1/21
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Subsequent statements of case that may be served after the defence
1) A counterclaim by the defendant; 2) A defence to counterclaim by the claimant; and 3) A reply to the defence to counterclaim by the defendant.
CPR Part governing additional claims and counterclaims
CPR Part 20.
Definition of an 'additional claim' under CPR 20.2
Any claim other than the main claim brought by the claimant against the defendant; it is treated as a claim under CPR 20.3.
Timing and permission rules for filing a counterclaim (CPR 20.4(2))
A counterclaim may be filed without the court's permission if filed together with the defence; filing at any other time requires the court's permission.
Claim number assigned to a counterclaim
The same claim number as the main claim.
Four substantive elements a defendant must establish to succeed on a counterclaim
1) Duty; 2) Breach; 3) Causation; and 4) Loss.
Court powers when a counterclaim should not be heard with the main claim
The court may order the counterclaim to be dealt with as separate proceedings under CPR 3.1(2)(e) or strike it out under CPR 3.4, considering factors such as its connection to the main claim under CPR 20.9.
Method of presenting a counterclaim among statements of case (CPR 15.7)
In the same document as the defence, positioned directly after the defence in a combined document titled Defence and Counterclaim.
Court fee requirement for filing a counterclaim
Yes, a court fee is payable on a counterclaim.
Four main circumstances where a defendant can rely on a cross-claim as a set-off
1) Mutual debts (legal set-off); 2) Defective goods under s 53(1)(a) Sale of Goods Act 1979; 3) Defective services; and 4) Equitable set-off.
Legal set-off (mutual debts)
A defence where both parties owe each other liquidated or readily ascertainable debts due and payable at the commencement of proceedings; the debts do not need to be connected, and it cannot apply to unliquidated damages.
Set-off for defective goods under s 53(1)(a) Sale of Goods Act 1979
Where a seller sues for the price of goods sold and delivered, the buyer can set up a breach of implied terms (such as satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose) in diminution or extinction of the price.
Defective services set-off
Where a claimant sues for the price of services, the defendant can set off its claim for damages for poor-quality services against that price.
Test for equitable set-off (Geldof Metaalconstructie NV v Simon Carves Ltd)
Applies where the cross-claim is so closely connected with the main claim that it would be manifestly unjust to enforce the claim without taking the cross-claim into account; unlike legal set-off, it can apply to unliquidated damages.
Location for pleading a defence of set-off in statements of case (CPR 16.6)
In the defence section of the Defence and Counterclaim document.
Standard drafting formula for pleading a defence of set-off
Set out as the final paragraph of the defence: 'Further or in the alternative, if the Defendant is held liable to the Claimant, the Defendant will seek to set off against the Claimant's claim so much of the sum awarded on its counterclaim as will reduce or extinguish the Claimant's claim.'
Deadline for filing a defence to counterclaim (CPR 15.4 / CPR 20.3)
14 days after service of the counterclaim.
Acknowledgment of service rules for a counterclaim (CPR 20.4(3))
There is no acknowledgment of service for a counterclaim, so the standard 28-day response period does not apply, though parties can agree an extension of up to 28 days under CPR 15.5.
Definition and purpose of a Reply (CPR 15.8)
An optional statement of case served by the claimant if it wishes to allege facts in answer to the defence that were not included in the particulars of claim.
Filing deadline for a Reply (CPR 15.8)
Must be filed with the claimant's directions questionnaire and served on the other parties at the same time (with the deadline set by the notice of proposed allocation giving at least 14 days).
Combined presentation of a Reply and a Defence to Counterclaim
They are normally contained in a single document titled Reply and Defence to Counterclaim, with the reply placed before the defence to counterclaim.
Rule on statements of case after a Reply (CPR 15.9)
No party may file or serve any statement of case after a reply without the court's permission.