1/34
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Philosophical issues in Psychology
What science is
How scientific knowledge develops
What makes knowledge scientific
Whether psychology can be considered a science
Necessity vs Efficacy
Necessary Condition: something that must be present for an outcome to occur
Sufficient Condition: something that guarantees an outcome when present
Example= Oxygen is necessary for human brain functioning, but oxygen alone is not sufficient to guarantee normal brain functioning
a priori vs a posteriori knowledge
a priori: knowledge independent of experience or observation
a posteriori: knowledge gained through experience or observation
Innate vs Learned Characteristics
Innate: Characteristics we are born with
Learnt: Characteristics developed through experience and environmental influences
Deduction
Reasoning from general premises to a logically necessary conclusion
Example:
All ravens are black
This bird is a raven
Therefore, this bird is black
Induction
Reasoning from specific observations to broader generalisations
Example:
I have observed 100 white swans
Therefore, I conclude that all swans are white
However, this conclusion is not guaranteed to be correct
Logical proof vs Scientific proof
Logical proof: Achieved through deduction and provides a logically certain conclusion if the premises are true
Scientific proof: Based on observations and induction, providing supporting evidence but not absolute certainty
Denying the Consequent (resulting from a cause) vs denying the Antecedent (happening prior)
Denying the consequent: Not Q —> Not P. This is logically valid
Denying the antecedent: Not P —> Not Q. This is logically invalid
Example:
If something is a raven, it is black
If it is not black, it cannot be a raven (valid)
If its is not a raven, it cannot be black (invalid)
Inductivism
The common sense view that science develops through observation and the collection of facts, from which scientific theories are constructed
Which philosophers are associated with empiricism and positivism
Empiricists: Locke, Berkeley and Hume
Positivists: Comte, the Vienna Circle and Ayer
Both approaches emphasise the importance of observable evidence in knowledge
The basic process of Inductivism
Observe the world
Collect facts through observations
Identify patterns and regularities
Develop scientific theories based on these facts
Gather further observations that support the theories
In short: Observations —> Facts —> Theories
Main problems of Inductivism
Problems with facts: What actually counts as a fact?
Problems with observations: How do we access facts objectively
Problems moving from facts to theories: How do we construct theories from observations
Problems with induction: Can we logically justify generalising from observations
Why might two people interpret the same facts differently?
Because perception and interpretation are influenced by:
Prior knowledge
Expectations
Experience
Top-down processing
Bistable visual illusions
Images that allow two different interpretations despite the visual input remaining unchanged
Examples:
The Rubin vase (a vase or two faces)
The duck-rabbit illusion
The young/old woman illusion
They demonstrate how perception is influenced by top-down processing
Top-down processing
The process by which prior knowledge, expectations and experience influence how we interpret incoming sensory information
Extraneous variables vs Confounding variables
Extraneous variables: Variables other than the independent variable that may influence the dependent variable
Confounding variables: Variables that systematically vary with the independent variable, making it difficult to determine what caused the results
Both can affect the validity of research findings
Galileo’s feather-and-hammer demonstration
Galileo demonstrated that objects fall at the same rate in the absence of air resistance, regardless of their mass
Differences in falling speeds on Earth are explained by air resistance and the shape of objects
This illustrates why experiments need to control relevant variables
What does it mean that scientific facts are temporarily indexed?
Facts and their interpretations can change over time as scientific knowledge develops
Example:
In the 1200s, the accepted view was that the Sun moved around the Earth
By the 1900s, the accepted scientific model was that the Earth moves around the Sun
The same observations can be interpreted differently depending on the scientific knowledge available at the time
How can prior experience bias scientific observation?
Researchers’ expectations and previous experience can influence what they notice and how they interpret observations
Example: Thurber’s microscope illustrates how prior expectations can influence what someone believes they are seeing
Selective Reporting
When researchers selectively report favourable or statistically significant results while leaving out other findings
This can create a misleading picture of the evidence and make findings appear stronger than they actually are
Statistical significance vs Scientific significance
Statistical significance: Whether a result meets a statistical threshold, such as p less than 0.05
Scientific significance: Whether the finding is meaningful or important in the real world
A statistically significant result is not necessarily scientifically important
The problem of induction
There is no logical justification for assuming that patterns observed in the past will necessarily continue in the future
Even if something has happened repeatedly, it does not guarantee it will happen again
Russell’s chicken example
A chicken is fed by the same person every morning
After repeatedly observing this, the chicken concludes that the person will always feed it
However, one day the person kills the chicken
Conclusion: Repeated observations cannot guarantee that a pattern will continue. Induction can fail unexpectedly
Hempel’s paradox of confirmation
Hempel demonstrated a logical problem with how evidence confirms theories
Theory: All ravens are black
Logically, observing a non-black non-raven (such as a white shoe) also confirms the theory that all ravens are black Logically
This illustrates the difficulties of determining what counts as confirming evidence
Falsificationism - Karl Popper
Proposed by Karl Popper
Falsificationism argues that a scientific theory must be capable of being proven false through observation or experimentation
A theory is scientific because it can be tested and potentially contradicted, not simply because evidence supports it
Why did Popper criticise Inductivism?
Popper argued that:
Collecting more supporting evidence does not prove a theory is correct
Theories can be made so flexible that almost any observation supports them
This could allow non-scientific beliefs, such as religion or Marxism, to appear scientific
He be,I eve dscientific theories should make predictions that could potentially be falsified
Can scientific theories ever be proven true according to Popper?
No
According to Popper:
Theories can never be established as absolutely true
They can only be considered well-tested
However, theories can be shown to be false through contradictory evidence
Why is one counter example important to Falsificationism?
One genuine counter example can logically contradict a universal statement
Example:
Theory: All swans are white
Observation: One black swan
Conclusion: The theory is falsified
This demonstrates how universal statements can be disproven by a single contradictory observation
According to Popper, why are more falsifiable theories better?
The more falsifiable a theory is, the better it is considered scientifically
A broader theory makes more predictions and has more opportunities to be proven wrong
Example:
Theory A: Apples thrown out of windows fall downstairs
Theory B: All objects thrown out of windows fall downstairs
Theory B is more falsifiable because it applies to a wider range of objects
According to Falsificationism, what is the process of scientific investigation?
Begin with a problem
Develop a theory to explain it
Make observations or conduct experiments
Determine whether the evidence falsified the theory
If falsified, reconsider or modify the theory
Unlike Inductivism, theories come before the observations used to test them
Main criticisms of Falsificationism
It can be difficult to determine whether a theory or an observation action is responsible for contradictory findings
Scientific theories involve multiple assumptions, making it difficult to identify exactly what has failed
Historically, almost every scientific theory has encountered contradictory observations
It is difficult to rank the importance and reliability of different observations
Some non-scientific statements can also be falsifiable, such as predictions made by astrology
What does the example of Uranus’ orbit demonstrate about Falsificationism
Uranus has an unusual, apparently inconsistent orbit that seemed to contradict Newton’s theory
However, the problem was actually caused by the gravitational influence of Neptune, which had not yet been discovered
Conclusion: An apparent contradiction does not necessarily mean a scientific theory is wrong. Other explanations and assumptions must be considered.
Paradigms - Thomas Kuhn
According to Thomas Kuhn, a paradigm is a set of assumptions, theories, methods and beliefs accepted by a scientific community
Examples:
Behaviourism
Newtonian mechanics
Paradigms provide the framework within which scientists conduct research
According to Kuhn, what are the five stages of scientific development?