1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Gender identities (1)
Gender identity may or may not align with a person’s biological sex.
Gender identity influences how people express themselves through clothing, behaviour and social roles.
Sex has often been viewed as binary (male or female), however modern perspectives recognise a diverse spectrum of gender identities.
Binary Gender Identity (1)
The view that gender only consists of two distinct (binary) groups: man or woman (boy or girl).
In a binary system, social norms, cultural expectations and stereotypes then shape how masculinity and femininity are expressed.
For example, masculine behaviour has historically been associated with traits such as assertiveness and independence, while feminine traits include being gentle and yielding. These beleifs have little basis in fact.
Non - Binary gender identity (1)
Non - binary gender identity describes people whose sense of self does not fit neatly into the traditional categories of man or woman (boy or girl).
People may feel that they are a blend of both genders, neither gender, or that their gender exists outside the traditional binary altogether.
Non-binary people may use a variety of pronouns.
The non-binary view is that gender expression can vary widely and may not correspond with conventional ideas of masculinity or femininity.
Gender Fluid (1)
Gender fluid refers to a gender identity that is not fixed and may change over time.
A person who is gender fluid might feel more masculine on some days, more feminine on others, or might shift between different identities depending on context or internal feelings.
Being gender fluid does not imply confusion or indecision. Rather, it reflects a flexible and dynamic relationship with gender.
Like non-binary individuals, people who are gender fluid may present themselves in diverse ways and may choose pronouns that reflect their fluid experience of gender.
Measuring Gender: Bem sex role inventory (1974) (1)
Sandra Bem was a feminist scholar and a very involved with the sexual liberation movement of the 1970’s and argued that gender flexibility was important for psychological health.
suggested that traditional gender roles were restrictive for both men and women, and that androgyny offered greater flexibility as it allows a person to combine characteristics associated with men and women.
She believed that flexibility is linked to greater psychological well-being, as androgynous people may be better equipped to navigate the varied demands of life.
Measuring Gender: Bem sex role inventory (1974) (2)
Bem developed the BSRI to measure the extent to which individuals identify with culturally defined masculine, feminine and or/neurtral traits.
The test was developed in the 1970’s by asking 100 American undergraduate students to list the traits they found to be socially desirable for each gender - the original list of 200 traits was narrowed down to 60 traits (20masc, 20 fem, 20 neutral)
Individuals who take the test are classified as masculine (high m, low m), feminine, androgynous, or undifferentiated.
Measuring Gender: Bem sex role inventory (1974) (3)
Androgyny is represented by scoring above the median in both masculine and feminine categories. Extremely low scores in both categories are labelled as ‘undifferentiated’
She found that overall more people were androgynous than were at the extremes
Reinforced her argument that we need to move away from the fixation of binary sex’s, and looking at a person instead.
Masculinity and femininity are independent traits, not linked to sex (irresepective), can score high or low on either or both regardless of their sex.
A03 - strength (ahead of its time)
One strength of the BSRI is that it was a groundbreaking approach to the study of gender identity.
Ben’s research challenged the prevailing binary view of gender, which saw masculinity and femininity as mutually exclusive and inherently tied to biological sex.
The BSRI helped to shift psychological thinking towards a more inclusive and flexible model of gender, one that allows for individual variation.
Arguably, it opened the door to later research into non-binary, gender fluid, and gender diverse identities - perspectives that have become increasingly relevant in contemporary gender studies.
This shows that the BSRI made an important contribution to out current understanding of gender identity
A03 - strength (Androgyny and psychological health)
Research has found a positive correlation between androgyny and psychological health, as Bem predicted.
For example Prakash (2020) tested 100 married women in India on masculinity/feminnity and a range of outcome measures related to health: physical health, depression, anxiety and perceived stress.
Masculinity/femininity was measured using the personal atttribute test.Women with high masculinity scores had better health scores, whereas those with high femininity scores had worse health scores
Additionally, two studies of ethnically diverse preadolescent childhren in the southeastern unites states found that androgynous children had mental health advantages, such as higher self esteem, over those who perceived themselves to possess characteristics of only one gender (Pauletti)
This supports the view that androgyny has a psychoprotective effect, because those with a strong sense of masculinity and femininity were better or in terms of their mental health.
A03 - limitation (self awareness)
One limitation of the BSRI is that people may not have insight into their degree of masculinity, femininity or androgyny, self report is not the most valid and reliable test.
Asking people to rate themselves on a questionaire relies on people having an understanding of their personality and behaviour that they may not necessarily have.
Gender is a social construct which may be open to interpretation.
People might also be either overly aware of existing stereotypes or not, compromising the validity and honesty of their answers. Additionally, the questionaires scoring system is subjective, and peoples application of the 7-point scale may differ.
This suggests that the BSRI may not be an objective, scientific way of assessing masculinity, femininity or androgyny.
Risk of social desirability