1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Lecture overview
This topic answers three main questions:
Sources of EU law: Where does EU law come from, and which sources have greater legal authority?
EU law-making: How do EU institutions create legislation, and which institutions are involved?
Controls on EU law-making: Can the EU legislate whenever it wants, or are there legal limits on its powers?
The lecturer emphasised that the slides are a starting point for understanding the subject. The textbook reading and workshops explore these principles in greater depth.
Part 1: Sources of EU Law
1.1 What are the sources of EU law?
The EU has its own legal system, consisting of different sources of law.
Collectively, these sources form what is known as the acquis communautaire.
What is the acquis communautaire?
The acquis communautaire refers to the collection of rights and obligations that make up the body of EU law.
It is not a single document. Rather, it includes the different laws, legal principles and obligations developed within the EU.
It also continuously evolves as the EU adopts new laws and develops its legal system.
The main sources include:
Treaties: The Treaty on European Union (TEU) and Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU).
Charter of Fundamental Rights: Protects fundamental rights within the EU legal framework.
General principles of EU law: Fundamental legal principles recognised within the EU legal system.
Legislative acts: Laws adopted through the EU's legislative procedures.
Delegated and implementing acts: Acts adopted through procedures other than the legislative procedures.
Case law of the CJEU: Decisions of the Court of Justice of the European Union.
International agreements: Agreements concluded by the EU.
Soft law: Non-binding instruments that can influence legal interpretation or behaviour.
Important: The lecturer specifically pointed out that international agreements are also part of EU law, even though they were not included in the initial acquis diagram.
1.2 The hierarchy of EU law
Not all sources of EU law have the same legal authority.
The hierarchy of norms determines which legal instruments take priority over others.
The basic rule is:
A legal instrument lower in the hierarchy must comply with the legal instruments above it.
For example, EU legislation cannot lawfully contradict the EU Treaties.
The lecturer explained that the original EC Treaty did not contain a formal hierarchy of norms, but the Lisbon Treaty clarified the hierarchy.
Hierarchy shown in the lecture slides
1. Constituent Treaties and Charter
TEU, TFEU and Charter of Fundamental Rights
2. General principles of EU law
Fundamental principles recognised by EU law
3. International agreements
Agreements entered into by the EU
4. Legislative acts
Regulations, directives and decisions adopted through legislative procedures
5. Delegated and implementing acts
Acts adopted under Articles 290 and 291 TFEU
Why does this hierarchy matter?
The Treaties establish the EU's objectives, powers and institutional framework. However, the Treaties alone are not sufficient to achieve the EU's goals.
The EU therefore needs legal acts to put those objectives into practice.
For example, if the EU wants to reduce environmental pollution, it may adopt legislation to regulate particular products.
That legislation must still comply with the Treaties and other higher-ranking EU legal norms.
Legislative acts versus delegated and implementing acts
The lecturer highlighted an important distinction:
Legislative acts — Article 289 TFEU
These are adopted using either:
The ordinary legislative procedure.
The special legislative procedure.
They may take the form of regulations, directives or decisions.
Delegated acts — Article 290 TFEU
These are non-legislative acts that may supplement or amend certain non-essential elements of a legislative act.
Implementing acts — Article 291 TFEU
These are used where uniform conditions are needed to implement legally binding EU acts.
Delegated and implementing acts may also take the form of regulations, directives or decisions.
The key difference is therefore the procedure used to adopt the act, not simply its name.
The lecturer stated that delegated and implementing acts would be covered further in the complementary teaching material.
1.3 Article 288 TFEU: Types of EU legal acts
Article 288 TFEU identifies five main types of legal acts:
Regulations
Directives
Decisions
Recommendations
Opinions
The lecturer emphasised that understanding their differences is essential for later topics, particularly direct effect, which concerns how EU law may be enforced before national courts.
1.4 Regulations
Legal basis: Article 288 TFEU
Article 288 states:
A regulation shall have general application. It shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States.
What does this mean?
A regulation has three important characteristics.
1. General application
Regulations establish rules that apply generally, rather than being limited to one specifically named individual or organisation.
2. Binding in its entirety
Member States must comply with the regulation as a whole.
They cannot choose which provisions they wish to follow.
