1/19
Jury decision making
Jury selection
•12 people randomly selected from those “summonsed”
•Usually for 2 weeks
•1/6 chance serving during lifetime
•Aged 18-75 years old
•Registered on Electoral Register
•UK resident > 5 years
Jury excusal
Timing / unreasonable
•Can ask for jury service to be deferred (once) to another time w/n 12 months.
•Can apply for complete excusal – with evidence
Previous Jury Service
•cannot be made to sit on a jury more than once w/n the span of 2 years → you have the right to be excused, if you wish.
are jury’s representative?
Criteria-defined pool & randomness don’t guarantee a representative jury
1/3 those called not available
Females & ethnic minorities under-represented in E&W juries
mathematical models
–Individual decision making
•Bayesian; weighted average; stochastic Poisson
–Group shifts in jury preference distribution
•Social Decision Scheme (SDS)
cognitive models
–“Story” model (Pennington & Hastie, 1986) widely adopted as useful & relating to subj experience
Jurors actively formulate plausible offence account(s) from emerging trial info + own experiences/expectations
story model: construction stage
•Coverage = degree to which story accounts for the evidence presented at the trial.
•Coherence = degree to which story is consistent, plausible and complete
•Uniqueness = determines the confidence a juror has in the story.
story model: Verdict representation stage
–Alternative verdict decisions based on e.g. details of crime, defendant’s mental state
story model: Classification stage
–Involves consideration of instructions from judge and matching chosen story with verdict decisions.
–Goodness of fit (to what extent does the chosen story match the guilty and non-guilty verdicts?)
do jurors understand evidence of judge’s instructions well?
NO (Tinsley 2001):
–Generally oral with few written or visual aids
–Evidence often muddled or sequenced illogically
–Questioning by barristers poor/difficult to follow
–Legal jargon & concepts difficult
–Judge’s instructions only received at end of evidence giving process (days/weeks)
solutions for juror understanding (Penrod & Heuer, 1997)
–Rewrite and standardise the judge’s instructions.
–Allow jurors to take notes to help remember details
–Allow jurors to ask Q’s to clarify issues
–Provide instructions early to ensure compliance
Jury size & decision rule
•E&W=12, Scotland=15, Brazil=7, Norway= 10
•Deliberations longer with larger juries & with unanimous decision rule
•“Hung” jury (don’t come to a decision) more likely with large jury and with unanimous requirement
•Neither size of jury nor decision rule influence verdict decision, but unanimity does affect confidence in decision
Deliberation
Early decisions
–Most jurors have already decided on a verdict before deliberation.
–1st ballot majority verdict preferences predict final verdict.
–In 9/10 juries, deliberation is about convincing the minority to agree with the verdict of the majority.
Group discussion
–Reinforces majority opinion
–Can intensify existing biases (i.e. group polarisation) or attenuate them or have little impact
common characteristics of foreperson (elected by jury i.e. lead jury)
•Male
•Older
•Better educated
•Extraversion
•Seated at end of a jury table
•Higher social status
•Experienced in jury service
•One of the first jurors to speak
•Likely to participate more than others
•When foreperson regarded as weak, hung jury more likely
Voir Dire
•In US, allow deselection of potential jurors by lawyers’ questioning to influence jury make-up
•UK abolished its version of VD in 1988
Defendant race
•White jurors rated black defendant as signif more violent and aggressive than white
•White jurors more likely to convict black defendant - but only when evidence weak
•When evidence weak, jurors of similar race more lenient
•More guilty verdicts for racial out-group members
•No sig. diff. in actual Crown Court verdicts by defendant ethnicity
Defendent gender
•cases in which a child had been killed by a parent: females sig. more likely to be convicted of manslaughter (lesser form of homicide)than murder
•Higher guilt ratings for a male vs female defendant in a student/ teacher sexual assault case (seen worse if teacher is male)
• +ve views/less guilt more feminine defendants, even if male (more lenient for women)
•Chivalry? +ve stereotypes? Abnormal behaviour - ‘Mad not Bad’?
•But also similarity bias: Juries composed mostly of women more likely convict male defendant in rape case
Judge
•Blanck (1985): more likely to be found guilty if the trial judge was rated as less dogmatic, less wise, less dominant and less professional.
•Judicial comments may reveal biases (eg.victim blaming in rape cases)→ judge meant to be impartial
•Judiciary in E+ W ‘institutionally racist’; just 1% judiciary are black
Barrister/ attorney
•Higher acquittal rate when defence attorney was male
•Aggressive attorneys were more successful at obtaining an acquittal for their clients than passive attorneys
•Narrative opening statement + legal exposition closing more effective
arguments for keeping the jury system: (Kapardis, 2010)
•‘12 heads better than 1’
•Individualises administration of justice
•Can ignore judge’s direction
•Counters interests of judge
•Decision made by one’s peers
•Important civic experience
•Jurors provide fresh perspective
•Interpreters of trial info
•Catalysts for legal reform (changing rules)
arguments against keeping the jury system: (Kapardis, 2010)
•Secrecy
•Task not for amateurs
•Not accountable
•Can’t remember all the facts
•Interference (Bribery/ intimidation)
•Traumatic experience
•Acquit too readily
•Costly/Time-consuming
•Conceal info about themselves (about jurors)
•Decision-making clouded by irrelevant factors.