1/39
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is conformity?
A change in behavior due to perceived influence of others.
What can conformity be due to?
Normative influence, or informational influence
What is normative influence?
The desire to be accepted/approved of. Involves public compliance, without private acceptance of norm.
What is public compliance?
Outwardly conforming while privately disagreeing.
What is informational influence?
The desire to be correct/accurate. Involves private acceptance of norm. Conforming because others are seen as a source of correct information, especially under ambiguity.
What is private acceptance?
The internal change in belief that happens when you’re genuinely persuaded by others’ ideas.
What is a norm?
A rule or standard for what is acceptable, appropriate, or correct in terms of judgement, value, perception, belief, behavior.
What is compliance?
Following orders for someone of authority. Submitting to the demands by someone in a position of power.
What is soft compliance?
Going along with requests
What is hard compliance (obedience)?
Going along with demands/commands — usually to someone in power.
Is information and normative influence a process or a result?
A process
Is private acceptance and public compliance a process or a result?
A result
What are social norms?
Unwritten rules or standards about what behaviors, beliefs, or values are appropriate in a given context. Once internalized, people feel strong pressure to follow them. Norms become automatic.
What conditions increase conformity?
Subject is a solitary dissenter (the only non-confederate)
The behavior is public
People are unsure of a situation, or it’s a crisis (ambiguity opens the door to informational influence and reliance on others)
Group size increases (up to a point)
The group is “important” to the person
People are of lower status
The motivation to be accurate is high (informational influence) and ambiguity is high
What is mindless compliance?
Automaticity in compliance
What is automaticity in compliance?
People follow directives or signs without questioning (“door closed,” “detour,” cones in a parking lot). Often, there is no real authority figure - just a sign or a norm we’ve internalized. We do this much of the time to keep daily life running smoothly.
What are the 2 main compliance techniques?
Foot-in-the-door and door-in-the-face
What is the foot-in-the-door technique?
Small request first, then larger.
What is the door-in-the-face technique?
huge request first that someone would never agree too, then scale back.
Would Milgram’s study happen today?
Modern TV demonstrations replicate Milgram’s core findings. Many still go to maximum shock when a person in authority calmly insists. Ethics block formal replication in universities, but the dynamic remains.
What conditions affect obedience?
Distance of authority, distance of victim, status of authority, status of individual, and the presence of others.
What is the implications of distance of authority on obedience?
Obedience is lower if the experimenter is remote
What is the implications of distance of the victim on obedience?
Obedience is lower if the teacher must place the learner’s hand on a shock plate
What is the implications of status of authority on obedience?
A low-prestige setting elicits less obedience
What is the implications of status of the individual on obedience?
Higher-status people resist more
What is the implications of the presence of others on obedience?
If peers refuse, obedience drops
What are the implications of Milgram’s shock study?
It is not about “sadistic” individuals, as that is a fundamental attribution error. It highlights the banality of evil.
What are the ethical implications of Milgram’s shock study?
It puts stress on participants, so we can no longer replicate it formally.
Does Milgram’s shock study have external validity?
No, it does not.
What are other factors of group contexts?
Unanimity & cohesion, public vs. private, prior commitment, and novelty/ambiguity
What is unanimity & cohesion?
Conformity is harder to resist if everyone else conforms. You don’t want to stand out from everybody else.
What is the effect of public vs. private on conformity?
Public responding boosts conformity, while private responding lowers conformity.
What is the effect of prior commitment on conformity?
Once you commit to something publicly, you rarely switch or go higher/lower
What is the effect of novelty/ambiguity on conformity?
Greater uncertainty leads to more informational influence. It wasn’t clear whether or not the learner was actually being harmed, so they ended up relying on the experimenter.
What are individual and cultural aspect differences that come with conformity?
Gender, personality (agreeableness and conscientiousness), individualist vs. collectivist, and injunctive vs. descriptive norms
What are the gender differences in conformity?
Women conform/comply more in many studies
What are the effects of personality differences in conformity?
Those higher in agreeableness and conscientiousness are more likely to conform or obey.
What are the differences in conformity between individualist vs. collectivist societies?
Collectivist cultures emphasize group harmony, leading to higher conformity
What are the effects of injunctive vs. descriptive norms?
“should” vs. “actually do.” People often follow descriptive cues (what others actually do)
What do the results of the studies on conformity tell us about human nature?
We are hardwired to conform to groups which keeps us safe and out of trouble. We are not inherently bad.