1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
A customer and an online retailer enter into a contract for the sale of washing machines. The customer telephones the retailer, who offers the customer interest-free credit over the phone. The customer decides to purchase the washing machine on these terms.
Which of the statements below most accurately reflects the position in law?
A. The contract between the retailer and the customer can be concluded verbally as there is no requirement for a contract to be made in writing.
B. As this is a consumer contact, it must be made in writing.
C. As this is a consumer credit agreement, it must be made in writing.
D. As the contract is a gratuitous promise, it must be made by deed.
E. As the contract is with an online retailer, it will automatically be concluded electronically.
Correct answer:
C. As this is a consumer credit agreement, it must be made in writing.
Explanation:
Simple contracts can be made in any form: verbal, written or through conduct of the parties. However, certain contracts are required to be made in writing, and a consumer credit agreement is one such contract.
A company manufacturing tin cans orders replacement machinery from a supplier. The output of the new machinery is stated to be 20% higher than that of the old machinery. The contract provides that the machinery is to be ready for operation on 30 September, and that the supplier will pay £1,500 per day for every day that installation is late. Installation is completed 30 days late. The delay in installation means that the company is not able to speed up its production as it had hoped, and it loses £20,000 in profits as a result.
What amount of damages will the company most likely be able to claim successfully from the supplier?
A. £20,000 lost profits, unless the company can show that £1,500 per day is a genuine pre-estimate of its loss.
B. Nothing, because lost profits are not recoverable in contract, and the agreement to pay £1,500 per day is void as a penalty.
C. £65,000, £1,500 per day for 30 days, plus £20,000 lost profits.
D. £45,000, £1,500 per day for 30 days because this amount was clearly stated in the contract.
E. Nothing, because loss of profits was not in the reasonable contemplation of the parties, and the agreement to pay £1,500 per day is void as a penalty.
Correct Answer:
A. £20,000 lost profits, unless the company can show that £1,500 per day is a genuine pre-estimate of its loss.
Explanation:
The company will most likely be able to claim £20,000 for lost profits. The lost profits appear to flow naturally from the supplier's breach and so they are not too remote. The company will not be able to claim the £1,500 per day unless it can show that is a genuine pre-estimate of its loss. The £1,500 looks like it could be a penalty, as it seems to be out of proportion to the company's likely losses.
A cyclist is riding carefully along a road when he is struck by a car driven carelessly by driver A. He is thrown from his bike and is then hit by a lorry driven carelessly by driver B. He suffers a broken leg. The cyclist issues proceedings against driver A only. The court finds that the cyclist suffered one indivisible injury, to which the negligence of both drivers, A and B, made a material contribution. The court finds that driver A was 40% to blame for the injury to the cyclist and driver B was 60% to blame.
In relation to the amount of damages recoverable by the cyclist, which of the following statements is correct?
A. The cyclist is entitled to recover 100% of his damages from driver A.
B. The cyclist is entitled to recover 100% of his damages from driver A, unless driver A seeks a contribution from driver B to reflect his share of responsibility.
C. The cyclist is only entitled to recover 40% of his damages from driver A.
D. The cyclist will need to pursue a claim against both driver A and driver B if he is to be entitled to recover his damages in full.
E. The court's apportionment of responsibility between driver A and driver B will determine the damages the cyclist is entitled to recover.
Correct Answer:
A. The cyclist is entitled to recover 100% of his damages from driver A.
Explanation:
The cyclist is entitled to recover 100% of his damages from driver A. The cyclist has suffered one indivisible injury caused by both driver A and driver B. Where the injury is not divisible, the claimant is entitled to recover his damages in full from either of the defendants. So, he may recover 100% of his damages from driver A. Therefore, (C) is not correct. (B)is not correct. By statute, driver A may seek a contribution from driver B because they are both liable to the cyclist in respect of the same damage. However, this does not affect the liability of driver A to the cyclist. (D) is not correct. The cyclist is entitled to recover his damages in full from driver A, as discussed above. (E) is not correct. While the court may apportion responsibility between driver A and driver B, this only takes effect as between driver A and driver B. It does not determine the damages the cyclist is entitled to recover.
Under the Railway Fares Act 2011, the government has laid before the House of Commons and the House of Lords a draft of the Railway Fares Regulations 2020, which set the prices of train tickets. The regulations are subject to the affirmative resolution procedure.
What powers do Parliament have in respect of the regulations?
A. Both the House of Commons and House of Lords have 40 days during which they can vote to reject the regulations.
B. Both the House of Commons and the House of Lords can amend the regulations.
C. Only the House of Commons can amend the regulations.
D. Only the House of Lords can amend the regulations.
E. Both the House of Commons and House of Lords must vote in favour of the regulations for them to become law.
Correct Answer:
E. Both the House of Commons and House of Lords must vote in favour of the regulations for them to become law.
Explanation:
(E) Both the House of Commons and House of Lords must vote in favour of the regulations for them to become law. The regulations are a form of secondary legislation, in that they are made under powers granted by an Act of Parliament. The affirmative resolution procedure requires that both Houses vote in favour of the regulations for them to become law. (A) is incorrect because it describes the negative resolution procedure, which is the other procedure for enacting secondary legislation. (B), (C), and (D) are incorrect because they provide for amendment and neither House has the power to amend the regulations.
