Democracy, bureaucracy, ILO

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/14

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

15 Terms

1
New cards

Weber: thoughts on bureaucracy for democracy?

2 positive effects (a)?

2 negative effects(a and b for each)?

Thought bureaucracy is both necessary for democracy and an impediment to it

1. Great Social Leveler: based on merit, not birth

a. Opposed to traditional/aristocratic power

2. Organizing Democracy: Organizations needed to make mass democracies function properly

a. Locations to vote, disseminating ballots, supervising elections, electoral lists, protecting

ballots, counting the votes

1. Based on different principles

a. Bureaucracy based on hierarchy and authority

b. Democracy based on equality

2. Dehumanizes people, limits participation

a. Iron Cage: people just follow rules, lack self- motivation and moral autonomy

b. Allows organizational elites to control politics

2
New cards

What are the two opposing perspectives of organizations in democracy?

1. Pluralism (Dahl): Democracy is possible because diverse interests are organized to pursue their interests, preventing any one from dominating and forcing compromise

a. Bureaucracy needed for organizing interests

2. Elite Theory: Theory arguing that elites dominate organizations

a. Bureaucracy is the basis of elite power and domination, prevents democracy

3
New cards

Michels: Iron law of oligarchy?

(Elite theory)

ILO: all complex organizations—no matter how democratic they are at the start—inevitably evolve into rule by a small, self-serving elite (an oligarchy)

Michels came up with the ILO through his participation in the German Social Democratic Party, which made him very disillusioned

4
New cards

6 causes of the ILO?

1. Bureaucracy provides rules and regulations that

enforce hierarchy (Weber)

2. Bureaucratic elites control the formal means of communication within the organization

3. Knowledge of rules

4. Leadership skills of elites

5. High status of organizational leaders

6. Lack of time and interest of non-elites

5
New cards

C Wright Mills: what type of sociologist?

What is his main contribution about problems (2 components)?

He is a critical sociologist, who wanted to highlight problems in hopes of correcting them

He wants to highlight how many problems are social rather than individual

Individual Problem: A problem caused by individual characteristics/choices/actions

Social Problem: A problem that individuals suffer but that is promoted by the social environment

6
New cards

How did Mills view social problems in his time?

... what does this result in?

He believed social problems were increasing although there was a simultaneous growing societal adoption of ideas of individualism

Promotes angst. We blame the problems on ourselves or deflect them to blame others

7
New cards

What is the social imagination?

What 3 things does it consider the interplay between?

This is the title of a book Mills wrote

It also is a concept that describes the ability to connect seemingly impersonal and remote historical/social forces to the incidents of an individual's life

1. History: how a society came to be, major historical forces that created it

2. Social Structure: how the various institutional orders in a society operate, which ones are dominant, how they function

3. Biography: particular individual characteristics

8
New cards

How does Mills handle the interplay between social structures and agency?

Our actions make up society, shape history, which is an example of agency

Sociological Imagination: Believes one's agency depends on history, social structure, and biography

Ex: Trump and Bezos have extreme agency

9
New cards

How did Mills see organizations?

Comparison with Michels?

Michels explains how elites dominate organizations; Mills explains how organizational elites dominate society.

Michels argued that organizations concentrate power in the hands of leaders, allowing a small group to dominate ordinary members. Mills focused on society as a whole, arguing that as society increasingly depends on large organizations, the elites at the top of major institutions (such as government, the military, and corporations) gain power over society

10
New cards

Mills: What are the 3 main types of elites?

1. Corporate Chieftains: CEOs of major corporations

2. Political Directorate: Officials who command the state hierarchies

3. Warlords: Military Generals

11
New cards

What are the three components of the power elites and what is their outcome?

1. Status Community: go to same schools, have same friendship networks, have same elite outlooks

2. Interdependence: all three segments of the elite interact with and depend on one another

3. Transferability: elites from one segment can become elites of another segment

Outcome: Cohesive elite community, able to look out for elite interests

12
New cards

How did Mills view democracy?

History (but!)?

Argued that people thought they controlled government, when it reality, it was the power elites that ran it for elite interests

Mills thought that his

argument was only relevant for the US in the 1950s

BUT that organisations will dominate in organizational societies

13
New cards

Porter's vertical mosaic?

(Draws on who + 4 factors? What type of focus + what conclusion?)

Draws on Mills and analyses who controls Canada's most powerful organizations, looking at economic, bureaucratic, political, and ideological factors.

Ethnic focus: argued against the claim that all communities in Canada experience equal treatment. Instead he claimed that the Canadian mosaic was stratified/vertical. Members of certain communities almost exclusively held power of others

14
New cards

In contrast to the elite theory what does pluralist theory argue about interests?

Main contributor to this view?

Suggests that power is diffuse and that all people organize to pursue their interests in politics

Tocqueville influenced this view, arguing that diverse organizations prevents any one group from dominating

15
New cards

How do Dahl and Useem respond to Mills' view of democracy?

Dahl: Studied politics in New haven and found that there were many dif. actors pursing different interests. Concluded that there was no power elite and