1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Butler education act (1st) → tripartite system + criticism
based on idea of meritocracy. Students took 11+ exam to determine if tey would attdnd grammer (top studetns so prepared for hgiher education) , secondary modern (prepared for lower class jobs → children who failed 11+) or technical schools (vocational → means gives skills for a job, working class)
-goal was to provide parity of esteem → idea al schools were equal in status, different in focus.
Criticism: System supported class inequality → 11+ cultrually biased toward midddle class children (more cultural and economic capital) meaning grammar schools became mostly for the elite because those who failed went to secondary modern.
Secondary moderns seen as ‘failing’ schools, stigmatising 80% of children as failures → self fulfilling prophecy + in some areas girls had to achieve higher than boys to get a grammar school place
New labour (4)
Reduce inequality caused by marketisation of schools, but still keep marketisation.
Tony Blair’s gov tried to keep ‘market’ but reduce inequality. E.g Education maintenacne allowance (EMA): weekly payment of up to 30 pounds per week to give to studtns of low income families if they stayed in school or college after 16.
INtroduced Education action zones (EZA) to provide extra funding to deprived areas
Aim Higher program launched to encourage working class kids to go to uni
Academies: bulldozed failing schools, rebuilt stricter ones. E.g some had detention booking similar to local prisons, glass windows and doors for principal to look through at all times, no talking when changing classes.
Criticisms: Benn → beleived policies were a contradiction. Helped poor by introducing Education maintenance allowance, also introduced University tuition fees which was a barrier to same working class students they claimed to be helping. This contradiction is called New labour paradox
Comprehensive shcool sustem (2)
meant to overcome class divide caused by tripartite school system ( social solidarity by making children from different classes mix) and make education more meritocratic.
Labour gov abolished 11+ exams (but some grammar schools still remain → still state - funded), and instead established local cathcment areas which has schools that only people in that catchment area could go to.
Criticisms: Functionalists like Ford found that social mixing doesn’t happen because students usually stuck to their own cliques. Marxists argue comprehensive school system move sifting and sorting inside school through streaming and setting, where working class children still eneded up in bottom sets, still the tripartite system in miniture.
Education reform act (3) - Marketisation and parentocracy:
Marketisation and parentocracy:
1988 act introduced marketisation, idea that schools should compete like businesses. David coined term parentocarcy (rule by parents) → parents had most power. If parents had power to choose child’s education, schools forced to improve standards to attract customers. Used Ofstead, league tables, open enrollment (students could apply to schools outside catchment areas), specialist schools (diff branding so gave diverse range of ‘products’ for parents to choose from), formula funding (more students = more money) → to have enough resources, must have money
Criticisms: ‘Parentocracy’ is a middle class phenomenon - when law gives choice, only those with enough financial and social (connections and knowledge) resrouces can actually choose → only wealthy parents could afford to move to go to school in diff actchment areas for open enrollement due to transport fees
Education reform act (3) - League tables and Cream skimming
Parents need info to compare schools to enocurgage marketisation.
→ National League tables introduced; pubished school exam results, created high stakes environment for competition; failing schools shamed, successful schools rewarded with formula funding
Criticisims: Barlett argues that successful schools becomes selective, picking highest achieving pupils → middle class. Avoid ‘expensive’ pupils (those who struggle academically, hae behavioral issues/special needs → shifting towards less successful schools (silt)
basically idea that high meaintencane studetns are shifted aside by schools (water)
Criticisms: in 2025/6 major debate broke out if private schools ( not run by gove) should have to pay a 20% VAT on the school fees they receive (currrently don’t). If do, can use money to improve state schools in poor areas to bridge inequality caused y education reform act as schools in poor areas are often struggling with funding as poor results, so less formula funding. However, if VAT removed, private school fees increase, middle class parents back into state schools → too much pressure on state schools.
Education reform act ideology
supported marketisation of schools, and also wanted more parental choice.
Education reform act (3) - formula funding
no more equal funding for al schools → based on number of pupils in enrollment → schools need children to get money for resources, compete to get children. Successful schools grow and receive money, unsuccessful schools forced to close or change management
Criticisms: Ball argues that formula funding creates ‘vicious’ cycle for deprived schools → unpopular school loses students, loses funding, no good teachers/facility, can’t improve
Education reform act (3) - myth of parentocracy
education amrket is rigged → choice offered by education reform act masks class and ethnic ineuqalitites.
Gerwitz’s study of 14 london schools:
priveledged skiled choosers - middle class parents with economic and cultural capital
disonnected local choosers - working class parents with limited economic and cultural capital
Semi - skilled choosers - working class parents who were ambitious for children but lacked cultural capital and economic capital to succeed → cultural capital is better thatn disconnected local choosers but most knowledge is based on opinions of others.