1/178
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Situational (Contingency) Approach
Effective leadership depends on matching the leadership approach to the demands of the situation. There is no single best leadership style.
Example: A new employee needs detailed instructions, while an experienced employee can work independently.
Fiedler's Contingency Theory
Leadership effectiveness depends on matching a leader's relatively fixed leadership style with the amount of control the situation gives them.
Example: A task-oriented leader may perform especially well during a crisis when clear direction is needed.
What are Fiedler's two leadership styles?
Task-oriented
Relationship-oriented.
Fiedler's Leadership — Task-Oriented
Focuses on completing tasks, achieving goals, and getting results.
Example: A manager prioritizes meeting deadlines.
Fiedler's Relationship-Oriented Leadership Style
Focuses on building relationships, trust, and cooperation.
Example: A manager prioritizes employee morale and teamwork.
How does Fiedler determine leadership style?
Through the Least Preferred Coworker (LPC) scale, which measures how positively a leader describes their least preferred coworker.
What does a low LPC score indicate
Task-oriented leadership.
The leader evaluates their least preferred coworker relatively negatively.
What does a high LPC score indicate?
Relationship-oriented leadership.
The leader evaluates their least preferred coworker relatively positively.
Fiedler's three contingency variables
Leader-member relations
Task structure
Position power
Fiedler's Contingency Variable — Leader-Member Relations
The degree of trust, confidence, and respect followers have for their leader.
Example: Employees trust their manager's decisions.
Fiedler's Contingency Variable — Task Structure
The degree to which tasks are clearly defined and organized.
High structure: Clear instructions and procedures.
Low structure: Unclear tasks with multiple possible solutions
Example: Following a detailed checklist is highly structured.
Fiedler's Contingency Variable — Position Power
The amount of formal authority a leader has over hiring, firing, promotions, discipline, and rewards.
Example: A manager has the authority to promote employees.
Fiedler — High Situational Control
Occurs when leader-member relations are good, task structure is high, and position power is strong.
Example: A trusted manager oversees clearly defined tasks and has authority over employees.
Best Leadership Style for High or Low Control
Task-oriented leadership
Best Leadership Style for Moderate Control
Relationship-oriented
Does Fiedler recommend changing leadership styles?
No. Fiedler views leadership style as relatively fixed, so effectiveness improves by matching the leader to the situation or changing the situation.
Example: Assigning a task-oriented manager to a highly structured department.
Situational Leadership II (SLII)
Leaders adjust their directive and supportive behaviors based on followers' development levels.
Example: A manager gives detailed instructions to a beginner but independence to an experienced employee.
SLII — Two Leadership Behaviors
Directive behavior
Supportive behavior
SLII Leadership Behavior— Directive Behavior
Giving instructions, setting goals, explaining tasks, and monitoring work.
Example: A manager tells an employee exactly how to complete an assignment.
SLII Leadership Behavior — Supportive Behavior
Listening, encouraging, praising, and involving followers in decisions.
Example: A manager encourages an employee who lacks confidence
SLII — Two Factors Determining Follower Development
Competence
Commitment
Factors Determining Follower Development - Competence
A follower's knowledge, skills, and ability to complete a task.
Example: An experienced employee knows how to perform their job.
Factors Determining Follower Development - Commitment
A follower's motivation and confidence toward completing a task.
Example: An employee is excited and confident about a project.
Four SLII Leadership Styles
S1 — Directing
S2 — Coaching
S3 — Supporting
S4 — Delegating
S1: Directing
High directive and low supportive behavior. The leader gives specific instructions and closely supervises work.
Example: Teaching a new employee step by step.
S2: Coaching
High directive and high supportive behavior. The leader gives instructions while also encouraging the follower.
Example: Helping a frustrated employee learn a difficult task.
S3: Supporting
Low directive and high supportive behavior. The leader listens, encourages, and involves followers rather than giving detailed instructions.
Example: Reassuring a skilled employee who doubts their abilities.
S4: Delegating
Low directive and low supportive behavior. The leader allows capable and motivated followers to work independently.
Example: An experienced employee manages a project without constant supervision.
SLII — Four Follower Development Levels
D1 — Low competence, high commitment
D2 — Some competence, low commitment
D3 — Moderate to high competence, variable commitment
D4 — High competence, high commitment
D1: Enthusiastic Beginner
Low competence and high commitment. The follower is motivated but lacks experience.
Example: A new employee is excited but does not know how to perform the job.
Best match: S1 — Directing.
D2: Disillusioned Learner
Some competence but low commitment. The follower has learned some skills but becomes discouraged.
Example: An employee understands the basics but gets frustrated.