3. Directly applicable
This was the main characteristic the lecturer wanted students to understand.
Direct applicability concerns how EU law becomes part of the national legal systems of Member States.
Once a regulation takes effect under EU law, it operates within Member States without needing to be transposed into national legislation.
The lecturer described regulations as being parachuted into national legal systems.
Example
Imagine the EU adopts a regulation establishing a particular rule for airline passenger protection.
The Member States do not need to create their own national legislation to give that regulation legal force.
The regulation operates as EU law within their legal systems.
National authorities may still need to adjust domestic arrangements to ensure the regulation works effectively, but this does not change its direct applicability.
Legislative example
Regulation (EC) No 261/2004
This regulation establishes common rules on compensation and assistance for passengers affected by:
Denied boarding.
Flight cancellations.
Long flight delays.
It illustrates how EU regulations establish common rules across Member States.
Key takeaway: Regulations are designed to promote uniformity because the same EU rules operate across Member States.
1.5 Directives
Legal basis: Article 288 TFEU
Article 288 states:
A directive shall be binding, as to the result to be achieved, upon each Member State to which it is addressed, but shall leave to the national authorities the choice of form and methods.
What does this mean?
A directive requires Member States to achieve a particular result, but allows them some flexibility in deciding how to achieve it.
Unlike regulations, directives generally require transposition into national law.
Transposition means incorporating the requirements of a directive into a Member State's domestic legal system.
How do directives work?
The EU adopts a directive establishing a particular objective.
The directive specifies a deadline for transposition.
Each Member State determines the appropriate national measures to achieve that objective.
The Member State must ensure that the required result is achieved within the deadline.
The lecturer explained that transposition deadlines are generally around two years, although the precise deadline depends on the directive.
Example
Imagine the EU adopts a directive requiring Member States to reduce the environmental impact of certain plastic products.
The EU specifies the result it wants to achieve.
However, Member States have discretion over the national legal measures used to meet that requirement.
They cannot simply ignore the directive because they disagree with its objective.
Legislative example
Directive (EU) 2019/904
This directive concerns reducing the environmental impact of certain plastic products.
It demonstrates how EU law can establish shared environmental objectives while leaving national authorities some discretion over implementation.
1.6 Regulations versus directives
This is one of the most important distinctions from Part 1.
Regulations | Directives |
Binding in their entirety | Binding as to the result to be achieved |
Directly applicable | Generally require national transposition |
Operate as EU law within Member States | Allow national authorities to choose form and methods |
Promote uniformity | Promote harmonisation |
Same EU rules operate across Member States | National measures may differ while pursuing the same required outcome |
Uniformity versus harmonisation
Uniformity means having the same legal rules operating across Member States.
Regulations are particularly suited to this because they are directly applicable.
Harmonisation means bringing different national laws closer together so they achieve common objectives.
Directives are particularly suited to this because Member States have flexibility in choosing how to achieve the required result.
A simple way to remember the distinction:
Regulation: Here is the EU rule. It applies as EU law.
Directive: Here is the result you must achieve. Choose the appropriate national legal measures to achieve it.
The lecturer identified this as a central takeaway from the first part of the lecture.
Important distinction for later study
Direct applicability is not the same as direct effect.
Direct applicability concerns how an EU legal act operates within a national legal system without needing national transposition.
Direct effect concerns whether a provision of EU law can be relied upon by an individual before a national court.
The lecture flags direct effect as a later topic rather than examining its conditions here.
1.7 Decisions
Legal basis: Article 288 TFEU
Article 288 provides that decisions are binding in their entirety.
Where a decision identifies particular addressees, it is binding only upon those addressees.
This means that a decision may impose legally binding requirements on specific Member States, organisations or individuals, depending on its content.
Legislative example
Council Decision (EU) 2022/1211
This decision concerned Croatia's adoption of the euro on 1 January 2023.
It illustrates the use of a decision to address a particular matter within the EU legal system.
1.8 Recommendations and opinions
Legal basis: Article 288 TFEU
Recommendations and opinions have no binding force.
This means they do not impose legally enforceable obligations in the same way as regulations, directives and decisions.
They are examples of soft law.
What is soft law?
