1/20
Comprehensive vocabulary flashcards reviewing Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 21, and the jurisdictional boundaries of 28 U.S.C. § 1367.
Two-Part Joinder Framework
The foundational analysis requiring every joinder issue to evaluate two distinct legal questions: 1) The Pleading Question (whether the text of the Federal Rule permits or requires adding the claim or party), and 2) The Jurisdiction Question (whether the federal court has Subject Matter Jurisdiction—via an independent basis or Supplemental Jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §1367—and Personal Jurisdiction over any new party).
28 U.S.C. § 1367(b)
A statutory restriction applicable exclusively in cases founded solely on diversity of citizenship (28 U.S.C. §1332) that bars supplemental jurisdiction over claims by plaintiffs against persons made parties under Rules 14, 19, 20, or 24, as well as claims by persons joined as plaintiffs under Rule 19 or intervening as plaintiffs under Rule 24, to prevent plaintiffs from bypassing complete diversity.
Rule 13(a) (Compulsory Counterclaim)
A claim that a pleading must state against an opposing party if it arises out of the same transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the opposing party's claim and does not require adding a party the court cannot reach; it is permanently lost if not raised in the answer.
Rule 13(b) (Permissive Counterclaim)
A claim stated against an opposing party that does not arise out of the same transaction or occurrence as the opposing party's claim; it does not need a connection to the plaintiff's claim, is not lost if omitted, and requires its own independent basis of subject matter jurisdiction (or an overlapping factual connection sufficient for 28 U.S.C. §1367(a)).
"Same Transaction or Occurrence" vs. "Common Nucleus of Operative Fact"
The distinction between Rule 13(a)'s narrower standard—which asks whether claims turn on the same exact facts and evidence—and 28 U.S.C. §1367(a)'s broader constitutional standard—which covers claims that share overlapping facts within the same case and controversy.
Cordero v. Voltaire, LLC
The key case establishing that an employer's fraud counterclaim alleging inflated employee hours arose from the same transaction or occurrence as the employees' Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) overtime claim and was compulsory under Rule 13(a), whereas the employer's theft and conversion counterclaims were not compulsory.
Rule 13(g) (Crossclaims)
A claim asserted against an existing co-party (such as Defendant 1 against Defendant 2) that arises out of the same transaction or occurrence as the original action or a counterclaim, or concerns property at issue in the action; crossclaims are always permissive, never compulsory.
Stacking Claims
The procedural mechanism under Rule 18 where, once a valid claim, crossclaim (under Rule 13(g)), or counterclaim is properly asserted, the asserting party is permitted to join any other completely unrelated claims it has against the opposing party.
Rule 18 (Joinder of Claims)
A rule allowing a party asserting a claim, counterclaim, crossclaim, or third-party claim to join every other claim it has against an opposing party, regardless of whether the claims are related; it does not confer subject matter jurisdiction, meaning each joined claim must independently satisfy jurisdictional requirements.
Rule 14(a) (Impleader)
A procedural device allowing a defending party (acting as a third-party plaintiff) to join a nonparty (third-party defendant) who is or may be liable to it for all or part of the claim asserted against it, shifting liability and avoiding inconsistent adjudications.
Derivative Liability
The essential substantive legal basis required for impleader under Rule 14 (typically indemnity or contribution grounded in substantive state or federal law), operating under the principle that "if I am liable to the plaintiff, you must reimburse me," rather than merely asserting that the third party is solely responsible.
Price v. CTB, Inc.
The key case demonstrating Rule 14 impleader, in which chicken house builder Latco, sued by a farmer for defective construction, was permitted under state indemnity law to implead nail manufacturer ITW on the basis of derivative liability.
Rule 14(a)(3)
The provision permitting an original plaintiff to assert a direct same-transaction claim against a third-party defendant; however, in diversity-only cases, 28 U.S.C. §1367(b) bars supplemental jurisdiction over this claim if the plaintiff and third-party defendant share state citizenship.
Rule 20 (Permissive Joinder of Parties)
The rule allowing multiple plaintiffs to join or multiple defendants to be joined if 1) their claims arise out of the same transaction, occurrence, or series of transactions or occurrences, and 2) any question of law or fact is common to all of them.
Rule 21
The rule governing misjoinder of parties, providing that misjoinder is never grounds for dismissing an entire action; rather, the court may drop or sever improperly joined parties or claims.
Mosley v. General Motors Corp.
The key case applying Rule 20, holding that ten Black and female workers could permissively join in a single action to challenge a company-wide discriminatory culture, satisfying both the same transaction requirement (the shared company-wide policy) and the common question requirement (discrimination).
Rule 19(a)(1) (Required Party)
Step 1 of the required joinder framework, evaluating whether an absent person must be joined because 1) the court cannot accord complete relief among existing parties without them, or 2) the absent person claims an interest such that disposing of the action in their absence impairs their ability to protect it or exposes existing parties to double, multiple, or inconsistent obligations.
Feasible Joinder (Rule 19)
Step 2 of the required joinder framework, which asks whether the court has the power to join the required absent person; joinder is feasible if the absent person can be served (personal jurisdiction exists) and their addition does not destroy subject matter jurisdiction (such as complete diversity).
Rule 19(b) Dismissal Factors
Step 3 of required joinder analysis, applied when joining a required party is not feasible, weighing four factors to decide whether to proceed or dismiss "in equity and good conscience": 1) prejudice to the absent person or existing parties, 2) whether relief can be shaped to lessen prejudice, 3) adequacy of judgment without the person, and 4) availability of an adequate alternative remedy (such as state court) if dismissed.
Temple v. Synthes Corp.
The United States Supreme Court decision holding that joint tortfeasors are permissive parties rather than required parties under Rule 19, meaning a plaintiff suing a medical device manufacturer over broken spinal screws was not required to join the doctor or hospital.
Marvel Characters, Inc. v. Kirby
A copyright dispute wherein the court determined under Rule 19(b) that it could proceed without two absent heirs over whom it lacked personal jurisdiction, because their legal interests were identically aligned with and vigorously defended by the existing family parties, preventing prejudice.