1/81
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the three key considerations in an international dispute?
(1) Whether the courts of England and Wales have jurisdiction to determine the claim; (2) which country's laws will apply to determine the dispute; and (3) whether the judgment will need to be enforced abroad and how this can be done, including investigating the debtor's means.
What is the distinction between jurisdiction and applicable law?
Jurisdiction determines which country's courts hear the claim; applicable law determines which country's laws those courts apply. An English court may apply French law, although the CPR still applies to the proceedings.
What does the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements provide?
It allows parties to agree which country's courts will have jurisdiction to hear a dispute, subject to the Convention's requirements.
To which proceedings can the Hague Convention apply?
Proceedings commenced on or after 1 January 2021, provided the choice of court agreement was concluded on or after 1 October 2015.
Do parties need to be based in a contracting state to enter into a Hague Convention choice of court agreement?
No. The parties themselves do not need to be based in a contracting state.
What types of disputes fall within the Hague Convention?
Civil and commercial matters only. Public and criminal disputes are excluded.
Which matters are excluded from the Hague Convention?
Excluded matters include disputes involving consumers and employment matters.
Which countries are contracting states for the purposes of the Hague Convention, according to the notes?
The UK, all EU member states, Mexico, Singapore and Montenegro.
What must a choice of court clause provide to fall within the Hague Convention?
It must give exclusive jurisdiction to the courts of a particular contracting state.
What is an example of an exclusive jurisdiction clause?
'The Courts of England and Wales will have jurisdiction to determine any dispute arising out of this contract.'
What form must a Hague Convention choice of court agreement take?
It must be in writing or be documented or evidenced in writing.
What is an asymmetric jurisdiction agreement?
An agreement under which one party can commence proceedings only in a specified country, whereas the other party can commence proceedings in any other country whose courts would have jurisdiction under the relevant rules.
Are asymmetric jurisdiction agreements covered by the Hague Convention?
It is unclear whether they fall within the Convention.
What is the effect of a valid exclusive choice of court agreement under the Hague Convention?
The chosen court cannot decline jurisdiction on the basis that another country's courts would be more appropriate; any other court must refuse to hear the proceedings.
When will the courts of England and Wales have jurisdiction under common law because the defendant is present in the jurisdiction?
Where the proceedings can be served on the defendant in England and Wales.
Does the defendant need to be based in England and Wales for the court to have jurisdiction through presence?
No. The defendant may be based elsewhere, and the subject matter may have taken place elsewhere, provided the defendant can be served within the jurisdiction.
Where can a foreign company be served in England and Wales?
At any place of business it has within England and Wales.
How can a solicitor facilitate service on a defendant?
A solicitor can be appointed to accept service on the client's behalf.
When can the courts of England and Wales have jurisdiction over a defendant outside the jurisdiction under common law?
Where the court gives permission to serve proceedings outside the jurisdiction.
What must a claimant establish to obtain permission to serve proceedings outside the jurisdiction?
(1) One of the jurisdictional gateways in CPR 6B PD 3.1; (2) reasonable prospects of success; and (3) that England and Wales is the proper place to bring the claim.
What is the threshold for establishing reasonable prospects of success when seeking permission to serve outside the jurisdiction?
A relatively low threshold.
What factors may establish that England and Wales is the proper place to bring a claim?
For example, witnesses are based there, English law applies or the defendant is normally resident there. Other considerations may include the risk of improper government interference or that the trial would otherwise be unfair.
Which CPR 6B PD 3.1 gateway applies where a claim seeks a remedy against a person domiciled in England and Wales?
Gateway 1.
Which CPR 6B PD 3.1 gateway applies to certain contractual claims?
Gateway 6: a claim in respect of a contract made within the jurisdiction, governed by English law, or containing a term giving the courts of England and Wales jurisdiction over claims relating to the contract.
Which CPR 6B PD 3.1 gateway applies to a breach of contract committed in England and Wales?
Gateway 7.
Which CPR 6B PD 3.1 gateway applies to tort claims involving damage in England and Wales?
Gateway 9: where damage was or will be sustained within the jurisdiction, or damage sustained results from an act committed or likely to be committed within the jurisdiction.
When can a contractual jurisdiction clause give the courts of England and Wales jurisdiction without permission to serve outside the jurisdiction?
Where the contract contains a term stating that the courts of England and/or Wales shall have jurisdiction.
How does a contractual jurisdiction clause interact with the Hague Convention?
The common law route may apply to agreements concluded before 1 October 2015 or agreements that do not give exclusive jurisdiction to the courts of England and Wales.
When is permission required to serve a claim form outside the jurisdiction?
In all circumstances except where the Hague Convention applies or the contract contains a term stating that the courts of England and/or Wales shall have jurisdiction.
What form must be filed when serving a claim form outside the jurisdiction without permission?
Form N510, filed when issuing the claim form, confirming the basis of the court's jurisdiction.
How does a claimant apply for permission to serve a claim form outside the jurisdiction?
By an interim application under the usual rules, using Form N244.
What is the period for serving a claim form outside the jurisdiction?
Six months.
What methods may be used to serve proceedings outside the jurisdiction?
(1) In accordance with an agreed regulation, convention or treaty; (2) through the government of the destination country; or (3) by any method permitted by the law of the destination country.
What are common reasons for a defendant to dispute the jurisdiction of the courts of England and Wales?
The defendant may dispute whether the Hague Convention applies, challenge whether a jurisdictional gateway or the proper-place test is satisfied, or argue that another forum is more appropriate despite effective service within the jurisdiction.
What must a defendant do first to dispute the jurisdiction of the courts of England and Wales?
File an acknowledgement of service under CPR 11(2), indicating that they intend to contest jurisdiction.
When must a defendant apply to dispute jurisdiction after filing an acknowledgement of service?