Soft law consists of instruments that are not legally binding but may still influence legal interpretation, policymaking or behaviour.
Relevant case: Case C-322/88, Grimaldi [1989] ECR 4407
The lecture identifies Grimaldi as authority for the persuasive character of recommendations.
Although recommendations are not binding, they can still be relevant to the interpretation of law.
Comparison of all five acts
Legal act | Binding? | Main characteristic |
Regulation | Yes | Generally applicable and directly applicable |
Directive | Yes | Binding result, flexibility over national implementation |
Decision | Yes | Binding in its entirety; may have specified addressees |
Recommendation | No | Non-binding guidance |
Opinion | No | Non-binding expression of a position |
Part 1 summary: EU law has different sources arranged within a hierarchy. Article 288 TFEU identifies the main legal acts, and the most important distinction stressed in the lecture is between the direct applicability of regulations and the national transposition of directives.
Part 2: EU Law-Making — Legislative Acts
2.1 What are legislative acts?
Under Article 289 TFEU, legislative acts are legal acts adopted through a legislative procedure.
There are two principal procedures:
Ordinary legislative procedure (OLP).
Special legislative procedure (SLP).
Legislative acts can take the form of regulations, directives or decisions.
2.2 Development of EU legislative procedures
EU law-making procedures have evolved through successive Treaty reforms.
Treaty | Development |
EEC Treaty 1957 | Consultation procedure |
Single European Act 1986 | Introduction of cooperation and assent procedures |
Treaty on European Union 1992 | Introduction of co-decision |
Treaty of Lisbon 2007 | Co-decision renamed the ordinary legislative procedure and established as the default procedure |
Why were these developments important?
The lecturer explained that the European Parliament gradually gained more legislative powers.
This matters because the European Parliament is directly elected by EU citizens.
Giving Parliament a stronger role in law-making can therefore be seen as improving the democratic character of the EU legislative process.
This links to the broader question of democratic legitimacy within the EU.
2.3 Ordinary Legislative Procedure (OLP)
The ordinary legislative procedure is the EU's default legislative procedure and applies across a large number of policy areas.
It was previously called the co-decision procedure.
Three institutions play central roles:
European Commission: Proposes legislation.
European Parliament: Examines and adopts legislation jointly with the Council.
Council of the European Union: Examines and adopts legislation jointly with Parliament.
The right of legislative initiative
The European Commission ordinarily has the right of legislative initiative.
This means it is responsible for preparing and proposing new legislation.
However, proposing legislation does not mean that the Commission can adopt it alone.
Under the ordinary legislative procedure, the European Parliament and Council act as co-legislators.
They must agree on the same legislative text.
The ordinary legislative procedure, step by step
Step 1: European Commission
Prepares and submits a legislative proposal
European Parliament
Examines the proposal and may propose amendments
Council of the EU
Examines the proposal and may propose amendments
Step 3: Agreement
Both co-legislators must agree on the same text, potentially through up to three readings
Agreement reached
Legislation adopted
No agreement
Legislation not adopted
What are readings?
Readings are stages during which the Parliament and Council examine a legislative proposal and consider amendments.
The procedure can involve up to three readings.
The lecturer noted that many proposals are adopted at first reading.
What are trilogues?
Trilogues are informal negotiations involving representatives of the European Parliament, Council and Commission.
Their purpose is to identify disagreements and negotiate compromises.
These discussions can help the institutions reach agreement earlier in the legislative process.
Why is the OLP important?
The Parliament and Council are on an equal legislative footing.
Neither can independently adopt legislation through the ordinary legislative procedure without the other's agreement.
The lecturer emphasised that this is the most important feature to remember.
2.4 Special Legislative Procedure (SLP)
The special legislative procedure differs from the ordinary legislative procedure because the European Parliament and Council do not act as equal co-legislators.
In the Council-led procedure illustrated in the lecture, the Council acts as the sole legislator.
The Parliament still participates, but its role is more limited.
It may be required to:
Be consulted.
Give its consent.
Consultation versus consent
Consultation: Parliament must be asked for its opinion, but its approval is not necessarily required for adoption.
Consent: Parliament must approve the proposed act, but it does not act as an equal co-legislator amending and negotiating the text through the OLP.
