Informed Consent and the Competent Patient: Reibl v. Hughes and Benjamin Freedman

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/26

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Flashcards covering informed consent principles, historical background, the landmark Reibl v. Hughes Supreme Court of Canada case, and Benjamin Freedman's moral theory of informed consent.

27 Terms

1
New cards

Which 1947 document established the foundational ethical standards for human experimentation following World War II?

The Nuremberg Code (1947).

2
New cards

What three core ethical principles were articulated in the Belmont Report (1979) regarding research on human subjects?

Respect for persons, beneficence, and justice.

3
New cards

According to Canadian health care theory and law (Kluge), what is the sole limitation placed on a competent patient's freedom to accept or reject treatment?

The only limitation is that the health of other people must not be threatened and the rights of others must not be infringed (e.g., when refusing treatments such as vaccination threatens public health).

4
New cards

What four distinct requirements do bioethicists commonly suggest for a patient to exercise informed consent?

Understanding (Cognitive Competence), Competent Values (e.g., Autonomy), Responsibility, and Free Choice or Voluntarism.

5
New cards

How does Vaughn (2017) justify informed consent through the principles of autonomy and beneficence?

Beneficence urges healthcare providers to promote patient welfare, which is achieved because knowledgeable, autonomous patients who choose for themselves advance their own best interests as they themselves conceive them.

6
New cards

How does Vaughn (2017) differentiate informed consent as an ethical ideal versus a legal requirement?

As an ethical ideal, physicians are morally obligated to inform patients about interventions and respect their choices; as a legal requirement, it compels healthcare providers to disclose information and obtain permission before proceeding.

7
New cards

In the landmark Canadian case Reibl v. Hughes, what complications did the plaintiff suffer during or immediately following the surgery?

Reibl suffered a massive stroke that caused permanent paralysis on the right side of his body and impotence.

8
New cards

Why did Reibl testify that he would have postponed the elective surgery had he been properly informed of the risks?

He testified that he would have foregone the surgery until his lifetime retirement pension vested in a year and a half, preferring a shorter, normal life over a longer life with severe disability.

9
New cards

What monetary damages did the trial judge initially award Reibl, and under which two legal torts?

Monetary damages in the amount of 225,000\ for negligence and battery.

10
New cards

According to the Ontario Court of Appeal, why was the action of battery ruled out as a ground for liability in Reibl v. Hughes?

The action of battery is confined strictly to cases where surgery or treatment has been performed to which there has been no consent at all.

11
New cards

What rule did the Supreme Court of Canada establish regarding whether failure to disclose medical risks constitutes battery or negligence?

Unless there has been misrepresentation or fraud to secure consent, a failure to disclose attendant risks, however serious, should go to negligence rather than to battery.

12
New cards

What track record from Dr. Hughes's own surgical experience demonstrated that the disclosure of risk was inadequate in Reibl v. Hughes?

Hughes had experienced 88 to 1010 patient deaths in the 6060 to 7070 operations of that type that he had previously performed.

13
New cards

What misconception held by Reibl regarding the surgical outcome was known to Dr. Hughes but not made plain to the patient?

Reibl had the impression that the surgery would alleviate his persistent headaches and hypertension so he could carry on with his job, but Hughes knew the surgery would not cure the headaches.

14
New cards

What is the distinction between the 'standard of disclosure' and the 'standard of comprehension' identified in Reibl v. Hughes?

The standard of disclosure is what the patient should be told, whereas the standard of comprehension is the level at which information must be pitched so the patient can actually understand it.

15
New cards

What is the subjective standard of comprehension, and why was it considered problematic by the court?

It asks what this particular plaintiff would have done; it unfairly favors the patient because an injured plaintiff suing in hindsight will inevitably testify that they would have declined the surgery.

16
New cards

What is the objective standard of comprehension, and why was it considered problematic by the court?

It asks what a reasonable person would do; it unfairly favors the doctor because a rational person presented with medical statistics would objectively accept a risk of paralysis or death over certain death without surgery.

17
New cards

What is the 'modified objective test' established by the Supreme Court of Canada in Reibl v. Hughes?

It starts with the reasonable person baseline but tailors it to account for the specific circumstances, characteristics, and concerns of the actual patient (e.g., occupation, economic status, pension vesting, age), while excluding irrational beliefs.

18
New cards

How did the ruling in Reibl v. Hughes transform provincial healthcare consent legislation throughout Canada?

It prompted provinces to clarify that informed consent is an ongoing process of information transfer, comprehension, and consent, where a signed form is merely evidence that the process occurred.

19
New cards

In Benjamin Freedman's moral theory, what is the distinction between the negative and positive rights to informed consent?

The negative right is freedom from interference, coercion, and manipulation (what others must not do); the positive right is the duty of others to provide information and recognize valid consent when confronted with it.

20
New cards

What fundamental moral right serves as the source for Freedman's positive right to informed consent?

The fundamental moral right to be treated as a person rather than an object, avoiding the denial of a person's humanity by ignoring them or declaring that they do not count.

21
New cards

Why does Benjamin Freedman oppose a blanket moratorium on medical experimentation involving prisoners?

He argues that society has a moral responsibility to investigate conditions for valid consent and that excluding prisoners denies them human respect and the altruistic opportunity to serve mankind.

22
New cards

Why does Freedman reject 'fully informed consent' as a reductio ad absurdum?

Requiring a subject to know all minutiae and conceivable sequelae would necessitate a mini-course in medicine, implying absurdly that only medical students or graduate life-science students could participate in research.

23
New cards

What is 'ignorant consent' according to Benjamin Freedman, and in what context is it common?

A valid consent where a patient chooses to remain uninformed about technical details and delegates decision-making power to the physician as their agent (giving carte blanche) to effect a cure.

24
New cards

Why does Freedman argue that informing the patient is not a fundamental requirement of valid consent?

He argues that the provision of information is derivative from the primary requirement that the consent must be the expression of an autonomous, responsible choice.

25
New cards

How does Benjamin Freedman define a 'responsible individual' in the context of informed consent?

An individual who typically makes choices based on reasons, remains open to rational argument, and is capable of formulating, carrying through, and living with the consequences of a life-plan.

26
New cards

Under Freedman's theory of voluntarism, when does an offered reward constitute duress rather than a free choice?

When the reward merely restores basic conditions of rights and freedoms (moral subsistence level) to which the person is entitled but has been unjustly deprived of (such as safety, basic education, or minimal healthcare).

27
New cards

What are the three recognized exceptions to the requirement to obtain informed consent?

Incapacitated (incompetent) patients, life-threatening emergencies with inadequate time to obtain consent, and voluntary waived consent.