A river breaks its banks and floods a farmer's field. A neighbour offers to help pump away the water. The neighbour's water pump is old and slow and takes a very long time to pump away the water. During that time, the crop in the field is ruined and the farmer is unable to sell it.
In a negligence action by the farmer against the neighbour to recover the value of the crop, which of the following is true?
A. The neighbour will be liable if a reasonable person would have taken steps to pump out the water more quickly.
B. The neighbour is not liable to the farmer because he voluntarily undertook to help rescue the crop.
C. The neighbour is not liable because the farmer is seeking to recover pure economic loss.
D. The neighbour will be liable if the farmer can show that, but for the delay caused by the slow pump, the crop would not have been damaged.
E. The neighbour is not liable because the damage to the crop was not reasonably foreseeable and so is too remote.
Correct Answer:
B. The neighbour is not liable to the farmer because he voluntarily undertook to help rescue the crop.
Explanation:
(B) The neighbour is not liable to the farmer. In general, there is no duty to undertake a rescue. Therefore, where a person does undertake a rescue, their duty is only to take reasonable care not to make the situation worse than it would have been had they not intervened. On the facts, there is nothing to suggest that the neighbour's intervention made the situation worse (it did not, for example, prevent anyone else from undertaking a more effective rescue of the crop). (A) is not correct. It refers to the standard of reasonable care, but the neighbour was not under a duty to take care to save the crop (only a duty not to make the situation worse). (C) is not correct. The crop has suffered physical damage, so its value is not pure economic loss. (D) is not correct. It refers to the test for establishing causation of damage, but this is not relevant here because the neighbour was not under a duty to take care to save the crop. (E) is not correct. It refers to the test for remoteness of damage, but this is not relevant here because the neighbour was not under a duty to take care to save the crop.
A motorbike rider and his passenger went out together and each drank more alcohol than the legal limit for driving. The passenger knew that the rider had drunk too much and also that the rider was not insured to drive the bike. Nevertheless, the passenger encouraged him to drive the bike with the passenger on board. Then, as they drove, the passenger encouraged the rider to drive in a dangerous manner. As a result, an accident occurred in which the rider was killed and the passenger was seriously injured.
In an action in negligence by the passenger against the estate of the deceased rider, which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
A. The rider's estate will be liable to the passenger because, by statute, the passenger's cause of action survives the rider's death.
B. The rider's estate will not be liable to the passenger because it will be able to rely on the defences of both voluntary assumption of risk and illegality.
C. The rider's estate will not be liable to the passenger because it will be able to rely on the defence of voluntary assumption of risk only.
D. The rider's estate will not be liable to the passenger because it will be able to rely on the defence of illegality only.
E. The rider's estate will be liable to the passenger because the passenger's intoxication prevents application of any defence against the claim.
Correct Answer:
D. The rider's estate will not be liable to the passenger because it will be able to rely on the defence of illegality only.
Explanation:
(D) The passenger's claim against the rider's estate is likely to be defeated by the defence of illegality. The defence of illegality is a rule of public policy which prevents a claimant from recovering compensation for damage suffered as a result of their own illegal actions. The defence of illegality is a complete defence, so the claimant cannot recover damages for harm suffered whilst he is taking part in the criminal activity. Answers (B) and (C) are not correct because they both assume that the defence of voluntary assumption of risk would be available. While the passenger's actions also indicate that he voluntarily assumed the risk of the rider's negligence, the defence of voluntary assumption of risk, by statute, does not apply to passengers in road traffic accidents. (A) is not correct. It is true that the passenger's claim against the rider survives the rider's death by statute. However that claim is likely to be defeated by the defence of illegality, as explained above.
A car parking company arranges to meet a car owner at the airport, where an employee will collect the keys and drive the car to a secure carpark for the duration of the car owner's trip. On leaving the airport, the employee does not drive directly to the secure carpark but drops into a nearby local supermarket to pick up his lunch. At the supermarket, the employee parks the car illegally in a place where parking is prohibited, and as he does so, he negligently damages the vehicle.
Which of the following statements most accurately describes the vicarious liability of the car parking company for the tort committed by its employee?
A. The car parking company is not vicariously liable because the damage was caused by the employee and cannot be attributed to his employer.
B. The car parking company is not vicariously liable because the employee acted illegally in parking the car and an employer cannot be liable for the criminal acts of its employees.
C. The car parking company is not vicariously liable because the negligence occurred when the employee left the authorised route and travelled to the supermarket.
D. The car parking company is vicariously liable for the actions of its negligent employee because the negligence occurred during the course of his employment.
E. The car parking company is vicariously liable for the actions of its negligent employee regardless of whether the negligence occurred during the course of his employment.