The lecture's diagram focuses on Council-led special legislative procedures. The precise institutional roles depend on the relevant Treaty provision.
2.5 OLP versus SLP
Ordinary legislative procedure | Special legislative procedure |
Default EU legislative procedure | Applies where the Treaties specifically provide |
Parliament and Council act as co-legislators | One institution has the principal legislative role |
Both must agree on the legislative text | Parliament may have a consultation or consent role in Council-led procedures |
Can involve up to three readings | Follows the procedure specified in the relevant Treaty provision |
Gives Parliament an equal legislative role | Parliament's role may be more limited |
Part 2 summary: The ordinary legislative procedure is the EU's default method of making legislation. The Commission proposes legislation, while the European Parliament and Council act as co-legislators. Under the Council-led special legislative procedure discussed in the lecture, Parliament has a more limited role.
Part 3: Controls on EU Law-Making
3.1 Why does EU law-making need controls?
The EU cannot simply create legislation whenever and however it wishes.
Although Member States have transferred certain powers to the EU, they remain important in determining the limits of those powers.
This raises an important question:
How can the EU exercise the powers necessary to achieve its objectives without exceeding the authority granted by Member States?
The lecturer explained that concerns about the EU exercising too much power became particularly significant during the 1990s.
Competence creep
Competence creep describes a situation where the EU begins legislating in areas where it has not been given specific authority to act.
Before the Lisbon Treaty, the division of powers between the EU and Member States was not always clearly defined.
This created concerns that the EU might gradually extend its legislative powers into areas that Member States intended to control themselves.
The Lisbon Treaty sought to clarify the division of competences.
Four controls on EU law-making
The lecture identifies four closely connected controls:
Competence: Does the EU have the legal power to act?
Legal basis: Which Treaty provision authorises the proposed legislation?
Subsidiarity: Is action at EU level justified instead of action by Member States?
Proportionality: Does the EU's proposed action go beyond what is necessary?
These controls help ensure that EU institutions act within the powers given to them.
3.2 Competence: Articles 1 and 5 TEU
What is competence?
Competence means the legal authority or power to act.
In EU law, competence determines the areas in which the EU is legally permitted to legislate.
The EU operates according to the principle of conferral.
The principle of conferral
Under Articles 1 and 5 TEU, Member States confer competences upon the EU through the Treaties.
This means the EU does not possess unlimited legislative powers.
It may act only within the limits of the competences granted to it.
For example, the EU cannot decide that it wants complete control over an area of national policy simply because it considers EU action beneficial.
It must first have the necessary Treaty authority.
Can the EU increase its own powers?
No.
The lecturer emphasised that the EU cannot determine the extent of its own competence.
In other words, the EU cannot independently grant itself additional powers or remove its own competences through ordinary legislative action.
Changes to the competences conferred by the Treaties require Treaty revision.
Relevant provision: Article 48 TEU
Article 48 TEU governs the procedures for revising the EU Treaties.
Conferral as an enabler and a constraint
The slides refer to a statement by J. Adams-Prassl and S. Bogojevic in Great Debates in EU Law (2021), explaining that conferral both enables and constrains EU power.
This means:
Conferral enables EU action because the Treaties give the EU legal authority to legislate in particular areas.
Conferral constrains EU action because the EU must remain within the boundaries of that authority.
What happens if the EU exceeds its competence?
An EU legislative act can be challenged before the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).
If the act is found to be unlawful because the EU exceeded its powers, the Court can annul it.
The lecturer also explained that national courts can refer questions concerning the validity of EU acts to the CJEU.
Key takeaway: The principle of conferral ensures that the EU exercises powers granted by Member States rather than creating its own powers.
3.3 Categories of EU competence
Relevant provisions: Articles 2–6 TFEU
The Treaty of Lisbon clarified the distribution of competences between the EU and Member States.
Article 2 TFEU identifies three main categories:
Exclusive competence.
Shared competence.
Supporting competence.
Articles 3–6 TFEU identify the policy areas within these categories.
The lecture also notes separate treatment for economic and employment policies and the Common Foreign and Security Policy.
