1/34
Looks like no tags are added yet.
(1 - intro + early legal developments)
learning outcomes
1) describe how theory and research methods have shaped and influenced conceptions of + responses to criminals (up to the 1970s)
2) describe the development of forensic psychology as an applied discipline
3) provide a comparative outline of forensic psychology across the globe
what is presentism + why should we avoid it?
uncritical adherence to present-day attitudes, particularly interpreting past events in terms of modern values + concepts
→ need to understand historical ideas within the context of the time, rather than judging them entirely by today's standards
LO1
what happened in R v. Hadfield (1800)?
james hadfield suffered a head injury in battle
he attempted to murder King George III
he was tried for high treason but acquitted on grounds of insanity
what was the significance of R v. McNaughten (1843)?
-a person is not criminally responsible if, due to a defect of reason from a disease of the mind, they:
→ did not know the nature and quality of the act they were committing; or
- knew what they were doing but did not know it was wrong
2) biological theories of criminal behaviour
what was Lombroso's (1876) theory of biological positivism?
-criminality is inherited
-someone ‘born criminal’ can be anatomically identified by such items as a sloping forehead, ears of unusual size, asymmetry of the face, prognathism, excessive length of arms, asymmetry of the cranium + other ‘physical stigmata’
what did Galton (1879) claim to discover?
-the 'face of crime' through composite photographs
-combined multiple exposures of different individuals of a particular type (e.g. criminals) to produce an ideal or prototypical image
→ believed combining faces could reveal the typical appearance of a criminal
what was the underlying assumption of biological theories of criminal behaviour?
criminality is innate + that it is expressed in (or related to) physical characteristics
what were the problems with early biological theories?
-theories lacked credibility, though should be remembered for
developments in research methods
-they used ideas from Social Darwinism to support stereotypes, including racial biases + eugenics movements
-they relied heavily on physical measurements
LO2
what were the important developments in the late 1800s + early 1900s?
1890: Wilhelm Wundt established a laboratory in Leipzig
1896: First recorded example of a psychologist acting as an expert witness
1906: Freud's speech to Austrian judges
1908: Hugo Münsterberg published On the Witness Stand
who was hugo münsterberg + why was he important?
-controversial psychologist who published On the Witness Stand in 1908
-argued that courts should use experimental psychology to assess individual differences, beyond what common sense + social experience could establish
what did charles goring (1913) investigate?
in The English Convict, Goring investigated the relationship between physical characteristics + criminality
what did ernst kretschmer (1921) investigate?
Physique + Character, applying the relationship between body type + personality to clinical populations
what was sheldon’s 1942 constitutional approach?
body types were associated with three personality characteristics:
endomorph - viscerotonia (pleasure loving, dependent)
mesomorph - somatotonia (exercise loving, aggressive)
ectomorph - cerebrotonia (withdrawing, unsociable)
→ argued that (mesomorph) would be most likely to have traits related to delinquency; such as aggression, impulsivity + risk taking
what are some limitations of this approach?
-risks assuming that criminals look physically different from non-criminals
-may confuse correlation with causation
-overlooks environmental + social influences
-risks stereotyping individuals based on appearance
4) biological theories + social influences (1950s–1970s)
what did Bowlby (1946) suggest about criminal behaviour?
poor upbringing + early experiences could contribute to criminal behaviour
what happened to forensic psychology during the 1950s?
psychologists began working in the prison wervice + social influences started to receive greater attention
what did sheldon (1956) find in his study of delinquents?
compared:
500 persistent delinquents.
500 non-delinquents matched for age, intelligence, place of residence + ethnic background
→ 60% of delinquents, compared with 30% of non-delinquents, were classified as mesomorphs
did follow up studies support sheldon’s findings?
some did:
- Glueck + Glueck (1956)
- Cortes + Gatti (1972)
-however, McCandless et al. (1972) failed to replicate the finding
what alternative explanations could account for the relationship between mesomorphy + crime?
