1/151
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the steps of analyzing negligence?
Duty, breach, factual causation, proximate cause, defenses, damages
What element of negligence does res ipsa belong under?
Breach
What are the main areas with big jurisdictional splits?
Landowner duty, parental immunity, bystander emotional harm, economic loss, and comparative fault types
How should you handle contributory negligence and implied AoR on the exam?
Note briefly that they existed and why they were replaced, then analyze under comparative negligence
What is the difference between negligence and strict liability?
Negligence requires defendant to have failed to use reasonable care, strict liability imposes liability even with reasonable care (drops breach)
What are the four goals of tort law to use as policy arguments?
Compensation for victims, deterrence, fairness/morality, and administrative efficiency
What are brief facts and the rule from Brown v. Kendall?
Defendant hit plaintiff in the eye while separating dogs; established fault-based liability for accidental harms, meaning plaintiff has burden to prove defendant failed to use ordinary care
What are brief facts and the rule from Hammontree v. Jenner?
Driver with seizures who was cleared crashed into plaintiff; negligence applies not strict liability, plaintiff must prove the defendant was careless and he wasn’t
What are the elements for the Birkner test for vicarious liability?
Conduct was the general kind the employee was hired to perform
It occurred substantially within the hours and ordinary spatial boundaries of employment
Motivated at least in part to serve the employer
What does Christensen say about vicarious liability?
A security guard on an off-site break to get food was involved in a collision; the issue of scope of employment under Birkner could go to a jury, not automatically dismissed even though she was off-site
What is the rationale for vicarious liability?
Employers are more likely to be solvent and insured (compensation), and they can supervise (deterrence)
What is the default rule for independent contractors?
No vicarious liability for the hiring party, unless apparent agency applies
What are the required elements for apparent agency under Roessler?
Representation by the principal that the contractor was its agent
Plaintiff’s reliance on the representation
Plaintiff’s detrimental change in position
What did Roessler say about apparent agency law?
Hospital could be liable for radiologist misreading scans despite not being an employee because he wore their uniform, worked at the hospital, and the hospital assigned him to plaintiff
Under the Third Restatement, what is the first question in the duty analysis?
Did the defendant’s own conduct create the risk of harm?
Under the Third Restatement, what is the duty for defendant’s who did create risk?
Default duty of reasonable care, unless a policy-based no-duty exception applies
Under the Third Restatement, what is the duty for defendant’s who did not create risk?
No duty to rescue (baby on the tracks), unless an affirmative duty exception applies
What is the public policy purpose of having no general duty to rescue?
Personal liberty, not cheapening heroism, and not endangering bystanders
What are the brief facts of Moch and it’s importance?
Utility company failed to supply hydrant water pressure to stop a fire, so defendant created a risk, but the court allowed a no-duty exception; the court justified based on the distinction between omission and commission, but not good law anymore
What are the brief facts of Strauss and it’s importance?
Electric company caused blackout and tenant fell on dark stairs in apartment, defendant created a risk but court used no-duty exception; court limited the “orbit of duty” to those in contract with the utility company to avoid crushing liability
What policy arguments get weighed in no-duty cases?
Floodgates of lawsuits and crushing liability vs. no deterrence and plaintiff left to bear the cost
What are the brief facts of Reynolds and it’s importance?
Minor drove drunk after wedding and hit plaintiff; defendant wedding hosts did create the risk but court said no-duty exception to third party because it would be unreasonable for social hosts to take all precautionary measures
What are the no-duty exceptions we’ve studied?
Moch: omission/commission, not good law
Strauss: limiting the orbit of duty to avoid crushing liability
Reynolds: social guests have no duty to third parties if it’s unreasonable
When can a statute create an affirmative duty?
When the statute’s purpose was to permit private lawsuits
What are the brief facts of Uhr and it’s importance?
School did not screen for scoliosis as required by statute, but plaintiff lost because the statute expressly immunized schools; otherwise, statutes can create duty
What does it mean to have a special relationship for affirmative duty?
Plaintiff and defendant have a custodial relationship where plaintiff depends on defendant for safety
List the Third Restatement’s special relationships for affirmative duty.
Common carriers, innkeepers, landowners open to the public, employers, schools, and doctors
Why was there no duty in Harper v. Herman?
No custodial special relationship between the boat owner and the guest who dove off into shallow water, knowing about danger doesn’t create a duty to warn
What is voluntary undertaking?
An affirmative duty if defendant starts to help plaintiff, they must act reasonably and not leave plaintiff worse off
What are the brief facts of Farwell v. Keaton and it’s importance?
Plaintiff was beat up by another person, then defendant iced his head and left him in a car where he died; affirmative duty based on voluntary undertaking
What are the brief facts of Randi W. and it’s importance?
School districts chose to write letters had to avoid hiding known sexual misconduct; affirmative duty to not misrepresent when there is a foreseeable risk of physical harm to third party
What is the rule from Tarasoff?
Affirmative duty created when a professional who knows a patient poses a serious danger of violence to a foreseeable third party
What are the brief facts of Vince v. Wilson and it’s importance?
