1/122
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Employment at Will
an employer can fire an employee or an employee can quit at any time and for any reason as long as it is not an illegal reason
US is the only country with Employment at Will
—> 0 job security because can be fired for any or no reason
Employees not subject to employment at will
employment contract
public employees
unionized workers
Employment at Will: Employment Contracts
negotiate terms: reasons for termination and/or protections upon termination (ex. severance pay or notice)
Employment at Will: Public Employees
employees who work under civil service/merit system
provides tenure
requires just cause for termination
guaranteed an administrative proceeding to determine just cause
Employment at Will: Unionized Workers
requires just cause for termination
administrative hearing to determine just cause
Wrongful Discharge Laws
Public Policy
Implied Contract
Implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing
*Key: contract law + torts
Wrongful Discharge Laws: Public Policy Exception
refusing to perform an illegal or unethical act
exercising a statutory right
performing a statutory obligation
Whistleblower stats – Both Fed/State
Petermann v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters (1959)
(CA) established the public policy exception to the at-will employment doctrine, creating a civil cause of action for wrongful termination when an employee is fired for refusing to commit an illegal act
Kelsay v. Motorola, Inc. (1978)
(IL) first case to allow punitive damages for wrongful termination
created cause of action for wrongful termination when employee is fired for exercising statutory right (filing for worker’s comp)
Wieder v. Skala (1992)
(NY) established cause of action for wrongful termination when employee is fired for performing a statutory obligation (lawyer reporting another’s misconduct)
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002
Federal act which protects employees of publicly traded companies from wrongful termination and retaliation when they report suspected financial fraud, securities violations, or unethical corporate conduct
makes firing a crime
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (2010)
Federal act which protects corporate whistleblowers from retaliation when reporting securities violations
Wrongful Discharge Laws: Implied Employment Contracts
Employer + employee’s conduct can be found to imply a contract which promises job security or specific termination rules
Foley v. Interactive Data Corp. (1988)
created implied employment contract exception to at will termination
Wrongful Discharge Laws: Implied Employment Contracts: Factors
length of service
no prior criticism
regular promotions/raises
assurances made by employer of continued employment for good performance
Woolley v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc. (1985)
example of case where there was found to be an implied contract from an employee manual
employee handbook is essentially a unilateral offer to its entire workforce just by distributing the manual
Wrongful Discharge Laws: Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing
addresses bad faith terminations and terminations that violate the spirit of employment relationships (“hail mary”)
Fortune v. National Cash Register Co. (1977)
example of breach of implied covenant of good faith when employee fired to avoid paying earned commission
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Objectives:
protect workers by placing ceiling on number of hours worked
place floor under wages —> minimum wage
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Employers covered by act
employers engaged in interstate commerce
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Protections
child labor laws prohibiting: most types of work (with some exceptions)
set maximum of 40 hours per week before paid overtime (1.5x regular wage)
established minimum wage
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Protections for 14 + 15 year olds
any non hazardous occupation w/ 2 restrictions:
number of hours per day
number of days per week
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Protections for 16-18 year olds
any non hazardous occupation with no time limit
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) (1938): Minimum wage
originally $0.25, now $7.25 as of 2009
30 states have minimum wage above federal, 5 do not have (differ to federal), 2 have minimum wage below federal (federal takes precedent)
exceptions: workers under 20 years old, certain student workers and waiters with tips
Glatt v. Fox Searchlight Pictures (2015)
federal court case that created a new legal test to decide if unpaid interns should be paid like regular employees
moved from Department of Labor’s very rigid 6 factor test —> Primary Beneficiary Test
Primary Beneficiary Test
factors:
no expectation of compensation
training provided by employer
integration with formal education
accommodates academic commitments
compliments rather than displaces paid work
Equal Pay Act of 1963
amended FLSA to prohibit gender based pay discrimination
Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA): Employers covered
private employers who engage in interstate commerce and have 50+ employees within a 75 mile radius of worksite
all public agencies
all educational agencies (public + private)
Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA): Protections
up to 12 weeks medical leave per year for any serious health conditions (including spouse, child or parents’)
employer must continue to provide health benefits if they already do so
employer must guarantee that employee may return to prior/comparable job when return + cannot be retaliated against
*employers do not have to pay employees on leave (unless in state with statute requiring)
OSHA (1970)
Employers must provide a workplace "free from recognized hazards" likely to cause death or serious physical harm.
