1/33
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Statutory location of directors' general duties in UK company law
Sections 171 to 177 of the Companies Act 2006 (Part 10, Chapter 2).
Relationship between statutory directors' duties and pre-existing principles (s 170(3)-(4) CA 2006)
The codified duties are based on, and must be interpreted in line with, the common law rules and equitable principles that they replaced.
Primary managerial responsibility of a director
The management of the company's business, exercised together with the rest of the board of directors.
Primary legal beneficiary of directors' general duties (s 170(1) CA 2006)
The company itself, rather than individual shareholders or creditors.
Party entitled to sue directly for breach of directors' duties
The company, because the duties are owed directly to the corporate entity.
Procedure for shareholders seeking indirect remedy for breach of directors' duties
Bringing a derivative claim on behalf of the company under Part 11 of the Companies Act 2006, which requires permission from the court.
Modification of directors' duties when nearing or facing insolvency (Sequana rule)
Under s 172(3) CA 2006 and BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [2022], when a company is insolvent, bordering on insolvency, or an insolvent liquidation/administration is probable, directors must consider and give appropriate weight to creditors' interests.
The seven general statutory directors' duties codified under Chapter 2, Part 10 CA 2006
Requirements of the duty to act within powers (s 171 CA 2006)
A director must:
Core standard of the duty to promote company success (s 172(1) CA 2006)
A director must act in the way they consider, in good faith, would be most likely to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole (with 'success' generally meaning a long-term increase in value).
Section 172(1) statutory stakeholder and policy considerations
Enlightened shareholder value
The principle underpinning s 172 CA 2006 requiring directors to promote the benefit of members as a whole by considering and managing wider stakeholder interests (such as employees, suppliers, customers, and the environment).
Statutory reporting obligation for large companies regarding s 172 compliance
The requirement to include a formal s 172 statement within their strategic report explaining how directors considered stakeholder factors.
Requirements of the duty to exercise independent judgment (s 173 CA 2006)
Directors must exercise their own judgment rather than unquestioningly following instructions from others, though it is not breached by acting in accordance with valid constitutional provisions or agreements entered into by the company.
Dual test for the standard of care, skill, and diligence (s 174 CA 2006)
Scope of the duty to avoid conflicts of interest (s 175 CA 2006)
A director must avoid situations where they have or can have a direct or indirect interest conflicting with company interests, applying in particular to exploiting property, information, or opportunities regardless of whether the company could have taken advantage of them.
Statutory situations where the s 175 conflict duty is not infringed
Duty not to accept benefits from third parties (s 176 CA 2006)
A duty prohibiting directors from accepting benefits from a third party conferred due to their being a director or taking/refraining from any act as a director (e.g., bribes or kickbacks), unless it cannot reasonably be regarded as likely to create a conflict.
Duty to declare an interest in a proposed transaction (s 177 CA 2006)
A requirement for any director directly or indirectly interested in a proposed transaction or arrangement with the company to declare the nature and extent of that interest to the other directors before the company enters into it.
Distinction between declarations under s 177 and s 182 CA 2006
Section 177 applies to interests in proposed transactions prior to entry, whereas section 182 is a separate statutory requirement to declare interests in existing transactions as soon as reasonably practicable (the breach of which is a criminal offence).
Examples of indirect interests under s 177 CA 2006
Interests held through a spouse, civil partner, or relative, or through another company or firm in which the director holds an interest (e.g., as a shareholder).
Methods for declaring an interest under s 177 CA 2006
Declaring the interest before the company enters the transaction either at a board meeting, by written notice to the other directors, or via a general notice.
General notice under s 185 CA 2006
A standing notice given to fellow directors stating that a director has an interest in a specified company, firm, or person and is to be regarded as interested in any future transaction with them, satisfying both s 177 and s 182.
Statutory exceptions to declaring an interest under s 177(5)-(6) CA 2006
Constructive knowledge rule under s 177(5) CA 2006
A director is treated as aware of matters they ought reasonably to be aware of, meaning ignorance caused by carelessness or lack of inquiry does not afford a legal defence.
Best practice for directors regarding potential conflicts of interest
Fully declaring the interest to the board and having it formally recorded in board minutes, rather than relying on statutory exceptions that may be uncertain.
Default voting and quorum restriction under Model Article 14 (MA 14)
A director with an interest in an actual or proposed transaction or arrangement with the company cannot vote or be counted in the quorum on that board decision.
Mechanisms to overcome Model Article 14 voting restrictions
Permitted causes under Model Article 14(4)
Remedies available for breach of duty of care, skill, and diligence (s 174 CA 2006)
Common law damages (financial compensation for losses caused by the director's negligence).
Remedies available for breach of general fiduciary duties (ss 171-173 and ss 175-177 CA 2006)
Shareholder advance authorisation under s 180 CA 2006
Advance approval given by shareholders based on full disclosure that permits conduct that would otherwise breach ss 171–177, provided the Act or articles allow.
Shareholder ratification rules after a breach (s 239 CA 2006)
Ratification occurs by ordinary resolution of shareholders; the votes of the conflicted director (if a member) and any connected persons are disregarded, though they may attend and count towards the quorum.
Director acts incapable of shareholder ratification under UK company law
Unlawful acts (such as paying dividends without available distributable profits) and acts amounting to a fraud on the minority.