A. Exclusive competence
Article 3 TFEU
Exclusive competence means that only the EU can legislate and adopt legally binding acts in the relevant area.
Member States may act where empowered by the EU or when implementing EU acts.
This represents the greatest degree of legislative competence exercised by the EU.
Examples of areas of exclusive EU competence include the customs union and common commercial policy.
B. Supporting competence
Article 6 TFEU
Supporting competence means the EU has a more limited role.
The EU may support, coordinate or complement Member State action.
The EU does not replace Member States as the principal authority in these areas.
Examples include culture, tourism and education.
The lecturer described this competence as ancillary to the activities of Member States.
C. Shared competence
Article 4 TFEU
Shared competence means both the EU and Member States may legislate and adopt legally binding acts in a particular area.
Examples include the internal market, environment and consumer protection.
The lecturer explained that much of the EU's competence falls into this category.
However, shared competence does not necessarily mean that the EU and Member States can exercise their legislative powers equally at all times.
This is because of the principle of pre-emption.
3.4 Shared competence and the principle of pre-emption
Relevant provision: Article 2(2) TFEU
Pre-emption means that where the EU has exercised its competence in a particular matter, Member States may be prevented from legislating on that same matter.
Member States can exercise their competence to the extent that the EU has not exercised its competence, or has decided to cease exercising it.
Example
Imagine that the EU and Member States share competence over a particular environmental issue.
Initially, a Member State may introduce its own legislation.
However, if the EU subsequently adopts binding rules covering that matter, the Member State's freedom to legislate may become restricted.
The extent of that restriction depends on the scope of the EU legislation.
Why is this important?
The lecturer explained that the term shared competence can be misleading.
It might suggest that both the EU and Member States always possess equal freedom to legislate.
However, pre-emption means that EU action can limit the Member States' ability to exercise their own competence.
Comparing the three categories
Category | Who can legislate? | EU's role |
Exclusive | Primarily the EU | Strongest legislative authority |
Shared | EU and Member States, subject to pre-emption | Competence is shared, but EU action may restrict national action |
Supporting | Member States retain the principal role | EU supports, coordinates or complements national action |
Important for Workshop 2: Understand why shared competence does not necessarily mean equal legislative freedom.
3.5 Legal basis
Competence alone is not sufficient to establish that a proposed EU legislative act is lawful.
The act must also have an appropriate legal basis in the Treaties.
What is a legal basis?
A legal basis is the Treaty provision that authorises the EU to adopt a particular measure.
The lecturer explained that once the Commission establishes that the EU has competence, it must identify the appropriate legal basis for its proposal.
Why does the legal basis matter?
The legal basis helps determine:
Which EU institutions are involved in making the legislation.
Which legislative procedure must be followed.
What voting requirements apply within the Council.
What type of legal instrument may be adopted.
This means that choosing the correct legal basis is essential to the lawfulness of the legislative process.
Specific and generic legal bases
The lecture distinguishes between two types.
Specific legal basis (lex specialis)
A Treaty provision dealing with a particular policy area.
Examples from the slides:
Article 192 TFEU — Environment.
Article 169 TFEU — Consumer protection.
Generic legal basis
A broader Treaty provision that may authorise legislation across a wider range of circumstances.
Examples from the slides:
Article 114 TFEU — Internal market harmonisation.
Article 352 TFEU — Flexibility provision.
The lecturer explained that generic legal bases may be relevant where no suitable specific legal basis applies, subject to the conditions of the relevant Treaty provision.
3.6 Article 114 TFEU: An example of a legal basis
Article 114 TFEU concerns the approximation of national laws relating to the establishment and functioning of the internal market.
What does approximation mean?
In this context, approximation means bringing national laws closer together.
This is associated with harmonisation.
For example, different Member States might have different rules governing the sale of certain products.
These differences could create difficulties for businesses operating across the EU.
Article 114 may provide a legal basis for measures intended to reduce relevant differences and improve the functioning of the internal market.
What does Article 114 tell us?
The lecturer highlighted three features:
The European Parliament and Council act through the ordinary legislative procedure.
The provision concerns the approximation of national laws.
The objective is connected to the establishment and functioning of the internal market.
The lecturer associated approximation with directives. However, Article 114 is not restricted to directives: measures based on it can take other appropriate legal forms.