Aunt funded a car for nephew who was a bad driver; affirmative duty to third party in car crash because of negligent entrustment of giving nephew something dangerous
What are the Rowland factors and what are they used for?
Used to evaluate whether an affirmative duty is owed to a third party; courts consider: foreseeability (most important), closeness of connection, moral blame, policy of preventing future harm, and insurance
What is categorical foreseeability?
Courts ask whether this type of harm is generally foreseeable enough to justify a rule for the whole category, not whether this specific plaintiff was foreseeable
List the affirmative duty exceptions (no third party).
Uhr: statute creates a duty
Third Restatement: special relationship
Farwell: voluntary undertaking
List the affirmative duty exceptions (yes third party).
Randi W.: foreseeable third party based on misrepresentation
Tarasoff: foreseeable third party from a patient
Vince: negligent entrustment
What are the traditional common law landowner duty categories?
Licensee (have permission): only duty for known dangers
Invitee (material benefit or public land): duty for known dangers and unknown that would be inspected
Trespassers: no duty, don’t willfully harm
What landowner duty approach is used in Carter v. Kinney and how is it applied?
Traditional categories; Bible study guest was a licensee so he was not owed a duty by landowner to protect against unknown ice
What landowner duty approach is used in Heins and how is it applied?
Duty to all lawful entrants based on foreseeability, abolished the common law categories; hospital visitor slipped on steps but categories were too unclear for courts to label
What is the test from Posecai?
When there is crime on business premises, balance foreseeability of the crime and the gravity of the harm against the burden of more precautions on site
What is the approach that Professor Feldman and the Third Restatement take for business crimes?
Treat business-customer as a special relationship that does create a duty, and debate foreseeability of the crime under breach and BPL
Why are courts split on landowner duty?
Traditional approach like in Carter is predictable with set rules, modern approach like Heins doesn’t depend on arbitrary lines for categories; states are split in half
What is the modern rule for spousal immunity?
Abolished in almost every state, spouses owe a duty to each other
What are the rationales for allowing parental immunity?
Family harmony, allowing parental discretion, stopping fraud and collusion to collect insurance, and depletion of family resources
What are the parental immunity approaches we’ve learned in class?
New York: full immunity, no duty
Goller: immunity for issues of parental discretion, otherwise yes duty
Second Restatement: breach when conduct is “palpably unreasonable”
Broadbent: reasonable parent standard for breach analysis
How did Broadbent analyze parental immunity?
Using a reasonable parent standard, court said a mother leaving her toddler in pool to answer the phone had a duty so breach question for jury
Where does Professor Feldman and the Third Restatement put foreseeability?
In breach, not duty
What did Behrendt say about foreseeability?
Foreseeability not for duty analysis, the employer had a duty to the employee, but because the harm was unforeseeable it meant no breach
Which cases still use foreseeability to decide duty?
Randi W., Tarasoff, and Palsgraf
What’s the first step in analyzing duty in state/municipal government?
Decide whether the act was ministerial (set rule) or discretionary (policy judgment)
Are state/municipal government discretionary acts immune?
Yes, as long as there is a reasonable basis for the decision
Why did the state lose it’s immunity in Friedman?
The state unreasonably delayed building a median it had already decided was necessary to reduce risk, but a reasonable decision that no barrier was needed stayed immune
What happens if a state/municipal government violates a ministerial duty?
It is no longer immune, but plaintiff still has to establish duty some other way
What are the Cuffy factors used for and what are they?
Cuffy factors are used to establish a special relationship between police and plaintiff that creates a duty to act
Government assumed an affirmative duty through promises or actions
Government knew inaction could lead to harm
Direct contact between government and the injured party
Plaintiff justifiably relied on promise
How did the court in Lauer analyze duty?
State medical examiner violated a ministerial duty so no immunity, but there was no special relationship with the plaintiff so no duty
What is the public duty doctrine?
State/municipal government owes duties to the public at large, not to individuals, absent a special relationship
What did Riss say about state/municipal duty?
Police inaction after repeated requests for protection does not create a duty because courts shouldn’t allocate police resources and liability would be crushing
Why did the police owe Schuster a duty?
Police solicited Schuster’s help as an informant, so that created a duty to protect
Why was there no duty in Riss, but a duty in Sorichetti?
In Riss, the police had no duty because they made no specific promise of protection to the plaintiff, whereas in Sorichetti, a special relationship created a duty through a court-issued order of protection, the police's knowledge of the father's violent history, and their specific assurances to the mother that they would take action
Why was there no duty in Lovelac for 911 call?
Caller was not the injured plaintiff, so there was no special relationship between police and plaintiff that would create a duty
Do federal governments have default immunity?
No, under the FTCA federal sovereign immunity was waived except for discretionary functions
What are the brief facts of Cope and it’s importance?
Car crash on unpaved road with little signs, not paving the road was immune because it was a discretionary decision for the government based on budget policy, but signs are cheap and easy so even though they were discretionary, there was no immunity
What is the Feres doctrine?
