1/82
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Misinformation strategy: false experts
Individuals presented as credible authorities
EX. James Taylor saying that wind power does not sustantially reduce emissions
Misinformation strategy: use front groups for information laundering
An industry or organization funds a seperate part from themselves and uses that other party to spread information
EX. Exxon funding Heartland institute who says global warming isn’t anthropogenic
Misinformation strategy: create an echo chamber
Create multiple front groups with the same message
EX. Oil industry funds multiple front groups, making it harder to attack them
Misinformation strategy: create uncertainty
Create messages that say the science is still out on the issue “until we have more information we can’t take action“
EX. Frank Luntz’s uncertainty memo
Motivated reasoning
An individuals propensity to adopt attitude-congruent beliefs and to defend them against novel evidence and arguments
Motivated reasoning causes: ego-defenseve/self-identity protection
When the ego is threatened by new information, the individual will employ a wide variety of strategies to justify rejecting that information.
Fear of seeing self as incompetent: individuals will resist acknowledging a scientific consensus if it will create a sense of incompetence
Fear of losing personal connections/social networks: individuals are motivated to believe claims that reinforce their important interpersonal connections
Motivated reasoning causes: automaticity and affect
Information processing is driven by instantaneous, unconscious responses, including emotions, stereotypes, and attractions
Heuristics: shortcuts that fundamentally shape conscious thought
Link between deliberation and mental bias: the more thorough an individuals thought process is, the more opportunities there are for unconscious and automatic biases to influence judgement. Strategies to shape judgement
Motivated reasoning causes: credibility
Values guide judgement as to whether an individual is an expert. Relies on arguments of competing experts, scientific consensus, appraisals of expertise, signs of an expert’s bias, the expert’s past performance
Motivated reasoning causes: biased assimilation
The tendency to evaluate new information in a way that aligns with one’s preexisting beliefs
Correction strategy: ego/identity affirmation
Buffering the individual against the threat to self by promoting self worth in another domain
align with cultural identity: educational messaging is more effective when the issue is less tied to social identity
Correction strategy: overwhelming evidence
Evidence that leaves little room for doubt
Correction strategy: pluralistic advocacy
Issue is shaped by multiple different perspectives/stakeholders. Promotes coexistence amongst all groups
Correction strategy: attack credibility of source of disinformation
Undermining the audiences’ trust in the outlet spreading false information
Correction strategy: framing
The way information is presented
Correction strategy: accessibililty
How easily a thought comes to mind
Correction strategy: fluency
The ease with which something is perceived and understood
Susceptibility
The likelihood that a threat will occur
Severity
If the threat occurs, how bad it will be
Self efficacy
Can I take action
Response efficacy
Will the action make a difference
How do threat and efficacy predict behavior?
If the threat is deemed significant enough, individuals who believe they have response and self-efficacy will cognitively process information about the risk and adopt behavior to avoid the risk. If the threat is high and efficacy is low, individuals may utilize maladaptive coping strategies.
Internal efficacy
One’s perceived ability to take political action
External efficacy
The belief that the government will respond to political demands
How do internal and external efficacy relate to engaging in political action?
People high in internal and external efficacy are more likely to influence political desicions
What frames did the study focus on?
Environment, public health, national security, economic, secular morality, religious morality, public accountability
How did newspapers differ in discussion of impacts and actions
WSJ was significantly different (less likely to talk about impacts and more likely to talk about actions) than other newspapers. Across the board, news articles were more likely to talk about actions than impacts.
How often were impacts and actions discussed together?
31%
Which newspaper was least likely to talk about present impacts of climate change?
WSJ
Which timing is focused on more?
Present
Which location is focused on more?
United States
Which newspaper was most likely to talk about negative efficacy?
WSJ
What impact frame was focused on most?
Environmental
Which newspaper covered the environmental impact frame the least?
WSJ
Which action frame was focused on most?
Conflict
Which newspaper utilized the Economic-Negative and Conflict frames the most
WSJ
Injunctive norm
What you should do
Descriptive norm
What you see people doing around you
What is meant by keeping injunctive and descriptive norms aligned?
You want them to reinforce each other to avoid contrast effects.
EX. telling people to not litter and showing people littering is contrasting
4 conditions of littering experiment
Clean environment, confederate dropped trash
Clean environment, confederate walked through
Littered environment, confederate dropped trash
Littered environment, confederate walked through
Littering experiment DV
Action- littering vs not littering
What was the main effect of the clean vs. the littered environment?
There was more littering in the littered environment than in the clean environment
In the littered environment condition, how did having high norm salience (model littering) compare to low norm salience (model walked by)?
The least littering occurred when participants saw a model drop trash into a clean environment.
In the clean environment condition, how did having high norm salience (model littering) compare to low norm salience (model walked by)?
The least littering occurred when participants saw a model drop trash into the clean environment.
Why are the two results different
Participants who saw a confederate litter in a clean environment would have their attention drawn to an anti-littering descriptive norm, whereas participants who saw a confederate litter in a littered environment would have their attention drawn to a pro-littering descriptive norm.