Best match: S2 — Coaching.
D3: Capable but Cautious Contributor
Moderate to high competence but variable commitment. The follower has skills but may lack confidence or motivation.
Example: An experienced employee doubts their decisions.
Best match: S3 — Supporting.
D4: Self-Reliant Achiever
High competence and high commitment. The follower is skilled, confident, and motivated.
Example: An experienced employee completes tasks independently.
Best match: S4 — Delegating.
SLII Strengths
Marketplace acceptance
Practicality
Prescriptive focus
Leader flexibility
Follower focus
SLII Strength — Marketplace Acceptance
The model is widely recognized and used by organizations.
Example: Companies use SLII in leadership training.
SLII Strength — Practicality
The model is easy to understand and apply in real workplaces.
Example: A manager can quickly identify how much guidance an employee needs.
SLII Strength — Prescriptive Focus
The model tells leaders which leadership behaviors to use in different situations.
Example: A manager uses directing behavior with a beginner.
SLII Strength — Leader Flexibility
Encourages leaders to adjust their behavior depending on followers' needs.
Example: A manager coaches one employee but delegates to another.
SLII Strength — Follower Focus
Recognizes that followers have different abilities and motivation levels and should be treated accordingly.
Example: A beginner receives more guidance than an experienced employee.
SLII Criticisms
Limited research supporting assumptions
Unclear development levels
Weak evidence for effectiveness prescriptions
Failure to account for demographic variables
SLII Criticism — Limited Research
There is not enough strong research supporting the model's assumptions.
SLII Criticism — Unclear Development Levels
Competence and commitment can be difficult to measure or classify accurately.
Example: An employee may be confident in one task but not another.
SLII Criticism — Weak Evidence for Prescriptions
Research does not consistently prove that matching leadership styles to development levels produces better results.
SLII Criticism — Demographic Variables
The model does not adequately account for factors such as age, education, or experience.
Leader-Member Exchange (LMX) Theory
Leadership focuses on the quality of individual relationships between leaders and followers.
Example: A manager has different levels of trust with different employees.
LMX — Dyadic Relationship
A one-on-one relationship between a leader and a follower.
Example: The relationship between a supervisor and one employee
LMX — Vertical Dyad Linkages
The original term used to describe individual leader-follower relationships in LMX Theory.
Example: A manager develops a separate working relationship with each employee.
LMX — Two Types of Relationships
In-group
Out-group
LMX — In-Group
Followers who develop high-quality relationships with their leader and often take on responsibilities beyond their formal job duties.
Example: An employee volunteers for special projects.
LMX — Out-Group
Followers whose relationships with their leader are based mainly on formal job responsibilities.
Example: An employee completes assigned work and goes home.
Factors Influencing In-Group and Out-Group Formation
Individual differences, such as personality
Willingness to negotiate additional responsibilities
Nature of the reciprocal work relationship
Benefits Received by In-Group Members
More information
More influence
More confidence
More concern from leaders
Typical Behaviors of In-Group Members
They tend to be more dependable, involved, and communicative.
Example: An employee regularly volunteers to help their manager.
Typical Behaviors of Out-Group Members
They generally complete their formal job responsibilities without taking on additional roles.
Example: An employee comes to work, does their assigned tasks, and leaves.
Early LMX Studies — Main Focus
Examined differences between in-group and out-group relationships.
Example: Studying why some employees receive more attention and opportunities than others.
Later LMX Studies — Main Focus
Examined how high-quality leader-member relationships relate to organizational effectiveness and positive outcomes.
Example: Studying whether employees with strong manager relationships perform better.
Positive Outcomes Associated with High-Quality LMX
Less turnover
Better work assignments
Better performance evaluations
More promotions
Higher job performance
Greater commitment
Higher job satisfaction
Greater participation
Faster career progress
LMX — Leadership Making
A prescriptive process that encourages leaders to develop high-quality relationships with all followers.
Leadership Making — Three Phases
Phase 1 — Stranger
Phase 2 — Acquaintance
Phase 3 — Partner
Leadership Making — Phase 1: Stranger
Scripted roles, one-way influence, low-quality exchanges, and self-interest.
Example: A new employee follows instructions without much interaction with their manager.
Leadership Making — Phase 2: Acquaintance
Tested roles, mixed influence, medium-quality exchanges, and concern for self and others.
Example: A manager tests an employee with new responsibilities.
Leadership Making — Phase 3: Partner
Negotiated roles, reciprocal influence, high-quality exchanges, and group interests.
Example: A manager and employee trust each other and make decisions together.
Two Ways LMX Works
Descriptively
Prescriptively
LMX — Descriptive Approach
Explains how in-groups and out-groups develop and how their differences affect organizational effectiveness and fairness.