OSHA: meaning of “recognized hazards”
danger employer knew about or should have known about given the state of industry knowledge
SeaWorld of Florida, LLC v. Perez (D.C. Cir. 2014
court held that exposing trainers to close contact with killer whales was a recognizable danger, so SeaWorld was in violation of OSHA
OSHA Issues That Show Up in an Office Environment
ergonomics
indoor air quality
workplace violence prevention
emergency action plans
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Injury/Illness Logs
Required for employers with 10+ employees
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Fatality Reporting
report to OSHA within 8 hours
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Severe Injury Reporting
report within 24 hours
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Annual Summary Posting
post previous year’s injury/illness summary
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Record Retention
keep on file for 5 years
OSHA Recordkeeping + Reporting: Anti-Retaliation
cannot discriminate against employees for reporting injuries
OSHA Penalties for Non-Compliance
serious/other than serious violations: up to $16,550 per violation
failure to abate: up to $16,550 per day beyond deadline
willful or repeated violations: up to $165,514 per violation
willful violation causing a worker’s death: criminal misdemeanor exposure - up to $250,000 for individuals/$500,000 for corporations + up to 6 mo prison (up to 12 mo for second offense)
***Beyond the fins: Citations are public record —> can spike insurance premiums, cost government contracts, damage company’s ability to hire
Secretary of Labor v. Megawest Financial, Inc. (OSHRC ALJ 1995)
first fully litigated case involving workplace violence addressed under the General Duty Clause of OSHA
Held that risk of criminal assault by third party against apartment leasing office staff did not constitute a “recognized hazard”
Secretary of Labor v. Integra Health Management, Inc. (OSHRC 2019)
ruled for the first time that OSHA General Duty Clause obligates employers to protect workers from third-party workplace violence
Employer know of danger + lack of action —> liable for employee death
Workers Compensation Laws: History
before law, employee injured on the job had to sue employer for negligence to get award
often did not work because Employer had many defenses:
Fellow Servant Rule: Employer not liable if coworkers’ negligence caused the injury
Contributory Negligence: if employee had any fault in the injury the employer was not liable
assumption of risk: voluntarily assumed workplace risks that were known part of job
Ives v. South Buffalo Railway Co. (N.Y. 1911)
Found NY’s first workers’ comp law passed in 1910 unconstitutional because imposed liability on employer without proof of fault which is tantamount to taking property without due process
New York Central Railroad Co. v. White (1917)
upheld 1913 workers comp rule (which NY state constitution was amended to explicitly authorize) —> validated workers’ comp nationwide
1911 Compromise
employees got fair, prompt medical treatment + compensation for injuries without having to prove fault on the part of the employer
trade off: strict liability —> no punitive + attorney’s fee awards because no court
employer got fixed, predictable liability + capped payouts set by statute
Workers’ Compensation Requirements
injury must:
be accidental
arise out of + occur in the course of employment
Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. v. Cardillo (D.C. Cir. 1940)
held that as long as an employee is the victim rather than the aggressor, doesn’t matter if a fight or horseplay was really about work, instead job put employee in the room with that coworker
Wiseman v. Industrial Accident Commission (Cal. 1956)
created traveling employee doctrine: employee traveling for work is considered in course of employment during the ENTIRE trip
Workers’ Comp: Benefits
medical expenses
lost wages
death benefits
vocational rehab
Workers Comp: Exceptions
employee can bypass workers’ comp entirely and sue if the employer intentionally created the conditions that caused the harm or if the employer acted with reckless disregard for employee safety
Social Security: (FICA) Fed Insurance Contributions Act
Government assured supplemental income for retirees, their survivors and the disabled
Medicare
federal health insurance program for retirees + people with specific disabilities
funded by FICA
Pension
employer promises to pay employee monthly sum when they retire after a certain number of years at the company
amount is determined by final salary and number of years at the company
right to pension has to vest
Tax Deferred Savings Accounts
retirement account where contributions are made with pre-tax dollars, allowing your investments to grow without annual income taxes until you withdraw the money in retirement
Benefit of Tax Deferred Savings Account > Pension
employee has the power to invest
savings grow without tax liability until the employee is ready to withdraw money from the account
vests immediately
account follows employee when they change jobs
ERISA: EE Retirement Income Security Act 1974
