1/76
Looks like no tags are added yet.
why are there so many errors associated with eyewitness testimony?
errors of identification; memory is constructed, not videotaped; errors due to suggestion, misinformation effect, post identification feedback effect
eyewitness testimony: errors with perception and attention
emotion and stressed can affect it; weapon focus
weapon focus
the tendency to focus attention on a weapon that results in the narrowing of our attention
eyewitness testimony: errors due to familiarity experiment
experimental condition (E) watched film of male teacher reading to students and control condition (C) watched film of female teacher reading to students; both groups saw a film of the teacher being robbed and asked to pick the robber out the spread; the actual robber wasn’t in the lineup, but the male teacher was; the E group was 3x more likely to pick the male teacher than the C group
post identification feedback test
increase in confidence due to confirming feedback after making an identification
whats being done to improve eyewitness testimony?
lineup procedures and interviewing techniques
lineup procedures
inform the witness that the perpetrator may not be in the lineup, use fillers in the lineup of people similar to the suspect, use a blind lineup administrator (someone who doesnt know who the suspect is), have witnesses rate their confidence immediately (high confidence at time of identification is associated with more accurate identifications but not confident afterward
interviewing techniques
cognitive interview; lets witnesses talk with minimum interruption; uses techniques that helps witnesses recreate the situation present at the crime scene, and how it could have appeared from different perspectives; leads to better accuracy
cognitive interview
a technique that decreases the likelihood of any suggestive input by the person conducting the interview
does immediate recall reduce the misinformation effect?
recalling the witnessed event should enhance memory for the event (testing effect)
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: witnessed event
an episode of 24
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: cued recall test
tested 24 critical details of the event, no feedback, given
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: distractor tests
demographics questionnaire, synonym and antonym vocab test, OSPAN task
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: audio narrative
consistent items were “the terrorist knocks the flight attendent uncosncious with a hypodermic syringe”; control items are “the terrorist knocks the flight attendant unconscious”; misleading items are “the terrorist knocks the flight attendant unconscious with a choroform rag”
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: cued recall final test
identical to the immediate cued recall test; participants were instructed to only recall info from the video
Chan et al (2009) Experiment Method: misleading items
test group recalled significantly more misinformation than the No test group; retrieval enhanced suggestibility (RES)
attention
taking the test might draw attention to specific events in the original video and these events might have stood out more as the misinformation was presented so were more likely to be changed
test potentiated learning
receiving a test on old info potentiates (strengthens) learning of new info
reconsolidation
every time we recall a memory, we have to reconsolidate it; it can be subjected to interference during this time
Thomas Bulevich and Chan (2010, Exp 1) method: audio narrative
warning is “we are uncertain as to the source of the narrative, therefore we were unable to verify the accuracy of the narrative; no warning was participants were told the audio narrative was a recap
Thomas Bulevich and Chan (2010, Exp 1) method: RES was eliminated with the warning about the validity of the audio narrative
could something like this be implemented in real life?
Deese-Roediger-McDermott (DMR) paradigm
words related to a critical lure are presented, but the critical lore itself is never presented; provide support that our memory is organized within semantic, categorical, representations, and is subject to suggestibility
why use the DRM Paradigm?
can help us learn more about false memories and manipulating participant age, stress levels, etc
DRM criticism
DRM paradigm doesn’t reflect real life events
Mandela Effect
a large group of people remember something differently than how it actually occurred; “collective false memories”
Fiona Broome
(writer/researcher) detailed her recollections of former South African President Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 1980s; he didn’t die in prison in 1980s, he died in 2013; others shared the false memory thought
why does mandela effect happen
memory is constructive; also could be misinformation effect
language
the ability to communicate complex ideas, share our internal thoughts and emotions and plans for the future
do other animals besides humans have the ability to learn and produce language?
