1/63
civil litigation
Q1. What is a limitation period?
The period within which a claimant must bring court proceedings to enforce a legal right.
Q2. What does it mean when a claim is statute-barred?
A: The limitation period has expired, giving the defendant a defence if they rely on it.
Does expiry of limitation automatically extinguish the underlying legal right?
Generally no. It normally provides a defence to the claim rather than extinguishing the right itself.
What is accrual of a cause of action?
The date when all the facts necessary to give the claimant a right to sue have occurred.
When does a cause of action in simple contract usually accrue?
When the contract is breached.
When does a cause of action in negligence usually accrue?
When actionable damage occurs, not necessarily when the negligent act took place.
Q8. What is the difference between issuing and serving a claim?
Issue formally starts proceedings; service formally brings the claim to the defendant's attention.
. Can a claim sometimes count as brought before its formal issue date?
Yes. For limitation, the earlier court-receipt date may apply where the claim was properly lodged before expiry and later issued.
What is the midnight distinction in limitation calculations?
If a cause of action arises exactly at the start of a day, that day is included. If it arises during the day, that day is excluded.
What is the limitation period for ordinary tort claims under s.2?
Six years from accrual of the cause of action.
What is the limitation period for simple contract claims under s.5?
Six years from the date of breach.
What is the limitation period for contribution claims under s.10?
Two years from when the right to contribution arises.
What is the normal limitation period for personal injury under s.11?
Three years from accrual or the injured person's date of knowledge, whichever is later.
What is the limitation period for Fatal Accidents Act claims under s.12?
Three years from death or the relevant dependant's date of knowledge, whichever is later, subject to the statutory gateway.
What is the special limitation rule for latent damage under s.14A?
The later of six years from accrual or three years from the relevant date of knowledge.
What is the long-stop limitation period under s.14B?
Fifteen years from the relevant negligent act or omission, subject to the statutory rules.
What is the limitation period for bringing a fresh action on a judgment under s.24?
Six years from when the judgment became enforceable.
What is a contribution claim?
A claim by one person liable for damage against another person liable for the same damage, seeking a share of the liability.
When does the two-year contribution period begin following a judgment?
When judgment determines the amount payable, under s.10(3).
When does the contribution period begin following an arbitration award?
On the date the arbitration award determines the amount payable.
When does the contribution period begin if the original claim settles?
When the amount of compensation to be paid is agreed, under s.10(4).
When does contribution clock begin?
No. It generally begins when the amount payable is determined by judgment or award, or agreed in settlement.
Must compensation actually be paid before the contribution clock begins?
No. The relevant judgment, award or settlement agreement can start time before payment.
Does an appeal changing the amount awarded automatically restart contribution limitation?
No. An appeal does not ordinarily restart the two-year clock.
What two dates must you compare when calculating personal injury limitation?
The date the cause of action accrued and the injured person's date of knowledge. Use the later date.
What four matters must the injured person know under s.14(1)?
Significant injury, factual attribution to the alleged act or omission, defendant's identity, and any necessary third-party facts.
What is a significant injury under s.14(2)?
An injury sufficiently serious that a reasonable person would consider bringing proceedings, assuming liability and ability to pay.
Must a claimant know that the defendant was legally negligent for time to run?
No. Knowledge of the relevant facts is enough; legal knowledge of negligence is unnecessary.
What is actual knowledge?
Facts the claimant genuinely knows.
What is constructive knowledge under s.14(3)?
Facts the claimant could reasonably have discovered, including with appropriate expert advice.
What protection applies to a claimant who reasonably seeks expert advice?
They are not automatically treated as knowing expert-only facts if they took all reasonable steps to obtain and act on advice.
What happens under s.11(5) if an injured person dies before their own limitation period expires?
Their estate may have a fresh three-year period from death or the personal representative's date of knowledge, whichever is later.
Who brings the deceased's surviving personal injury claim?
The personal representative, on behalf of the deceased's estate.