regulations set up to protect employees’ investments:
prohibits conflicts of interest
imposes certain fiduciary standards
requires certain record keeping
requires certain disclosures
provides for oversite
Unemployment Insurance
government assured short term income for workers who lose job for economic difficulties (layoffs NOT firing or leaving of own will)
Requirements for Unemployment Insurance
employee must have lost job for economic difficulties
must be ready to work —> cannot turn down a job and must be actively trying to get a new job
Important Facts About Unemployment Insurance
federal law provides the general guidelines, standards and requirements for the program
state laws actually govern the administration of the program
system funded by FUTA (Federal Unemployment Tax Act)
HIPPA
keeps individual’s medical information private
HIPPA: Requirements for Employers
employee medical records must be kept separate from employee’s personnel file
can only share when legally required
COBRA
mandates that employer must continue to offer group health insurance coverage to employees who leave
COBRA: Availability
employees who leave for ANY reason (including layoff, leaving of own will, firing)
widows of employees who die
ex-spouses of employee
COBRA: Coverage
up to 18 months after employee leaves (up to 36 months for widows)
COBRA: Exceptions
if employer terminates the policy
COBRA: Cost of Insurance
Employee pays premium + administrative fee
Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act 2010 (Obamacare)
protections:
prohibits denial of coverage for preexisting conditions + cancellation of coverage for technical mistakes
allows young adults under 26 to be covered by parents’ health insurance
ended lifetime limits + most annual limits on care
provides access to recommended preventive services without costs
Medicare patients get 50% discount on name brand drugs
small businesses get tax credits to assist in providing insurance benefits to employees
states can receive federal matching funds for expanding eligibility to low income individuals + families for healthcare coverage
devoted fund to preventing Medicare + healthcare fraud
additional funding for constructing community health centers + to support public programs for public health
insurance companies must spend at least 85% of all premium dollars collected on benefits and quality improvement or rebate customers
states can require insurance companies to justify their premium increases to be eligible to participate in new health insurance exchange
ACA Premium Tax Credit
lowers monthly health insurance costs when you buy specific plan
available to people who earned 100-400% of federal poverty level ($32,150 - $128,600)
expired at end of 2025
American Rescue Plan Act (2021)
eliminated 400% cliff entirely —> set eligibility based on % of income
Inflation Reduction Act (2022)
extended subsidies from American Rescue Plan Act to the end of 2025
Essential Health Benefits
health plans are required to cover a set of essential health benefits:
ambulatory patient services (such as visiting doctor’s office)
ER + ambulance service
hospitalization
maternity + newborn care
mental health + substance use disorder services
prescription drugs
rehabilitative + habilitative services + devices
laboratory services
preventative + wellness services + chronic disease management
pediatric services (including oral + vision care)
Equal Pay Act: History
events that led to the act being passed:
WWII —> more women worked while men were at war but paid much less than men
Civil Rights Movement
Feminist Movement —> “The Feminine Mystique” published in 1963 highlighted challenges for women
Equal Pay Act: Protections
prohibits discrimination based on sex when employees performing jobs requiring equal skill, effort, responsibility + performed under similar work environments
Equal Pay Act: Process
direct or through EEOC (equal employment opportunity commission)
plaintiff must identify a comparable male employee who makes more for performing equal work
Equal Pay Act: Problems
difficult to find a man who performs comparable job
difficult to know what coworkers make
minor differences in working conditions can be used to defeat claim
Equal Pay Act: Affirmative Defenses
Seniority System: must be applied uniformly to all employees and cannot be manipulated to cover up discriminatory practices
Merit System: if employer can show male consistently outperforms in measurable tasks, can justify pay difference
system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production
differential based on any factor other than sex
Corning Glass Works v. Brennan (1965)
defended pay difference by a factor other than sex: market forces + greater bargaining power of men
court found this NOT to be a justification
County of Washington v Gunther (1981)
Title VII (which covers all employment discrimination) case which found employer in violation
Boyer v US (2024)
Federal circuit had to take a position on prior salary for 1st time —> found insufficient as a sole factor other than sex
Court Positions on Prior Salary Alone as Factor Other Than Sex
1,2,6,9,10,11 + federal circuit —> all skeptical/hostile
