorenzs findings lack population validity as we cannot apply them to human attachment behaviours
However, the concept of a critical period in humans has been supported by further research and theorists increasing reliability
P2 E2 2E2
L - some of Lorenzo’s conclusions can be questioned
Guiton made chickens imprint on yellow rubber gloves
found that chickens would try to later, mate with rubber gloves but did eventually learn to mate with other chickens
L2 F2
therefore suggest that Lorenz’s assumption that this was a permanent change is incorrect, decreases validity
Furthermore, Lorenz has been criticised for deliberately removing the geese from their mother questioning the ethics of the experiment
HARLOW
P1 E1 2E1
L - ethical issues
Monkeys were very similar to humans. These questions the necessity of causing such harm to monkeys.
We can assume that due to similarity the trauma they would experience would be similar to the trauma infant would experience
L1 C1
therefore, harlow should how sensitive and vulnerable monkeys are to maternal deprivation and the lifelong damage that early neglect causes them questioning whether the research should have ever taken place
however, Harlow’s research offered a theoretical breakthrough challenging the previously established idea that infants form an attachment to who feeds them
P2 E2 2E2
S - provides theoretical and practical value
harlow’s findings developed out understanding on the effect of maternal deprivation and impact on later adult bhvrs
E.g. he demonstrated that infants who do not form attachments will likely go on to become poor caregivers themselves. This is helped social workers understand risk factors in neglect and abuse cases.
L2 C2
therefore the usefulness of harlows research help provide insight to attachment formation increasing its ecological validity
however, Harlow study has poor population validity as the participants were monkey so we cannot be sure infants will be behave in the same way
BOWLBY
P1 E1 2E1
S- of Bowlby‘s concept of the critical period comes from research support by Lorenz
Lorenz studied in printing in geese and found that there was a critical period for geese imprint 12 to24 hours if they did not imprint in this time then they never would.
This process appears to be innate in some bird species and helps them to survive
L1 C1
therefore this is a strength as it increases the reliability of Bowlbys idea
however developmental psychologist often prefer the term sensitive period as opposed to critical period as attachments have been shown to made after Bowlbys proposed critical period
P2 E2 2E2
L- a limitation of Bowlby‘s monotropic theory of attachment is an alternate explanation from Kagan.
He suggested that the temperament of an infant influence with they become secure or insecurely attached.
kagan propose the temperament hypothesis which considers infants varying temperament on how some babies are most sociable and “easy” whereas others are more anxious and “difficult”
L2 C2
this is a limitation of Bowlby as he does not consider how genetic components of personality may impact attachment quality reducing the validity
however concepts such as the internal working model and community hypothesis have a wealth of support supporting research behind them such as hazan and shavers love quiz that suggested that infants with the secure earlier attachment are more likely to go and have meaningful long lasting adult relationship relationships
P3 E3 2E3
S- of bowlbys concept of the internal working model comes from research support by Bailey
They found that ppts who had poor attachments to their mother were significantly more likely to have poor attachments to their own children.
Bailey assessed 99 mothers with one year old infants on their relationship to their mothers using the standard interview and assessed their attachment to their child
L3 C3
therefore this support bowlby’s idea that our initial attachment set the tone for all future adult relationships increasing the reliability of the theory
however there is mixed evidence for the importance of monotropy. Schaeffer and Emerson refute the idea that infants only form one special attachment and note that most infants form multiple attachments.