What is Cialdini’s recommendation on where to focus attention when most of society is acting bad?
Focus on the injunctive norm
What was the suggestion for how to change the iron eyes cody commercial?
Changing the depicted environment from trashed to clean, removing the idea that people do litter
Conditions of petrified wood experiment
Descriptive norm sign: “Many past visitors have removed petrified wood from the park, changing the natural state of the Petrified Forest“ with pictures of visitors taking wood
Injunctive norm sign: “Please don’t remove the petrified wood from the park, in order to preserve the natural state of the Petrified Forest“ with a picture of a visitor stealing wood and a circle and a bar through it
Petrified wood experiment result
The descriptive norm message resulted in significantly more theft than the injunctive norm message
What should you do if good practice is already prevalent?
Draw attention to the descriptive norm- the fact that people are taking part in good practice.
Boomerang effect: Reactance
Individuals perceive themselves as having specific behavioral freedoms. iF these freedoms are threatened or eliminated, individuals will be motivated to reestablish them.
EX. If a man highly values the freedom to smoke, and his wife tells him not to smoke, he may be motivated to smoke more when his wife isn’t there to reestablish his freedom to smoke
Boomerang effect: ironic processing
Humans experience difficulty with not thinking about something they are told to not think about
EX. participants who were told to think of a white bear had more white bear thoughts than people who were told to think of the bear
Boomerang effect: fear control
Cognitions reated to threat override those related to efficacy. Individuals may attempt to reduce the fear by rejecting the message.
EX. people tuning out overwhelming climate change messages
Boomerang effect: observational learning
Receivers of a message that doesn’t specifically identify harmful consequences of a target behavior may encode a message for later use
EX. Viewers may perceive rewards in social influence messages, such as anti-drug ads. If a PSA portrays a drug user as thin and beautiful, it may concurrently communicate certain rewards with using drugs.,
Boomerang effect: internalizing attributions
People may discount their intrinsic motivations for engaging in the behavior and instead attribute compliance solely to the possibility of gaining the extrinsic rewards
EX. If people receive a financial incentive to quit, they could perceive earning money (rather than living a healthier life) as their reason for quitting
Boomerang effect: ambiguity reduction
Undesirable constructs may become accessible simply by introducing new concepts into a network of ideas. The newly acquired knowledge may influence the attitudes and behaviors of the individual
EX. When a person sees a movie rating, they attain knowledge about the movie that did not exist before exposure to the rating
Boomerang effect: peripheral processing
If an individual lacks motivation or the ability to process deeply, he more likely processes peripherally and fails to seriously consider arguments presented in the message
EX. A television viewer may not be motivated to process a campaign advertisement that intends to portray an opposing candidate in a negative light. The viewer may pick up on peripheral cues, such as the candidate’s appearance.
Boomerang effect: social norms
As a result of exposure to a strategic message, the receiver deduces that the undesirable behavior being targeted is a social norm
EX. An adolescent female may observe a campaign intending to promote sexual abstinence and deduce that most of her peers must be having sex. The girl may be more likely to engage in sexual behavior.
Imagery for client change engagement: 2 dependent variables
Q-sort for salience/importance and efficacy
What types of images had a strong positive association with feeling that climate change is important
IMPACTS- flood aerial views and ice sheets
What types of images had a strong negative association with feeling that climate change is important
Identifiable people, church congregation
What types of imagery promoted self-efficacy
Energy futures (solar panels, wind farms, electric cars, etc.)
What types of imagery underminded self-efficacy?
Impacts —> hopelessness
What were the conditions?
Imagery: solar panels, climate protest, flooding, smoke, no image
Text: actions only, impacts only, actions and impacts
What variables were measured?
Potential moderator: political party
Mediators: efficacy, issue importance
DV: energy conservation, political action
How did imagery influence perceived efficacy?
Solar>Flooding>Smoke>No image
How did text influence perceived efficacy?
Actions>actions and impacts>impacts
How did political party influence perceived efficacy and issue importance?
Democrats>Indeendents>Republicans
Overall takeaway
Imagery of solutions are great, include actions in text
Greenwashing
Misleading information used to present an environmentally friendly image
Sin: hidden trade off
Product is “green“ based off of a single environmental attribute
EX. paper is made out of X recycled content
Sin: no proof
When a claim cannot be substantiated
EX. shampoo claims no animal testing, no evidence or certification
Sin: vagueness
Poorly defined, likely to be misunderstood
EX. “environmentally friendly“ no definition, not clear what it means
Sin: irrelevance
A claim that is true, but unhelpful. Distracts from finding a truly greener option
EX. CFC automotive cleaner. CFCs have been banned for 30 years, no products are manufactured with it
Sin: lesser of two evils
A green claim that is true within the product category, but risk distracting of the negative impact of the category as a whole
EX. organic cigarettes
Sin: fibbing
A false environmental claim
EX. a dishwasher detergent that claims to be packaged in 100% recycled paper, but is plastic