-certain types of body build may be instrumental in attracting police attention + thus over-selected
-muscular individuals might be more likely to be successful in crime (Feldman, 1977)
what is the XYY syndrome?
-about one in 1,000 males carries 47 chromosomes, the extra chromosome is a Y chromosome, so such individuals are categorised as XYY
-in carstairs maximum security hospital 7 out of 197 men convicted of violent offences were XYY
(i.e., 36 times greater than the norm for non-offenders - Lerner + Libby, 1976)
what were the limitations of the XYY theory?
-support for this theory has been mixed
-rutter + giller (1983) argue that ‘An extra Y chromosome …probably carries a slightly increased risk of behavioural problems’
-however, they note that some XYY men are well adjusted + the vast majority of criminals have no chromosomal abnormality
-we do not actually know the relationship between XYY + other variables that might influence delinquency, such as intelligence + social class
-there seems to some weak evidence for some predisposing biological factors in criminal behaviour, but a more comprehensive theory would need to include psychological factors
what did eysenck (1977) suggest about criminal personality?
-says heredity + the environment interact to cause criminal conduct
-twin studies indicate that identical twins (same genes) are more concordant in terms of criminal behaviour than fraternal twins, even if they grow up in the same environment
-9 studies indicate an average concordance rate of 55% for identicals + 13% for fraternals
what is a limitation of the twin-study evidence?
identical twins may be treated more similarly than fraternal twins
→ studies comparing identical twins raised apart would help establish the influence of heredity
what did eysenck's adoption studies suggest?
-children whose biological parents were criminals were more likely to become criminals, even if their adoptive parents were not
-however, criminality was highest when both biological + adoptive fathers were criminals, suggesting an additional environmental influence (Mednick et al., 1983)
what was a limitation of the adoption studies?
main problem - most children were adopted at birth - according to Bowlby, for example, separation from the mother in the first 5 years can lead to criminality; so could be due to parental separation
how did explanations of criminal behaviour change between the 1800s + 1970s (summary)?
Early to mid 1800s:
-early legal precedents around ‘insanity’
-biological focus
Late 1800s, early 1900s:
-greater emphasis on experimental methods
Early to mid 1900s:
-further work on biological models
-stunted growth of legal psychology
1950s to 1970s:
-shift to include social factors
LO3
how has forensic psychology developed in the czech republic?
since 1990s, increase in:
-research + academic literature
-roles for forensic psychologists in government + czech police
-courses forensic psychology at universities
-psychologists being judiciary experts
forensic psychology used as tool for:
-police officers (recruitment + dealing with trauma)
-studies on crime prevention (societal level)
what demographic + crime information was presented about the Czech Republic (Polisenska, 2007)
-located in central europe
-slightly smaller than the UK, with around a sixth of its population.
-landlocked
-joined the european union in 2004
-property crimes accounted for approximately 66.6% of crimes
-violent crimes accounted for approximately 6.3%
what are the main challenges facing forensic psychology in India (Karandikar, 2017)?
-in the top ten countries with the highest crime rate; 7th largest in the world, 2nd most populated
-need more FPs involved in criminal investigations + the criminal justice system
-some help in high profile cases but discredited by Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
-researchers are collecting data about offenders + types of criminals but not a joined up approach with government institutions which would help
→ CBI & police would benefit from analysis of crime data
-prisons – ‘fall behind’ other countries in terms of using psychologists (forensic + clinical) in rehabilitation + assessment
-overcrowding, tress, bullying, mental health issues create further challenges
-few forensic psychology courses, need to make FP more attractive as a profession
summary
-theories + research have moved on from singular causal theories since the 1800s
-forensic psychology’s history is steeped in famous cases that have paved the way for law, further research + more evidence-based practice
-forensic psychology as we know it is very ‘Western- centric
-is an increase in FP in other countries/continents, but not necessarily a good thing to ‘copy’ the West