Within 14 days after filing the acknowledgement of service.
What must accompany an application disputing jurisdiction?
Evidence supporting the challenge.
What should a defendant avoid doing if they wish to dispute the court's jurisdiction?
They should not take further steps to engage with the proceedings beyond filing the acknowledgement of service; for example, they should not file a defence.
What is the effect of submitting to the jurisdiction of the courts of England and Wales?
The defendant cannot subsequently dispute that court's jurisdiction.
What is the applicable law framework for contractual disputes?
The Rome I Regulation, as amended and retained EU law.
What is the first question when determining the applicable law of a contract under Rome I?
Whether the parties have chosen the applicable law.
How may parties choose the applicable law of a contract under Rome I?
By an express choice in the contract. The choice can also be made after the dispute has arisen.
What happens if the parties have chosen the applicable law of a contract under Rome I?
The chosen country's law applies.
What is the next step under Rome I if the parties have not chosen the applicable law?
Consider whether the contract falls within one of the specific categories in Articles 4(1)(a)–(h).
Which law applies to a sale of goods contract under Rome I in the absence of a choice?
The law of the seller's habitual residence.
How is a seller's habitual residence determined under Rome I?
By its central administration or principal place of business.
Which law applies to a contract for the provision of services under Rome I in the absence of a choice?
The law of the service provider's habitual residence.
Which law applies to a contract relating to land under Rome I in the absence of a choice?
The law of the country where the land is situated.
Which law applies to a distribution contract under Rome I in the absence of a choice?
The law of the distributor's habitual residence.
What happens under Rome I if the contract does not fall within one of the specified Article 4(1)(a)–(h) categories?
The applicable law is that of the country where the characteristic performer has their habitual residence.
Who is the characteristic performer under Rome I?
The party required to effect the characteristic performance of the contract.
What final consideration may affect the applicable law under Rome I?
Whether the contract is manifestly more closely connected with another country.
To which contracts does the Rome I framework described in the notes not apply?
Contracts entered into before 17 December 2009.
Which types of contract have special provisions under Rome I?
Contracts of carriage, consumer contracts, employment contracts and insurance contracts.
What is the applicable law framework for tortious disputes?
The Rome II Regulation, as amended and retained EU law.
What is the first question when determining the applicable law of a tort under Rome II?
Whether the parties have validly chosen the applicable law.
When is a choice of law agreement for a tort effective if made after the event giving rise to the damage?
The parties' choice will be effective.
When is a choice of law agreement for a tort effective if made before the event giving rise to the damage?
Only where both parties pursue a commercial activity and freely negotiated the choice.
How may parties choose the applicable law for a tort under Rome II?
The choice may be express or demonstrated by the circumstances of the case.
What is the next step under Rome II if the parties have not chosen the applicable law?
Consider whether the claimant and defendant habitually reside in the same country.
What law applies under Rome II where the claimant and defendant habitually reside in the same country?
The law of that country applies, even if the damage occurred elsewhere.
How is a company's habitual residence determined under Rome II?
By its central administration.
How is the habitual residence of a natural person acting in the course of business determined under Rome II?
By the location of their principal place of business.
What law applies under Rome II where the claimant and defendant do not habitually reside in the same country?
The law of the country in which the damage occurs.
Where is the place of damage under Rome II?
The place where the damage occurs, not the place where the event giving rise to the damage occurs or where indirect consequences might occur.
What final consideration may affect the applicable law under Rome II?
Whether the tort is manifestly more closely connected with another country.
To which events does the Rome II framework described in the notes apply?
Events giving rise to damage which occurred on or after 10 January 2009.
Which types of tort have special provisions under Rome II?
Product liability, unfair competition, environmental damage, infringement of intellectual property and industrial action.
How are conflict of laws issues determined in disputes involving Scotland or Northern Ireland?
In the same way as conflict of laws issues involving any other country.
Which legislation governs jurisdiction where a defendant is based in Scotland or Northern Ireland?
The Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982.
What is the effect of exclusive jurisdiction rules under the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982?
The relevant part of the UK has exclusive jurisdiction. For example, disputes concerning land are heard in the part of the UK where the land is situated.
What is the effect of a jurisdiction agreement under the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982?
Where the parties agree that a particular part of the UK will have jurisdiction, that part will have jurisdiction.
What is the effect of submission to jurisdiction under the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982?
If a party submits to the jurisdiction of a court, for example by filing a defence, that court will have jurisdiction, subject to exclusive jurisdiction rules.
Can submission to jurisdiction override exclusive jurisdiction rules in a UK cross-border dispute?
No.
What is the starting point for jurisdiction in a UK cross-border dispute if no exclusive jurisdiction, jurisdiction agreement or submission rule applies?
A person should be sued in the courts of the place where they are domiciled.
How is an individual's domicile described in the notes for UK cross-border jurisdiction?
Residence plus a substantial connection.
How is a company's domicile described in the notes for UK cross-border jurisdiction?
Its registered office or place of incorporation.
Where may a contractual claim be brought as an alternative to the defendant's domicile under UK cross-border jurisdiction rules?
In the courts for the place of performance of the obligation in question.
Where may a tort claim be brought as an alternative to the defendant's domicile under UK cross-border jurisdiction rules?
In the courts where the harmful event occurred or may occur.
Where may a claim arising from the operations of a branch, agency or other establishment be brought?
In the courts for the place where the branch, agency or establishment is situated.
Where may claims against multiple defendants be brought under UK cross-border jurisdiction rules?
In the courts where any one of the defendants is domiciled, provided the claims are so closely connected that it is expedient to hear and determine them together.
Where may a counterclaim be brought under UK cross-border jurisdiction rules?
In the court where the original claim is pending, if the counterclaim arises from the same contract or facts as the original claim.