Key takeaway: The legal basis connects the EU's authority to legislate with the procedure and legal requirements governing the proposed measure.
3.7 Subsidiarity and proportionality
Once the EU has established that it possesses competence and has identified an appropriate legal basis, it must consider how that competence should be exercised.
The lecturer divided this into two stages:
Stage 1 — Authority to act
Does the EU have competence?
Is there an appropriate Treaty legal basis?
Stage 2 — Exercise of competence
Does the proposal comply with subsidiarity?
Does the proposal comply with proportionality?
These two principles are governed by Article 5 TEU.
3.8 The principle of subsidiarity
Legal basis: Article 5(3) TEU
What is subsidiarity?
Subsidiarity is the principle that decisions should be taken as closely as possible to citizens, where appropriate.
It seeks to ensure that EU action is justified rather than automatically replacing action at national level.
The principle does not apply to areas of exclusive EU competence.
The subsidiarity test
The lecturer described subsidiarity as a comparative efficiency test.
The EU should act in areas of non-exclusive competence only where:
The objectives of the proposed action cannot be sufficiently achieved by Member States.
Those objectives can be better achieved at EU level because of the scale or effects of the proposed action.
Example
Imagine a problem involving pollution that crosses the borders of several Member States.
One country acting alone may not be able to address the problem sufficiently.
Coordinated action at EU level might be more effective because the problem affects multiple countries.
This could provide a justification for EU action under subsidiarity.
However, where a problem can be adequately addressed by Member States themselves, EU-level action may be harder to justify.
Why is subsidiarity important?
It protects the balance of powers between the EU and Member States.
It requires the EU to explain why action at Union level is preferable to action at national level.
The lecturer also emphasised that subsidiarity can be understood as both a legal control and a political control.
3.9 Subsidiarity as a legal control
Can an EU legislative act be challenged for breaching subsidiarity?
Yes, in principle.
The CJEU can review whether EU legislation complies with the principle.
However, the lecturer explained that the Court has historically been reluctant to engage in detailed substantive review of subsidiarity.
Relevant case
Case C-84/94, United Kingdom v Council (Working Time Directive)
The lecture uses this case to illustrate the Court's approach to reviewing subsidiarity.
The lecturer described the Court's approach as sometimes involving light-touch review.
This means that although subsidiarity is legally enforceable, judicial scrutiny may be relatively restrained.
Why does this matter?
If courts are reluctant to intervene extensively, political mechanisms become particularly important in monitoring whether EU legislation respects subsidiarity.
This leads to the role of national parliaments.
3.10 Subsidiarity as a political control
Protocol No 2: Early Warning Mechanism
The Treaty of Lisbon introduced an enhanced role for national parliaments through Protocol No 2 on the Application of the Principles of Subsidiarity and Proportionality.
This allows national parliaments to examine proposed EU legislation and raise concerns about subsidiarity.
How does the Early Warning Mechanism work?
When the Commission sends a legislative proposal to the European Parliament and Council, the proposal is also sent to national parliaments.
National parliaments have eight weeks to submit a reasoned opinion explaining why they consider that the proposal breaches subsidiarity.
Each national parliament has two votes under the mechanism.
With 27 Member States, there are 54 votes in total.
The slides identify two important procedures.
A. Yellow card procedure
A yellow card is generally triggered when reasoned opinions reach at least one-third of the allocated votes.
The Commission must then review its proposal.
After reviewing it, the Commission may:
Maintain the proposal.
Amend the proposal.
Withdraw the proposal.
It must give reasons for its decision.
A yellow card therefore does not automatically prevent legislation from proceeding.
B. Orange card procedure
The orange card procedure applies to proposals under the ordinary legislative procedure.
The slides explain that it is triggered when at least half of the allocated national parliamentary votes object on subsidiarity grounds.
The Commission must review its proposal.
If it maintains the proposal, it must provide reasons.
The European Parliament and Council then consider the subsidiarity objection.
Under the mechanism, the proposal does not proceed if a majority of votes cast in Parliament or 55% of Council members conclude that it breaches subsidiarity.
