imp questions

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/4

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

5 Terms

1
New cards

What are crimes called where the prosecution doesn’t have to prove mens rea?

One line: Strict liability offences.

Why: The usual equation is actus reus + mens rea = liability. Strict liability takes mens rea out of the equation. The prosecution only has to prove that D did the act (p 13).

Example: Most driving offences.

Why the law allows it: These offences aim to prevent harm, not to punish moral wrongdoing. They’re seen as fair because they usually carry no social stigma and no prison sentence (p 13). A speeding ticket doesn’t brand you a criminal the way a theft conviction does.

Trap to avoid: Careless driving and gross negligence manslaughter are not strict liability. They do have a fault element (negligence). It just doesn’t require D to be aware they’re doing wrong. The scale is:

  • Intention/recklessness: D knew.

  • Negligence: D should have known.

  • Strict liability: whether D knew doesn’t matter.

Hook: “Strict” means the law is strict with you. It doesn’t care what was in your head.

2
New cards

D confesses but says it was under duress. Does D have to prove duress?

One line: No. D only has to raise some credible evidence of duress. Then the prosecution has to disprove it beyond reasonable doubt.

Why: Woolmington v DPP [1935] says the burden of proof is always on the prosecution, for every element and for disproving defences (p 14). The defence carries only a light evidential burden. It has to put forward enough evidence to make the defence worth taking seriously. That rule exists so court time isn’t wasted on far-fetched defences.

Two burdens to keep apart:

  • Evidential burden (on D): “Here’s some credible evidence I was threatened.”

  • Legal/persuasive burden (on the prosecution): “We’re sure, beyond reasonable doubt, that he wasn’t under duress.”

Hook: D only has to open the door. The prosecution has to close it.

For extra marks later: insanity is the well-known exception, where D does bear the burden. Chapter 2 doesn’t cover that, so check it when you reach the defences chapters.

3
New cards

The two types of defence, with examples

One line: Justifications (the act was right) and excuses (the act was wrong, but D isn’t to blame).


Justification

Excuse

What it says

“I did nothing wrong in these circumstances.”

“It was wrong, but it would be unfair to punish me.”

Focus

The act

The person

Example (from the guide)

Self-defence

Duress, insanity

The theory behind excuses: H.L.A. Hart said D lacked “the capacity or a fair opportunity to conform” to the law (p 13).

  • Insanity is about capacity: D’s mind couldn’t conform.

  • Duress is about fair opportunity: someone had a gun to D’s head.

Hook: Justification puts the Judgment on the act: it was fine. Excuse Excuses the person: we forgive you.

4
New cards

Dadson shot an escaped convict. It was at that time lawful to shoot an escaped convict. Why then was he found guilty of unlawful wounding?

Facts (accurately): Dadson was a constable guarding a wood. He shot a man who was running away with stolen wood. The man had earlier convictions for wood-stealing, which made this theft a felony, and shooting a fleeing felon was lawful at the time. Dadson didn’t know about the earlier convictions. (Your question calls him an “escaped convict”. The legal point is the same.)

One line: He was guilty because a defence needs both a good reason and for D to act because of that reason. Dadson had the reason without knowing it, so he didn’t act on it.

The principle (p 13): Defences sit outside the offence definition. To rely on one, “there must not only be a good reason for the accused acting as they do, but also the accused must act for that reason.”

Compare it with an offence element (the guide’s contrast, p 13): If A has sex with B believing B isn’t consenting, but B actually is, A is not guilty of rape. Lack of consent is part of the actus reus, so if it’s missing there’s no crime, whatever A thought. Justification doesn’t work that way. You can’t benefit from a justification you didn’t know existed.

Hook: You can’t be justified by luck.

For discussion marks (Activity 2.1 asks whether Dadson was right):

  • For the decision: Dadson meant to do something unlawful. Morally, he’s no different from a constable who shoots an innocent thief.

  • Against it: No harm was done that the law didn’t permit, since the victim could lawfully have been shot. Punishing Dadson punishes his bad mind alone.

That tension (should we punish bad intentions or bad outcomes?) comes back in the attempts chapter, so it’s worth noticing now.

5
New cards