many animal species are capable of communication between individuals; ants communicate through chemicals; bees communicate by wagging tails; birds communicate by bird calls
animal communication
a rigid, usually small, set of signals that strand for specific things that typically refer to details of the current environment
language
using a set of units, you can generate an essentially infinite number of possible sentences, even with entirely new ones
grammar
the presence/absence of a grammar for combining words is the most fundamental difference between human and animal language
Alex the Parrot
an African Grey parrot, was trained to produce remarkable linguistic behaviors; trained to use over 200 words; seemed to understand the meaning of abstract words such as shape and color
Washoe the Chimp
learned up to 250 signs: included abstract signs like more; formed novel compound words from single signs
so is animal communication actually language
most researchers agree that no animal, trained, or otherwise, has demonstrated true language like productivity to generate novel constructions from a fixed set of symbols; true language appears to be unique to humans
behaviorists, B.F. Skinner
language is learned based on the same kind of mechanisms as other kinds of skill learning; trial and error with reinforcement for correct or incorrect language; modeling of other people’s language behavior
Noam Chomsky
there’s an innate capacity to learn language thats present prior to any actual language experience, either before birth or after’ basic concepts of language don’t need to be learned; words, syntax, and tense; the details of ones language(which words, which syntax but with the specific details to be learned based on experience
universal grammar
contained some of the basic scaffolding of syntax but with the specific details to be learned based on experience
poverty of the stimulus
Chomsky argued that some language capabilities must be innate because language is learned based on a limited number of examples; this reflects a preexisting set of rules about grammar that precedes experience
pidgin
a simplified form of a language, usually used for communication between people not sharing a common language; has reduced expressive abilities and grammar; children of pidgin speakers can take the broken language and turn it into a fully expressive new language (creole)
deaf isolates
people who can’t hear and aren’t exposed to any real sign language; they develop a rudimentary sign language of their own
typical milestone of language development
0-3 months: cooing, 4-8 months: babbling (consonant and vowel), 8mo-1yr: single words, 1-2yrs: 2 word phrases, 2-3 years: explosion of word knowledge and 2-3 word telegraphic speech; 3-4 yrs: complex multiword speech
child-directed speech (CDS) or infant directed speech (IDS)
consists of a parent/older sibling speaking directly to a child
motherese
uses sing song like speech cadences, exaggerated vowel pronunciations and repetitions; helps infants identify the beginning and end of speech sounds and draws their attention to important concepts
head turn task
babies conditioned to turn their heads when they hear a change in a speech sound; when they correctly turn their head, they’re rewarded with a lit up display with moving toy animals; during test they measure how often the baby turns to actual changes in a speech sound; found language abilities of infants were positively correlated with their mothers use of elongated and open vowel sounds typical of motherese(may help babies learn basic building blocks of language
phonetic properties
the actual sounds that the speaker is making
2 types of linguistic units
phonemes and morphemes
phonemes
the smallest unit of speech that can change the meaning of a word (sounds)
morphemes
the smallest meaningful units of speech (meaning)
phonological ambiguity
isolated sounds are ambiguous
pollack and picket (1964)
recorded conversations of people waiting for an experiment to start; participants couldn’t identify their own spoken words about 50% of the time when heard in isolation
phonemic restoration effect: warren 1970
recorded a spoken sentence and then removed an individual phoneme from the recording and replaced it with a nonspeech sound; asked participants if they noticed any sounds missing; most participants didn’t notice any sounds missing and if they did, they chose wrong sound
articulations
during speech the human mouth makes characteristics movements that can be used to determine what phoneme a person is pronouncing
McGurk effect
view the visual articulations of 1 phoneme while hearing the auditory signal consistent with a different phoneme; demonstrates that our brain uses additional info besides the speech stimulus to determine what phoneme is being said
speech segmentation
determining where the individual words are in a segment of speech; when we speak, we don’t actually pause between words
Saffron (1999)
infants (and adults) are statistical learners who encode the frequency with which different sounds appear together
lexicon
all words a person understands
semantics
the meaning of language
syntax
rules for combining words into sentences
word frequency
the frequency with which a word appears in a language
word frequency effect
the fact that we respond more rapidly to high-frequency words than to low-frequency words; word frequency influences how we process the word; likely need more time to process the meaning of a low frequency word
lexical decision task
understanding words vs non-words; research using the lexical decision task has demonstrated slower responding to low frequency words
understanding ambiguous words
context can usually help us determine meaning
lexical ambiguity
when words have more than 1 meaning
Multiple Lexical Activations
Swinney (1979) posed the question of whether the context completely isolates the “correct” meaning; the garden was filled with spiders and other bugs: at the same time they watched (the words the insect meaning of the target word or the hidden device meaning of the word or not related at all) on a computer screen and performed a lexical decision task; both ant and spy showed speeded responses; suggests that both meanings of the word bug were activated, despite the surrounding context favoring only 1 (insects)
lexical priming
priming that involves the meaning of words
parsing
grouping of words into phrases
garden path sentences
sentences that begin appearing to mean 1 thing but then end up meaning something else; illustrate temporary ambiguity
temporary ambiguity
1st one organization is adopted and then when the error is realized, the person shifts to the correct organization
problem
a situation in which you need to accomplish a goal and the solution isn’t immediately obvious
problem solving
a cognitive process that involves discovering, analyzing, and solving problems; discover and describe, analyze and process, select a solution, take steps to solve, reflect on effectiveness
well defined problems
have correct answers and certain procedures lead us to them; effectively solved by computers, like computing math problems/playing chess; developing instructions for computer simulations can help us better understand how our brain could be solving similar problems
ill defined problems
don’t have just 1 correct answer, can be solved in many different ways and sometimes not sure if you’ve even reached the right answer; real world problems such as relationships, morals/values must be taken into account; computers not very good at solving
the behaviorist approach
theorized that problem solving is a reproductive process; solving problems by using previous experiences and what’s already known; use trial and error model to solve problems
The gestalt approach
problem solving is a productive process; occurs when you’re thinking about a problem and is characterized by the restructuring of info in your mind; to do this you have to actively manipulate, or think about info and change its representation in your mind; insight occurs during the productive process when info is restructured and the solution suddenly comes to consciousness; theorized that when people have ‘ah ha’ moments they’re in the process of restructuring; “the whole is greater than the sum of its parts”; heuristics
heuristics
rules of thumb, educated guesses, common sense or even intuitive judgements; mental shortcuts to solving problems that usually get us to our goal based on simple properties of problems; lessens the cognitive load
the information processing approach
describes what happens between stimulus and response; people are the processors of info; info about a problem enters your system, you draw info from your long term memory into your working memory in order to manipulate the info and arrive at a solution; computers take in info and arrive at a solution; algorithms; computers use an unbelievable amount of high speed processing power to work out many possible solutions to a given problem and choose the best possible 1 quickly; humans have limited processing power which constrains how many steps of a problem and possible solutions can be considered at 1 time