1/7
Breakdown of evaluate Carlsson
Intro - Carlsson’s 2000 review article aims (4)
provide evidence for and against dopamine hypothesis
look beyond this at interaction of neurotransmitters such as serotonin, glutamate and GABA
look at specific brain areas with regard to neurotransmitter interactive
produce better drug treatment with less side effects
Intro - procedure - 3 types of study
animal studies using rodents to test neurotransmitter and brain structure functioning
studies on people with acute schizophrenia and remission
research studies using brain scans to investigate psychosis
Findings - glutamate!
He found that low levels of glutamate play role in schizophrenia.
Glutamate failure in cerebral cortex = positive symptoms
Glutamate failure in basal ganglia = negative symptoms
Strength - validity
High validity
Investigated dopamine hypothesis from 50’s which he helped develop
Suggests clozapine can reduce psychotic symptoms by reducing serotonin and dopamine levels
Also considers glutamate possible contributor to schizo
Suggests both hypothesis may be true - Send’t Literautre review (2012) supports this - increases concurrent validity
Additionally, Crippa et al 2015 suggests that other neurotransmitters are linked to psychosis
Issue and debate - developped understanding of how psychology has developed over time, by studying own study from 50s
Weakness - generalisability
Lacks generalisability
Animal studies used do not match target population of people with schizophrenia
Affects the issue and debate of culture, and animal findings do not give anh insight to culture
Lurhman et al 2015 - auditory hallucinations may differ across culture
Although issues w generalisability, has strong applications, findings helped develop better antipssychotics.
Supported by Papanastasious et al (2013) - suggets anto- glutamate anti
psychotics are good for people who do not respond to typical drugs
Strength - reliability
High reliability
lab experiments
PET scans
techniques are controlled and standarised - increases replicability
eg Brier et al 1997 - used pet scans to provide high levels of dopamine is linked to psychosis
Increases scientific credibility
However, secondary data used - initial research may have been flawed, animal studies reduce scientiifc credibility
Weakness - reductionism
Highly reductionist
Only focuses on neurotransmitter interaction (serotonin, glutamate, dopamine)
Ignores other social and genetic causes, perhaps oversimplifying schizo down to bio approach
Although reductionism can be seen as a strength, important characteristic of science
Conclusion - 5 concs - applications - issue and debate
there may be different subpopulations of those with schizophrenia, where schizophrenia is causses by different abnormal levels of neurotransmitters other than just dopamine
This has implications for treatment.
He also concluded that glutamate should be studied to explain schizophrenia, and may explain increased dopamine responsiveness.
increased serotonin activity is found in those with schizophrenia
more focus on other neurotransmitters such as GABA is needed
strong applications, because it is useful in developing better anti-psychotic drugs.
allowed dopaminergic drugs to be improved that have fewer side-effects
research has also led to the development of glutamate antipsychotics which could help people who do not respond well to typical antipsychotics.
issue and debate - literature review has little practical issues in the design and implementation of research, because primary research is not being conducted.