No liability for injuries to service members arising from military service, except for malpractice
What are the steps that Cope lays out for federal duty?
Ministerial or discretionary?
If discretionary, grounded in policy?
If policy-laden then yes immunity, if not then no immunity
If no immunity, move onto breach
What is parasitic emotional harm, and is it recoverable?
Emotional harm that accompanies a physical injury, recoverable without a special test
What is the default rule for freestanding emotional harm?
No duty, unless a recognized category applies
What is the zone of danger?
Test for recovering emotional harm, requires a reasonable fear of imminent physical harm to oneself and distress that produces physical manifestations
What happened in Falzone and what test did it create?
Plaintiff almost got hit by a car and got sick from the distress after, created the zone of danger test which displaced the old physical impact requirement for recovery
What happened in Gammon and what was the rule?
Plaintiff was delivered a severed leg instead of father’s belongings, rule is that in a situation so disturbing that an ordinary person would foreseeably suffer serious distress you can recover
What did the court in Johnson v. Jamaica hospital say about duty?
No duty to parents who suffered emotional harm from baby kidnapping because they were not in the zone of danger themselves
What are the Dillon/Portee bystander factors?
Death or serious injury, close relationship, direct sensory observation at the scene, and severe emotional distress
What happened in Portee v. Jaffee and what was the rule?
Mother watched son die trapped in an elevator, mother could recovery even outside the zone of danger because all Dillon bystander factors were met
What is loss of consortium?
A spouse can recover for lost companionship when the other spouse is physically injured
What happened in Diaz and what was the rule?
Plaintiff could recover for loss of consortium because of husband’s injury from chemicals in the workplace
Where do courts split on loss of consortium?
Courts are split on whether to allow unmarried partners to recover and children to recover from parent’s injury
Why did the worker in Metro-North lose?
Exposure to asbestos without an imminent threat isn’t enough, fear of future disease isn’t recoverable unless it’s more likely than not to occur
When is economic loss recoverable under ordinary negligence?
When it flows from physical injury or property damage
What are the Second Restatement elements for negligent misinformation?
Plaintiff is in the limited group the information was intended for
Plaintiff relied on information
Defendant knew plaintiff would rely
What happened in Nycal v. KPMG?
Auditor didn’t know investor would rely on negligent information, so no recovery for economic loss using Second Restatement factors
What are the 3 approaches to negligent misinformation?
New York: requires privity between parties
Second Restatement: factors based on reliance
New Jersey: only requires plaintiff be foreseeable
What happened in LAN/STV?
Contractor couldn’t sue architect for bad designs because there was no contract between them, the economic loss rule pushes contractual issues into contract law not torts
Who can recover from legal malpractice?
Clients always are owed a duty as long as they can show there would’ve been a different outcome, and nonclients only can in limited circumstances under Biakanja factors
What are the Biakanja factors?
Intent was to affect plaintiff, foreseeability, certainty of injury, closeness of connection, deterrence, and burden on profession
What happened in Southern California Gas?
Businesses lost revenue from negligent gas leak, company had no duty because they were ripple-effect losses with no relationship to the company
Why was People Express an outlier for economic loss?
Court allowed recovery for a small, identifiable, foreseeable class of businesses in airport
What is the basic breach question?
Did the defendant fail to exercise the care a reasonable person would use under all the circumstances?
What is the Hand formula?
Defendant breached if B < P x L (burden of the untaken precaution is less than probability times gravity of harm)
Analyze Carroll Towing using the Hand formula.
Burden of keeping a bargee aboard during working hours was a small burden compared to the risk of a barge breaking free during a busy time and causing harm
Analyze Adams v. Bullock using the Hand formula.
The burden of the precautions of insulating wires or shutting down the trolley were impractical compared to the low chance someone would swing on a wire
How does foreseeability fit into the Hand formula?
It limits plaintiff, there’s no duty to guard against extraordinary, unforeseeable harm
When does the standard of care change?
For people with visible physical disabilities, children doing child activities, and children below 5
Which characteristics do not change the standard of care?
Mental illness, gender, geography, hidden disabilities, old age, and children doing adult activities
What was the rule in Vaughan v. Menlove?
The objective standard of care applies even if defendant lacked intelligence to know better
What standard do common carriers owe under Bethel?
Ordinary reasonable care under the circumstances, not heightened care
What is the difference between a standard of conduct and a standard of care?
A standard of conduct is a fixed judge-made rule, a standard of care lets the jury decide reasonableness case-by-case
In Goodman, how did Judge Holmes set a standard of conduct?
He made a blanket rule that drivers at railroad crossings must stop, look, and get out if necessary, or else they cannot recover at all
How did Cardozo respond to the Goodman case?
Cardozo in the Pokora case said that a standard of conduct for drivers is too broad because getting out of the car at crossings can sometimes be more dangerous, so the jury should decide each case not the judge
What are the arguments on either side of the judge vs. jury debate?
Judges provide more consistency across similar cases, but juries embody the reasonable person
What function does custom serve in breach analysis?
Custom is evidence for the jury, but it’s never conclusive of breach