1/6
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Summary of missing shade of blue
Hume asks us to imagine a man that has gone through life having experienced every shade of blue apart from one
If all the shades of blue were lined up together, with a gap for the missing shade, Hume argues most would say that the man could formulate the idea of the missing shade
This is problematic for him as this simple idea has no impression from which it came
What is Hume’s response?
Hume says that this is an idea without an impression, but it is so ‘singular’ that he dismisses it
What are the counter arguments?
But is it really ‘singular’? Surely the same example could be used for a missing pitch in music, sweetness or sourness of food…
Even if it were ‘singular’, it cannot be dismissed. It would still be a counter‐example
What are some other responses?
The missing shade of blue is a complex idea - a combination of different ideas of colour (like a palette mixing paints but in the mind)
You do not really have an idea of the missing shade – we find it hard to accept this because we do have the concept, just not the mental image
Criticism 1- Force and Vivacity
There may be no way to prove that all impressions are more forceful than ideas – what about remembering a roller coaster ride compared to reading Hume!
Even Hume acknowledges that mad people may have more forceful ideas than impressions
The problem is that we may not be able to tell if we are mad or not and it is now generally acknowledged that mental illness is a matter of degree
Criticism 2- Certain Concepts
There are many concepts that seem to be different from Hume’s interpretation of an ‘idea’
Such concepts it seems very difficult to explain how they would be copied
For example, from what impression is ‘justice’ copied? Or Truth? Or beauty? How could these ever be broken down from other complex ideas?
Criticism 3- Language example
It is difficult to see how language derives from impressions
When I say ‘red’ this is not the same as having the impression of red. Does this mean that the word ‘red’ must derive from a different impression than having the experience of red?
It is also difficult to see how we can share ideas if they are internal. How can we know that your ‘red’ is the same as my red?