Correct Answer:
D. The car parking company is vicariously liable for the actions of its negligent employee because the negligence occurred during the course of his employment.
Explanation:
(D) The car parking company is vicariously liable. For an employer to be vicariously liable, the employee's tort must be committed during the course of employment. The question here is whether the employee's deviation from the authorised route, to go to the supermarket, took him outside the course of his employment. If the extent of the deviation in time or distance indicates that the employee has started on a separate independent journey for a purpose of his own, the employee is unlikely to remain within the course of employment. On the other hand, a minor deviation, not amounting to a new and separate journey, is unlikely to take the employee outside the course of his employment. On the facts, this appears to be a minor deviation, which is unlikely to take the employee outside the course of his employment. Therefore, (C) is not correct. (A) is not correct because an employer is vicariously liable for the tort of an employee committed during the course of employment, as discussed above. (B) is not correct. An employer can be vicariously liable for the torts of employees which amount to a criminal act, provided there is a sufficiently close connection with the employee's employment, so that the tort was committed in the course of employment. (E) is not correct because an employer can be vicariously liable for an employee's tort only if the tort was committed during the course of employment.
Parliament has recently passed a new statute relating to war crimes.
Which of the following is NOT a presumption that can be used in helping to determine the reach of the statute?
A. A presumption against allowing statutes to alter the common law.
B. A presumption that statutes cannot be retrospectively applied.
C. A presumption against removing the court's jurisdiction.
D. A presumption that ambiguity in a criminal case will fall in favour of the defendant.
E. A presumption that statutes can be retrospectively applied.
Correct Answer:
E. A presumption that statutes can be retrospectively applied.
Explanation:
(E) The other presumptions exist. Presumptions can assist in clearing up statutory ambiguities and are rebuttable when the relevant legal rule may be unapplied if there is sufficient evidence. (A) through (D) are all included as presumptions and so would be incorrect.
A traffic accident occurred when two cars collided at a junction between a main road and a side road. Driver A was driving along the main road when driver B pulled out of the side road into her path. Driver A was exceeding the speed limit at the time of the accident. Driver B was driving without due care and attention. Both drivers were convicted of road traffic offences. Neither driver was physically injured but driver A's car was damaged. The evidence showed that the damage would have been less serious had driver A been driving within the speed limit.
In an action by driver A against driver B to recover the money she paid for repairs to her car, which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
A. Driver A will not have a successful claim because she was exceeding the speed limit at the time of the collision and so the defence of illegality will apply.
B. Driver A is likely to have a successful claim, but her damages are likely to be reduced to reflect her share in responsibility for the damage to her car.
C. Driver A is likely to have a successful claim and will recover the full cost of the repairs because she can rely on driver B's conviction for driving without due care and attention as evidence of his negligence.
D. Driver A will not have a successful claim because she was not injured, so her only loss was pure economic loss in incurring the cost of repairs to her car.
E. Driver A will not have a successful claim because both she and driver B are equally to blame for the accident.
Correct Answer:
B. Driver A is likely to have a successful claim, but her damages are likely to be reduced to reflect her share in responsibility for the damage to her car.
Explanation:
(B) Driver A will have a successful claim but her damages will be reduced. Driver A was owed a duty of care by driver B. Driver B was in breach of that duty, and this caused driver A's loss. However. the facts show that driver A failed to take reasonable care for her own safetv by exceedina the speed limit and that this contributed to the harm she suffered.
The Secretary of State has announced that they intend to create a compensation scheme for homeowners who lost their homes during recent flooding in the south east of England. The Secretary of State also announced that they would consult with those affected when developing the scheme. However, two weeks later, and before the consultation process had been completed, the Secretary of State launched the compensation scheme, detailing who would qualify and the levels of compensation payable. A homeowner who was affected by the flooding but who would not qualify under the scheme announced by the Secretary of State wishes to challenge the scheme. The homeowner files an application for judicial review.
Which of the following bases for the homeowner's judicial review application is most likely to succeed?
A. The Secretary of State has not given effect to a legitimate expectation of consultation.
B. The Secretary of State has not complied with the general statutory duty to consult.
C. The Secretary of State has not complied with the general common law duty to consult.
D. The Secretary of State has not complied with the rules on natural justice.
E. The Secretary of State has not given effect to a substantive legitimate expectation.
Correct Answer:
A. The Secretary of State has not given effect to a legitimate expectation of consultation.
Explanation:
(A) The homeowner is most likely to prevail on the basis that the Secretary of State failed to give effect to a legitimate expectation of consultation. A public body can give rise to a legitimate expectation that it will exercise its powers in a certain manner, either by an explicit promise or by prior conduct. Here, the Secretary of State explicitly promised to consult with those affected by the flooding, thereby giving rise to a legitimate expectation which the Secretary of State failed to fulfill. (B) and (C) are incorrect because there is no general duty to consult imposed either by statute or by the common law. (D) is incorrect because, on these facts, there is no evidence of a breach of the rules of natural justice.