1/24
Marxism and Retribution
explores the relationship between two major perspectives:
Kantian retributivism: People who commit crimes deserve punishment because they are morally responsible for their wrongdoing.
Marxist social analysis: Society is shaped by economic inequality, exploitation, and unequal distributions of power.
central arguments
Retributivism can be morally justified in theory, but may be impossible to apply fairly in societies characterized by significant inequality.
Retributivism
Retributivism argues that punishment is justified because someone who commits a crime deserves to be punished.
Punishment is based on moral responsibility.
People should be punished because they committed wrongdoing.
The punishment should reflect what the individual deserves.
It emphasizes fairness, responsibility, and human dignity.
utalitarianism
Utilitarianism justifies punishment because of the positive consequences it can produce for society.
Three major purposes:
Deterrence: Discouraging people from committing crimes.
Incapacitation: Preventing offenders from committing additional crimes.
Rehabilitation: Helping offenders change their behaviour.
important difference
Retributivism asks: Does this person deserve punishment?
Utilitarianism asks: Will punishing this person benefit society?
Why does Murphy support retributivism in theory?
draws on Kantian philosophy and the idea of human dignity.
argues that people should never be treated simply as tools for achieving social benefits.
believes retributivism respects human dignity because it connects punishment to the individual's own wrongdoing.
agrees with the principle that people should only be punished when they are genuinely responsible for their actions.
main question: What gives the government the moral authority to punish individuals?
He argues that punishment involves coercion because the state restricts people's freedom against their wishes.
This creates a conflict between:
Individual autonomy and freedom.
The state's authority to enforce laws.
Kant and social contract theory
argues that laws can be justified when they are consistent with what rational individuals could reasonably agree to.
The social contract is not necessarily an actual agreement that people historically signed.
Instead, it is a theoretical way of determining whether laws are fair.
social contract theory example
imagine creating rules for society without knowing which social class you would belong to.
You would likely agree to rules that protect everyone equally rather than rules that give one group permanent advantages.
Kant believes laws should reflect a united or general will that everyone could reasonably accept.
This allows the state to restrict certain freedoms without necessarily violating individual autonomy.
Important distinction:
Respecting autonomy does not mean allowing people to do absolutely anything they want.
It means respecting the rules that rational individuals could agree to as fair.
The balance of benefits and burdens
The argument is that:
Everyone benefits from living in an organized society.
Laws protect people and create social stability.
In exchange, individuals are expected to obey those laws and accept certain restrictions on their freedom.
crime and unfair advantage
Someone who commits a crime may be viewed as gaining an unfair advantage because they receive the benefits of society without accepting the responsibility of obeying its rules.
Punishment is therefore supposed to restore the balance between benefits and burdens.
Murphy's Marxist criticism
Murphy believes the balance-of-benefits-and-burdens argument only works if society distributes benefits and burdens fairly.
Murphy argues that many societies are unequal because of unqueal social opportunities
If some people receive fewer benefits from society than others, it becomes difficult to argue that everyone has an equal obligation to obey the rules.
Murphy discusses Bonger's argument that criminality has two primary economic sources.
need and deprivation
greed and selfishness
Bonger also emphasizes the importance of reciprocity.
He argues that strong communities depend on people recognizing their shared humanity and supporting one another.
Without reciprocity, social relationships weaken and criminality may increase.
reciprocity
A relationship based on mutual respect, cooperation, and shared benefits.
Alienation and punishment
Murphy argues that people who are economically and socially excluded may not feel that they belong to the same community as those who enforce the law.
Rational choice
He argues that theories of justice and social contracts often assume individuals are rational, self-interested people who calculate the benefits and costs of their decisions.
However, Murphy questions whether this understanding of human behaviour is accurate.
Murphy’s suggestion about Rawls
Rawls may define rationality in a way that helps guarantee his preferred theory of justice.
Murphy also argues that philosophical theories depend on assumptions about how society actually operates.
Society cannot encourage behaviour and then punish it
Capitalist society encourages competition.
People are encouraged to pursue personal wealth and success.
Self-interest and individual achievement are often rewarded.
However, when these attitudes contribute to criminal behaviour, individuals are punished.
Murphy’s argument about encouraging behaviour
Society cannot encourage greed, selfishness, and competition and then place all the blame on individuals when those attitudes contribute to harmful behaviour.
He also uses the example of soldiers who are trained to view enemies as less than human.
If society encourages these attitudes, how fair is it to place all responsibility on individuals when they act accordingly?
Voluntary acceptance
Social contract theory suggests that people owe obedience to the law because they voluntarily accept the benefits of living under the rule of law.
Murphy challenges the voluntary acceptance argument.
He questions whether individuals who experience poverty, discrimination, and exclusion have genuinely received the benefits necessary to justify this supposed agreement.
conclusions
Retributivism is morally defensible in theory but difficult to justify in practice when society is deeply unequal.
Before society can fairly punish individuals for violating its rules, it must create conditions where people have meaningful access to the benefits and opportunities of society.
Addressing structural inequality is more important than simply changing how punishment is delivered.
rejects the idea that replacing prisons with psychiatric institutions necessarily solves the problem. Both can involve forcing individuals to change their behaviour without addressing the underlying social inequalities.
central takeaway
punishment cannot be fairly justified through reciprocity when society itself fails to provide equal benefits and opportunities. A just punishment system requires a just society.