Example: Some employees receive more opportunities because they have closer relationships with their manager.
LMX — Prescriptive Approach
Leaders should try to build strong, trusting relationships with every employee.
Example: A manager gives every employee opportunities for additional responsibilities.
LMX — Six Strengths
Accurately describes in-groups and out-groups
Focuses on dyadic relationships
Emphasizes communication
Warns about potential bias
Supported across cultures
Supported by extensive research
LMX Strength — Realistic Workplace Relationships
Recognizes that leaders naturally develop different relationships with employees.
LMX Strength — Dyadic Relationships
Focuses on individual leader-follower relationships rather than treating all followers the same.
LMX Strength — Communication
Emphasizes communication as essential to developing effective leadership relationships.
LMX Strength — Bias Awareness
Encourages leaders to recognize potential favoritism and unequal treatment.
LMX Strength — Cross-Cultural Support
Research across different cultures has found similar patterns in leader-member relationships.
LMX Strength — Research Support
A large body of research connects high-quality LMX to positive organizational outcomes.
LMX — Four Criticisms
Fairness concerns
Unclear relationship-building process
Limited explanation of contextual factors
Measurement disagreements
LMX Criticism — Fairness
In-groups and out-groups can create unequal treatment or favoritism.
Example: A manager gives special opportunities only to favored employees.
LMX Criticism — Unclear Relationship-Building Process
The theory does not fully explain exactly how leaders should develop high-quality relationships.
LMX Criticism — Contextual Factors
The theory does not adequately explain how workplace or situational factors influence leader-member relationships.
LMX Criticism — Measurement
Researchers disagree about the best way to measure the quality of leader-member exchanges.
Four Challenges That Make Teams Important
Globalization
Competition
Specialization
Information Age
Teams — Globalization
Organizations operate and compete across countries, increasing the need for collaboration.
Example: Employees in different countries coordinate a product launch.
Teams — Competition
Organizations must improve performance and develop specialized capabilities to compete.
Example: A company uses a team to develop a better product than competitors.
Teams — Specialization
Different employees develop expertise in specific areas and must combine their work.
Example: Marketing and finance specialists collaborate on a project.
Teams — Information Age
Organizations must manage increasingly complex information and technology.
Example: A technology company needs programmers, designers, and analysts.
Three Types of Decisions in the Team-Use Framework
Routine decisions
Adaptive decisions
Innovative decisions
Team-Use Framework — Routine Decisions
Familiar problems with known and tested solutions.
Example: Processing a standard customer refund.
Team-Use Framework — Adaptive Decisions
Problems that require modifying or adjusting existing solutions.
Example: Changing a marketing campaign when sales decline.
Team-Use Framework — Innovative Decisions
New or unclear problems requiring creative and untested solutions.
Example: Developing a completely new product.
When Are Teams Most Appropriate?
Teams are especially useful when problems and solutions are complex, uncertain, or innovative and require multiple skills.
Example: A company forms a team to develop a new product.
Work Team
An interdependent group of people with complementary skills, shared goals, and mutual responsibility for results.
Example: Employees from different specialties work together to complete a project.
Four Types of Teams
Functional work teams
Problem-solving work teams
Multidisciplinary/cross-functional teams
Self-managing work teams
Functional Work Team
Employees from the same department or functional area working together.
Example: An accounting department.
Problem-Solving Work Team
A team formed to identify, analyze, and solve a specific problem.
Example: Employees investigate why customer complaints increased.
Multidisciplinary/Cross-Functional Team
Employees from different departments or areas of expertise working toward one goal.
Example: Marketing, finance, and engineering collaborate on a product launch.
Self-Managing Work Team
A team that has authority to organize and manage much of its own work.
Example: Employees assign their own tasks without daily manager supervision.
Steiner's Group Productivity Equation
Actual Productivity = Potential Productivity − Process Losses + Synergy.
The equation shows that team performance depends on potential productivity, reduced by process losses and increased by synergy.
Note: Synergy was added later and was not part of Steiner's original equation.
Four Components of Steiner's Expanded Equation
Actual productivity
Potential productivity
Process losses
Synergy
Steiner's Equation — Actual Productivity
The amount of work or output a team actually produces.
Steiner's Equation — Potential Productivity
The maximum output a team could produce if its resources and abilities were used effectively.
Steiner's Equation — Process Losses
Productivity lost because of motivation or coordination problems.
Two Types of Process Losses
Motivation losses
Coordination losses
Process Loss — Motivation Losses
Reduced productivity because team members put in less effort.
Example: One member contributes very little to a group project.