DR - Non-Party Disclosure and Norwich Pharmacal Orders

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/15

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

16 Terms

1
New cards

Civil Procedure Rule governing disclosure against a non-party

CPR 31.17 (alongside Section 34 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 or Section 53 of the County Courts Act 1984).

2
New cards

Timing requirement for seeking CPR 31.17 non-party disclosure

It can only be made after proceedings have already been commenced.

3
New cards

Procedural and jurisdictional basis of a Norwich Pharmacal order

The court's inherent equitable jurisdiction, recognized in Norwich Pharmacal Co v Customs & Excise Commissioners [1974] and expressly preserved by CPR 31.18.

4
New cards

Primary objective of a Norwich Pharmacal order

To obtain information from a third party mixed up in wrongdoing, usually to identify the wrongdoer so that proceedings can be initiated against them.

5
New cards

Timing for when a Norwich Pharmacal order may be sought

Most commonly sought before proceedings have started, but can technically be made at any stage.

6
New cards

Statutory two-part jurisdictional test for non-party disclosure (CPR 31.17(3))

  1. The documents must be likely to support the applicant's case or adversely affect another party's case.
  2. Disclosure must be necessary to dispose fairly of the claim or save costs.
7
New cards

Discretionary standard applied after meeting CPR 31.17(3) conditions

The court is not required to make an order; satisfying the test only establishes jurisdiction, and the court exercises discretion according to the overriding objective.

8
New cards

Service requirements for an application under CPR 31.17

The application must be served on the non-party respondent and on every existing party to the proceedings.

9
New cards

Required contents and evidence for an application and order under CPR 31.17(2) and (4)

The application must be supported by evidence. The order must specify documents or classes of documents, require the respondent to identify what is not in their control or withheld, and set the time and place for disclosure and inspection.

10
New cards

General costs rule for non-party disclosure under CPR 46.1(2)

The applicant must pay the non-party respondent's costs of the application and of complying with any order that is made.

11
New cards

Grounds for departing from the general costs rule under CPR 46.1(3)

The court may make a different order based on all circumstances, including the reasonableness of the respondent opposing the application and whether parties complied with relevant pre-action protocols.

12
New cards

Three conditions for a Norwich Pharmacal order (Mitsui & Co v Nexen Petroleum)

  1. A wrong was carried out, or arguably carried out, by an ultimate wrongdoer.
  2. The order is needed to enable action to be brought against that wrongdoer.
  3. The respondent was mixed up in the wrongdoing so as to facilitate it and can likely provide the needed information.
13
New cards

Distinction between a 'mere witness' and a respondent under the Norwich Pharmacal doctrine

A respondent cannot merely be an innocent bystander or witness; they must have been 'mixed up' in the wrongdoing to have facilitated it, even if not personally at fault.

14
New cards

Legal test articulated in Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd [2002]

A Norwich Pharmacal order must be both necessary and proportionate in all the circumstances of the case.

15
New cards

Costs framework for Norwich Pharmacal applications

The applicant typically pays the innocent third-party respondent's costs (including compliance), and may subsequently seek to recover those costs from the wrongdoer.

16
New cards

Crucial distinction between CPR 31.16 pre-action disclosure and a Norwich Pharmacal order

CPR 31.16 is strictly available against a person likely to be a party to the proceedings, whereas Norwich Pharmacal relief is sought against a third party who will not be a defendant.