1/22
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Mens Rea
mental state
The four types mental states (in common law)
Specific, general, malicious/malice, strict liability.
Important to remember
Common-law classifications and MPC mental states are different systems. Do not automatically equate specific intent with purpose or general intent with recklessness.
What is the function of mental states?
1. Distinguishing Between Criminal and Non-criminal Conduct
mental state is tied with our personal, intuitive sense of blameworthiness (e.g. mail carrier delivering anthrax to a government official after a political extremist sends it in the mail; we see the extremist as guilty and the mail man as innocent)
2. Grading Crimes
hierarchy of offenses e.g. murder-manslaughter-criminally negligent homicide; the difference in the three is the mental state
What are the four mental states according to the MPC?
Purposefully
Knowingly
Recklessly
Negligently
Purposefully (MPC)
The defendant had an underlying conscious objective to act/engage in conduct.
Conduct element: Conscious object is to engage in conduct or cause result
Attendant circumstance element: Aware of the attendant circumstances or believes/hopes they exist
Knowingly (MPC)
The defendant is practically certain that the conduct will cause a particular result. (Aware of his conduct).
Conduct element: aware that conduct is of that nature
Attendant circumstance element: aware that such circumstances exist.
Result element: aware that result is practically certain
Recklessly (MPC)
The defendant consciously disregarded a substantial and unjustified risk.
Conscious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk (so must be aware)
Gross deviation from standard of conduct a law abiding citizen in the actor’s situation (subjective test)
Negligently (MPC)
The defendant was not aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk but should have been.
Should have been aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk.
Gross deviation from standard of care of a reasonable person in actor's situation (objective test)
Mistakes of fact are irrelevant
Jury can consider nature, purpose, and circumstances BUT NOT heredity, intelligence, and temperament (keeps test objective)
Four types of common law mental states/crimes?
Specific intent, general intent, malicious, strict liability.
Specific intent crimes (common law)
Person had to desire to commit the act and they desired/intended the result.
Inchoate (unfinished) crimes: solicitation, attempted […], conspiracy.
Theft and property crimes
Intent-to-kill/murder
Voluntary manslaughter: intentional murder in heat of moment; lowers level of culpability
General intent crimes (common law)
Intent to perform the act but don’t intend or have knowledge that the consequences will be the result
battery
rape
kidnapping & false imprisonment
involuntary manslaughter
depraved heart murder
Murder (common law) ?????????????????????
The unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought
Malicious (malice) crimes (common law)
arson and common law murder
Strict liability crimes (common law)
Regulatory
Public welfare
Morality crimes (statutory rape or bigamy)
Selling alcohol to minors
According to the MPC, if a statute requires a certain mental state, can a different mental state be substituted?
Only when it is a higher level of culpability; when a crime requires only a negligence mental state, one can also be convicted with a reckless mental state. However, if a crime requires a knowing mental state, then a reckless mental state will not suffice.
The “other minds” question
Basically, it is the difficulty in determining what is going on inside the mind of another. How do we determine what someone’s
intent is? How do we determine what is going on inside their mind? We can use direct evidence and circumstantial evidence to help us find this out.
Direct evidence
If the factfinder believes the evidence, it establishes the point it is offered to prove (without the necessity of drawing any inferences). (pg. 235 example)
Circumstantial evidence
Requires the use of one or more inferences to prove the point it is offered for. (pg. 235 example)`
What type of evidence is this? Witness saw defendant stab the victim.
Direct evidence (Fact: defendant stabbed the victim.)
What type of evidence is this? Defendant left town after the stabbing. Defendant was washing a bloody knife.
Circumstantial evidence (inference: guilty people often flee) (inference: few innocent reasons to have bloody knife) (fact: defendant stabbed the victim)
Cluster of ideas
When a legislature uses an established common-law term in a statute, courts assume the lawmakers adopted the entire cluster of ideas, history, and legal nuances attached to that word or phrase in the common-law.