Yellow card versus orange card
Yellow card | Orange card |
Generally requires one-third of allocated votes | Requires at least half of allocated votes |
Commission must review the proposal | Commission must review the proposal |
Commission may maintain, amend or withdraw | Additional scrutiny by Parliament and Council if maintained |
Does not automatically stop the proposal | Can prevent the proposal from proceeding |
Applies to draft legislative acts under the Protocol | Applies to proposals under the OLP |
3.11 Examples of the Early Warning Mechanism
The slides identify three occasions when the yellow card procedure was triggered.
Year | Proposal | Outcome |
2012 | Regulation concerning the right to take collective action | Commission withdrew the proposal, while maintaining that subsidiarity had been respected |
2013 | Regulation establishing a European Public Prosecutor's Office | Commission maintained the proposal |
2016 | Revision of the Posting of Workers Directive | Commission maintained the proposal |
What do these examples demonstrate?
National parliaments can influence the legislative process by requiring the Commission to reconsider a proposal.
However, the Commission is not necessarily required to withdraw legislation following a yellow card.
This raises a question about the mechanism's effectiveness.
Workshop consideration: Does the Early Warning Mechanism provide meaningful control over EU law-making if the Commission can maintain its proposal despite objections from national parliaments?
The lecturer encouraged students to consider how effective political controls are compared with judicial controls.
3.12 The principle of proportionality
Legal basis: Article 5(4) TEU
What is proportionality?
Proportionality requires that EU action must not exceed what is necessary to achieve the objectives of the Treaties.
In simple terms:
The EU should not use measures that go further than necessary to achieve a legitimate objective.
The lecturer explained that proportionality is also a general principle of EU law, developed substantially through the case law of the Union courts.
Protocol No 2 provides further guidance on its application.
Example
Imagine the EU wants to reduce a particular form of pollution.
It considers introducing legislation restricting certain products.
The EU must consider whether the proposed restrictions are necessary to achieve the environmental objective.
If the legislation imposes unnecessarily extensive restrictions, proportionality concerns may arise.
Subsidiarity versus proportionality
These principles ask different questions.
Subsidiarity | Proportionality |
Should the EU act? | How far should EU action go? |
Focuses on the appropriate level of government | Focuses on the extent and intensity of the measure |
Article 5(3) TEU | Article 5(4) TEU |
Does not apply to exclusive EU competence | Applies to the exercise of EU competence |
3.13 Case law: Digital Rights Ireland
Joined Cases C-293/12 and C-594/12, Digital Rights Ireland
This case concerns proportionality and fundamental rights.
Background
The EU adopted the Data Retention Directive (Directive 2006/24).
The Directive required the retention of certain communications data, with the objective of assisting in the investigation and prevention of serious crime.
Legal issue
The question was whether the data retention requirements interfered disproportionately with fundamental rights, particularly:
The right to privacy.
The right to protection of personal data.
Decision
The CJEU annulled the Directive.
The Court accepted that retaining communications data could, in principle, contribute to combating serious crime.
However, the measures went beyond what was necessary and disproportionately interfered with fundamental rights.
Legal significance
The case demonstrates that:
An EU measure may pursue a legitimate objective.
The measure may be capable of achieving that objective.
Nevertheless, it can still be unlawful if it goes beyond what is necessary.
Key principle: A legitimate objective does not automatically justify every measure adopted to achieve it.
This case is an important illustration of proportionality operating as a legal control on EU legislation.
3.14 Workshop case study: The Common Charger Directive
The lecturer concluded by introducing a case study for Workshop 2.
Directive (EU) 2022/2380, amending Directive 2014/53/EU.
The legislation concerns harmonising charging requirements for certain electronic devices, including the use of USB Type-C.
The slides refer to the original Commission proposal, COM(2021) 547 final.
Why is this relevant?
The Common Charger Directive provides an opportunity to apply the legal principles discussed throughout the lecture.
For example:
Competence: Does the EU have authority to regulate this issue?
Legal basis: Which Treaty provision permits legislation concerning the relevant products and internal market?
Subsidiarity: Would action at EU level be more effective than separate national requirements?
Proportionality: Do the charging requirements go further than necessary to achieve the intended objectives?
These questions demonstrate how the four controls can be applied to an actual legislative measure.