Is an estate's surviving personal injury claim the same as a dependant's Fatal Accidents Act claim?
No. The estate continues the deceased's own claim; dependants bring a separate claim arising from the death.
what is the gateway rule for fatal accidents?
Check whether the deceased could still have maintained an action and recovered damages when they died.
What if the deceased's own claim was already statute-barred at death?
The dependants' claim is generally barred too, subject to any applicable s.33 discretion.
If the deceased's claim was not barred, how is the dependant's limitation period calculated?
Three years from death or the relevant dependant's date of knowledge, whichever is later.
What is latent damage?
Damage caused by negligence that is hidden and only discovered later.
Does section 14A apply to personal injury claims?
No. It applies to negligence claims involving damage other than personal injury.
Does section latent damage claims apply to breach of contract merely because damage was discovered late?
No. Section 14A is specifically concerned with negligence claims, not ordinary contract claims.
How is limitation calculated for latent damage?
The later of six years from accrual or three years from the relevant date of knowledge.
What is the relevant starting date for the three-year period under latent damage?
The earliest date when the claimant has both the required knowledge and the right to bring the action.
What must the claimant know under latent damage?
Significant damage, factual attribution to the alleged negligence, defendant's identity and any necessary third-party facts.
Must the claimant know precisely how the defendant was negligent?
No. Sufficient factual knowledge suggesting the defendant's act or omission caused the damage is enough.
What is the purpose of the 15-year long-stop under s.14B?
: To impose a final deadline for applicable negligence claims, regardless of when the damage was discovered.
When does the 15-year long-stop begin?
From the relevant negligent act or omission, rather than the date the hidden damage was discovered.
What if the claimant discovers latent damage after the 15-year long-stop expires?
The claim is generally barred under s.14B, even if the claimant could not reasonably have discovered the damage earlier.
What is the limitation period of judgments?
A fresh action on a judgment must generally be brought within six years of the judgment becoming enforceable.
Does judgement limitation rules automatically prevent enforcement of the original judgment after six years?
No. It restricts fresh actions on judgments; enforcement of existing judgments is subject to separate rules
What is the rule concerning judgment interest?
Interest that became due more than six years earlier cannot be recovered.
What counts as a disability under s.38(2)?
Being under 18 or lacking the relevant mental capacity to conduct legal proceedings.
When must the claimant normally be under a disability for s.28 to apply?
When the cause of action accrues.
What is the general disability limitation period for disability
Six years from when the disability ends or the claimant dies, whichever occurs first, subject to special rules.
What is the special rule for personal injury for disability?
three years from when the disability ends or the claimant dies, whichever occurs first.
normal limitation period for disability in general claims ?
6 years
Can a person obtain a fresh disability extension merely by inheriting a claim from someone who was not disabled?
No. Section 28(2) generally prevents this.
Can successive disabilities repeatedly restart limitation when a claim passes between people?
No. Section 28(3) prevents repeated extensions of that kind.
What is the disability limitation period for contribution claims under s.28(5)?
Two years from when the disability ends or the claimant dies, whichever occurs first.
What 3 discretion apply to limitation?
Fraud, deliberate concealment of relevant facts, and claims for relief from the consequences of a mistake
What happens to limitation where fraud/concealment and mistake?
Its commencement is postponed until the fraud, concealment or mistake is discovered or reasonably discoverable.
time limit follows the original cause of action
What does reasonable diligence mean under fraud/concealment/mistake discretion?
The steps a person acting reasonably should have taken to discover the relevant facts.
What does court’s discretion in limitation mean?
To allow the court to disapply specified limitation periods for personal injury and death claims where equitable.
What is the central test for courts discretion of limitation?
Whether it is fair and equitable to allow the claim, considering prejudice to both claimant and defendant.
What 6 factors do the court consider?
Delay and reasons; effect on evidence; defendant's conduct; disability; claimant's promptness; steps to obtain advice.