1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Meyers argues that treating identity as either entirely socially constructed or entirely internally chosen (Young’s idea)…
creates a false dichotomy.
1st Opposing Position to Young: Gender Essentialism
There is an inherent, identifiable essence that determines what it means to be a woman or a man.
2nd Opposing Position to Young: Individualist Voluntarism
Individuals freely choose their identities; identity is fundamentally a matter of personal choice.
3rd Opposing Position to Young: Gendered/ Individualized Identities
Gender is simultaneously socially constructed and individually negotiated. We exercise some agency over our identities, but socialization influences us in ways we may not consciously recognize or be able to change.
Gender, as Meyers suggests, "worms its way into identity" through deeply embedded social expectations.
Subordinated Identities
Dimensions of individual identity that society places in inferior or disadvantaged positions.
Internalized Oppression
When individuals absorb oppressive social assumptions about themselves and reproduce those assumptions through their own attitudes and behavior.
Literary Interpretation
Rather than treating one theory as an absolute, exhaustive explanation of gender, we should recognize that different interpretations may illuminate different dimensions of human experience.
Counterstories
A narrative designed to challenge and resist oppressive stories imposed upon individuals or marginalized groups, replacing narratives of inferiority with narratives that affirm their dignity and command respect.
Control Condition
Concerns an individual's ability to act voluntarily and exercise agency over their own actions.
Nagel on the Control Condition
Examines control in relation to moral luck and whether individuals should be morally judged for circumstances beyond their control.
Nelson on the Control Condition
Uses the concept more narrowly in relation to moral identity and reclaiming one's sense of agency.
Normative Competence
The capacity to understand moral and social expectations and to recognize oneself and others as morally responsible agents.
Justice as Fairness
He argues that principles of justice should be established by free and rational individuals who are concerned with pursuing their own interests but are placed in an initial position of equality. Rawls wants to prevent these conflicts of interest by requiring principles of justice to be established under conditions of equality.
The Original Position
A hypothetical situation in which individuals come together to determine the principles of justice that will govern their society.
Veil of Ignorance
Behind it individuals do not know their own personal identities or circumstances.
Hobbes
The state of nature is a state of war.
Individuals view one another as potential threats.
Individuals view one another as potential threats.
Individuals surrender substantial freedom to establish political order.
His political outlook is comparatively bleak.
Rawls
The original position is a hypothetical situation of equality.
Individuals are rational and mutually disinterested.
The central problem is establishing fair principles of justice.
Individuals agree to principles that protect equal liberties and establish fair social arrangements.
His approach is comparatively optimistic.
Hobbes
Emphasizes the dangers of unrestricted freedom and the need for a powerful sovereign.
Rawls
Emphasizes how individuals can rationally agree upon fair principles of justice when they do not know what position they will occupy in society.
Rawls and Hobbes
Recognize the importance of agreements in establishing social order, but they approach the problem from substantially different perspectives.
Reflective Equilibrium
Describes a process in which principles and particular judgments are examined in relation to one another. Makes justice an ongoing process of examination, adjustment, and evaluation rather than something society establishes once and never questions again.
The First Principle of Justice: Equal Basic Liberties
The principle establishes that every individual should possess the greatest possible system of basic liberties, provided that everyone else can enjoy the same liberties.
The Second Principle of Justice: Social and Economic Inequalities
Rawls recognizes that social and economic inequalities will inevitably exist; that can only be acceptable under two conditions.
Condition One: The Difference Principle
It requires that inequalities be structured in a way that improves the position of the least advantaged.
Condition Two: Fair Equality of Opportunity
This means individuals should have a genuinely fair opportunity to obtain positions of employment, authority, and social status.