7+8 —> permissive
SCOTUS has not accepted a case on issue yet
Remedies for violating EPA Act
back pay
potentially punitives
potentially liquidated damages
injunction - enjoins employer from further unlawful conduct
Lily Leadbetter Fair Pay Act (2009)
Leadbetter argued that the statute of limitations for discrimination should start when the discrimination is discovered rather than at the time of the last discriminatory act (paycheck)
Supreme court did not agree, so Obama signed bill to change statute of limitations to begin with discovery
Paycheck Fairness Act 2008
act (which was never passed) to address judicially created loophole
required factor other than sex to:
be based a bona fide factor (education, training, experience)
be job-related to the position
be consistent with business necessity
defense will not apply if employee can demonstrate an alternative practice exists that would serve the same business purpose without producing a pay differential and the employer has refused to adopt the alternative
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII)
largest scope employment discrimination act because even extends to hiring
created U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC): a federal government agency that enforces laws making it illegal to discriminate against a job applicant or employee
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Scope
all employers who conduct interstate commerce
employment agencies
labor unions
state + local government agencies
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Requirements
Protected Class member
Adverse Employment Action
Discriminatory Motive
Filing a Charge with the EEOC
EEOC Investigation and Right-to-Sue Notice: if EEOC does not want to file complaint on behalf, will provide Right-to-Sue Notice giving 90 days to sue independently
Types of Title VII Claims
Disparate Treatment: Intentional
Disparate Impact: Unintentional - facially neutral policy that has discriminatory effect in practice
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Protected Classes
race, color, national origin, religion, gender/sex, pregnancy
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Disparate Treatment Case
STAGE 1: Plaintiff must establish that he/she:
belongs to a protected class.
was qualified for the position
suffered an adverse employment action
and similarly situated employees outside the protected class were treated more favorably
STAGE 2: ER may establish a legally permissible reason for not hiring Plaintiff
Bona Fide Occupational Qualification (“BOFQ”)
STAGE 3: EE Rebuttal
argues employer’s defense is a pretext for discrimination in an attempt to disguise it
Bona Fide Occupational Qualification (“BOFQ”)
affirmative defense for disparate treatment: employer can hire based on protected characteristic if it is reasonably necessary to normal operation of the business
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Religious Discrimination
Stage 1: plaintiff must establish sincere religious belief that conflicts with job requirement
employer must accommodate OR
Stage 2: Employer must show could not reasonably accommodate the religious belief without undue hardship
Stage 3: Employee challenges whether Employer would suffer undue hardship
Groff v Dejoy (2023)
case determined what undue hardship means under Title VII’s religious accommodation provision + challenged precedent of “de minimus cost” (anything more than a negligible cost)
Changed the precedent to an accommodation which creates substantial hardship because prior standard did not really protect religious beliefs
Phillips v Martin Marietta Corp (1971)
1st Supreme Court Case to deal with Title VII sex discrimination
ruled cannot have different hiring standards for men and women
Price Waterhouse v Hopkins (1989)
1st Supreme Court case to deal with stereotypes as sex discrimination
ruled that employer cannot penalize someone for not conforming to a stereotype
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Pregnancy Discrimination
1978: amended to include pregnancy as protected class
International Union v Johnson Controls (1991)
policy to not hire fertile women struck down by court because decisions about the welfare of future children belong to the employees themselves not their employers
Young v UPS (2015)
ruled that it was discriminatory to have a policy that treats nonpregnant workers different than pregnant workers with regards to accommodations
Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII): Disparate Impact Tests
Pool of Applicants Test: % of protected class employees in employer’s workforce doesn’t reflect the % of qualified protected class workers in the relevant labor market
Selection Rate Test: comparison of rates at which employer hires, retains, and promotes protected class members v. non class members
Griggs v Duke Power Company (1971)
question: does general intelligence test + high school diploma requirement violate Title VII even without proof of discriminatory intent?
held: DOES violate Title VII because intent is not considered only IMPACT —> no business necessity for policy + discriminatory effect